Page 1 of 11

U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 10:07 pm
by giffo
What clubs will be fielding u18's this year? Lockleys is in the process of re-establishing it's u18's team and if anyone is looking for a game please get in touch with me for me info.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 12:49 pm
by S Demon
giffo wrote:What clubs will be fielding u18's this year? Lockleys is in the process of re-establishing it's u18's team and if anyone is looking for a game please get in touch with me for me info.


Hope Valley have U/18's for the 3rd year in a row after not having them for a few years. 4-5 will get a taste of senior footy too by the look of them. I'm not sure if their trial games are already locked in or not. Demon Juke would know more..

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 12:54 pm
by schimma
Smosh has a squad of 30 training at the moment. solid numbers looking at a good year.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 12:57 pm
by piccachu
Smosh has a squad of 30 training at the moment. solid numbers looking at a good year.



Sh!t, Sounds like Smosh will be a force this year. we also have 18s this year, we have seena bout 16 of our lads out at training very spazmoticly, a few have baseball and other sports that are holding them back from getting out to training,

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 1:01 pm
by Muffler
We are trying for 18's after about 4 to 5 years off.
First training monday so hoping for a few blokes.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 12:00 pm
by old school 2010
ingle farm will again have a 18s

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 1:53 pm
by The Dark Knight
We put in for an Under 18s side again this year, we do have a fair few under 18s training but I'm unsure if we will have an Under 18s side.

As for the competetion as a whole, form what I've seen the last two years, playing in and watching the under 18s competition, 2009 and 2010 have been an a big mess, the management of the competition should of been better than what it has been.

We made the grand final in 2008 and in that year IMO, the competition was strong, every side had plenty of numbers playing and it was an enjoyable competition to play in and be a part of. I remember in 2007 watching our under 18s playing after us in the 16s and the competition then was very good.

But in the last two seasons, the competition level has dropped and many clubs have lost they're under 18 sides because of a lack of numbers and IMO it seems like less and less time is being put into developing and managing the under 18s competitions.

I hope the SAAFL can look at the Under 18s competition to see how they can improve it and manage it better so players moving from junior footy to senior footy can have a smooth transition so they won't be caught in between, which has happened to alot of younger players of the last couple of years and so the competition stays strong and doesn't fall to bits.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 9:34 pm
by giffo
schimma wrote:Smosh has a squad of 30 training at the moment. solid numbers looking at a good year.

Any chance of sending some our way ;) .

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 9:36 pm
by Pag
Salisbury will have Under 18s after not having enough numbers last year. Most of the boys will be genuine Under 17s but they should be competitive.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 9:55 pm
by old school 2010
pag- yeh someone from salisbury csalled me tonight about a trial vs ingle farm

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 18, 2011 12:53 pm
by old school 2010
can anyone tell me the teams for the under 18s please

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 18, 2011 12:54 pm
by Pag
old school 2010 wrote:can anyone tell me the teams for the under 18s please

They're not up yet mate.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 4:02 pm
by old school 2010
INGLE FARM 18S DESPERATELY LOOKING FOR TRIAL GAMES IN MARCH
also need an oval with lights for fri 18th march if vs salisbury if anyone can help please let me know cheers

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 10:37 pm
by watchdog
old school 2010 wrote:INGLE FARM 18S DESPERATELY LOOKING FOR TRIAL GAMES IN MARCH
also need an oval with lights for fri 18th march if vs salisbury if anyone can help please let me know cheers


Try pt districts u18. The coach rang me today asking if I knew of anyone looking for a trial

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 10:45 pm
by NO-MERCY
Does anyone know if Seaton have an U/18s this year?

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Feb 24, 2011 11:12 pm
by old school 2010
watchdog -do you have any contact details for port districts thanks

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 9:21 am
by Sass!
Modbury have had about 10-20 under 18's attend 80% of our preseason training. Extremely pleasing to see, few of them will certainly get games in our Div 7 & 7R sides this year. Even a couple that could slot nicely into the Div 2R side.

Think our 18's will be a stronger outfit than last year as a majority are now playing there second year in there and a large number have senior games experience.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 9:31 am
by piccachu
Modbury have had about 10-20 under 18's attend 80% of our preseason training. Extremely pleasing to see, few of them will certainly get games in our Div 7 & 7R sides this year. Even a couple that could slot nicely into the Div 2R side.

Think our 18's will be a stronger outfit than last year as a majority are now playing there second year in there and a large number have senior games experience.


Interesting to read the part i have highlighted in bold. at Our club we have a rule in place that no U/18 is to be selcted in the C grade.
if they are good enough to be picked in the As or Bs they will be, but it is our feeling that The kids will not learn good habbits playing at this levell and may hinder there development being constantly bashed around by fully grown men. not saying either club is right or wrong with what there doing and people please dont take this as me haveing a crack at the C grade im just curious to see if any other clubs feel the same way

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 9:42 am
by Footy Smart
piccachu wrote:
Modbury have had about 10-20 under 18's attend 80% of our preseason training. Extremely pleasing to see, few of them will certainly get games in our Div 7 & 7R sides this year. Even a couple that could slot nicely into the Div 2R side.

Think our 18's will be a stronger outfit than last year as a majority are now playing there second year in there and a large number have senior games experience.


Interesting to read the part i have highlighted in bold. at Our club we have a rule in place that no U/18 is to be selcted in the C grade.
if they are good enough to be picked in the As or Bs they will be, but it is our feeling that The kids will not learn good habbits playing at this levell and may hinder there development being constantly bashed around by fully grown men. not saying either club is right or wrong with what there doing and people please dont take this as me haveing a crack at the C grade im just curious to see if any other clubs feel the same way


Yeah its a theory that has pros and cons IMO. Running 4 senior sides it can also mean a matter of numbers, however with our C grade being in Div 7 they are still playing a reasonable level. If we were in C3 and C6 i would also suggest they dont play that grade over 18s. They can also get 'bashed around by fully grown men' but our lads can handle it and they wont be asked to play if they arent up to it. Must choose the right 18s to play against the men.

At MFC this year will have a strong focus on our junior developement through the Ressies hopefully find a few that are capable of playing A grade this year or next. A few have improved greatly over the pre season already which is a great sign.

Re: U18's competition-the future of our game

PostPosted: Thu Mar 17, 2011 8:19 pm
by giffo
old school 2010 wrote:can anyone tell me the teams for the under 18s please

Red- Eastern Park, Hope Valley, Golden Grove, Modbury, Pooraka, Salisbury, Salisbury North, Salisbury West, Elizabeth. Blue- Broadview, Ingle Farm, Gepps Cross, North Haven, Seaton, Port District, Portland, SMOSH-West Lakes. Yellow- Flinders Park, Kennilworth, PHOS Camden, Plympton, Lockleys, Mitcham, Goodwood Saints, Henley.