SA Footy

Why couldn't the GSFL have it and SFL not? or too hard for umpires who do both comps? Surely it wouldn't be too hard to adapt?

My experience from when it was first brought in at the 18s level at SANFL in 2016

RD 1 WTF????

RD 4 Did we have any today? Didn't notice it.

am Bays wrote:My experience from when it was first brought in at the 18s level at SANFL in 2016

RD 1 WTF????

RD 4 Did we have any today? Didn't notice it.

Exactly players know the rule now and have adjusted their tactics accordingly.....non issue in my book.

I watch the AFL and the amount of inconsistency at that level concerns me .

But aren't you talking about the deliberate out of bounds interpretation used in the AFL Shoe Boy?

What the SFL/GSFL are bringing in is the "last touch out of bounds free kick to opposition" rule as used by the SANFL. So it takes deliberate or not deliberate out of the equation. This may finally send Peachy into retirement because some of his touch finding mongrel floaters will now come at a cost.

I watch about as much SANFL footy as I do Water Polo so is the last touch rule only from a kick. What happens in the case of an errant handball, spoil, or player in possession getting pressured over the boundary line. Is that still a throw in?

Less throw ins from 13 - 15 year old panel boundary umpires should at least make you happier Shoe Boy.

It's last clear disposal over the line

kick, handball, errant kick or handball ball that takes a "un-kind" bounce and crosses the boundary line the opposition team gets possession.

If it's touched, "fumbled" accidentally knocked over the line it's a throw in.

SFL AGM ,we watched a video and the rules where very inconsistent .

This example is a free kick this is not !!! WTF didn't notice a lot of difference .

Rubbish rule. It’s not under 8’s

Give it a couple of years and you won't need to worry about the SFL implementing anything.

Happy Valley throwing the money around!!!! Hughes on $800 a game.

They would have plenty up their sleeve after Lawry retired.

Notice Happy Valley have heaps off juniors heading to SANFL Junior comp ... whats the go there

Broken Down Hack wrote:Notice Happy Valley have heaps off juniors heading to SANFL Junior comp ... whats the go there

They're all junior girls. Moving to a league where they can get better competition against more teams. At this stage the SFL can't facilitate that. Nothing sinister, just symptomatic of the early days of the girl's/women's comp.

Boring as bat shit on here, any news on numbers out at pre Xmas pre-season from clubs?
Many started?

Flies getting 30-40 out for - 17's B and A grade combined.


Other Topics;

Murdock making ANY friends at Emus?

Flaggys strong again couple of recruits on radar apparently, they will be the hunted again in 2018.

Noarlunga - Rumors of Separations between B and A grade groups still lingers ..... Comer coaching B's in 2018 shoe boy??

Cove have had quite a few players return from country footy, up to 10 new recruits signed with 6 or 7 very solid A graders amongst them.

Aldinga going ok? O'hanlon Flintham Boreham all on the move, will leave a bit of a hole in Sharks midfield.

Valleys Surely not going to keep preaching "playing kids " had 3-4 years with same group. New Coach paying his nephew recruit big bucks.... doesn't end well normally if true.

Porties Not much on radar laying low after semi final f#*k up.

Christies - Picked up a few Hodge will help , will he train though

jet-airport wrote:Boring as bat shit on here, any news on numbers out at pre Xmas pre-season from clubs?
Many started?

Flies getting 30-40 out for - 17's B and A grade combined.


Other Topics;

Murdock making ANY friends at Emus?

Flaggys strong again couple of recruits on radar apparently, they will be the hunted again in 2018.

[b]Noarlunga - Rumors of Separations between B and A grade groups still lingers ..... Comer coaching B's in 2018 shoe boy??

Jet-airport One of the strengths of the footy club is the strong bond between 17.5 to A grade possibly due to the fact Bazz has them all training together as one with the exception on Thursday night the lads break into their grades for the last hour .

I will add most of the lads have played since minis and form a strong bond off field as their partners are also close friends .

The executive and football department are currently working through coaching roles within the whole of the Footy club .

Should be a politician SB!

Flaggys don't start pre-season until the new year, Sam T back from injury will be a massive boost for the back line.

Dutchy wrote:Should be a politician SB!

Flaggys don't start pre-season until the new year, Sam T back from injury will be a massive boost for the back line.

Haha He should be Dutchy

Reading between the political statement, could we see the premiership winning B grade coach from 2017 not required for 2018 Shoe Boy?

jet-airport wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Should be a politician SB!

Flaggys don't start pre-season until the new year, Sam T back from injury will be a massive boost for the back line.

Haha He should be Dutchy

Reading between the political statement, could we see the premiership winning B grade coach from 2017 not required for 2018 Shoe Boy?

Heard the same plus the rumour is B grade coach was asked to retract their application

jet-airport wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Should be a politician SB!

Flaggys don't start pre-season until the new year, Sam T back from injury will be a massive boost for the back line.

Haha He should be Dutchy

Reading between the political statement, could we see the premiership winning B grade coach from 2017 not required for 2018 Shoe Boy?

Shane is part of the executive team in his role as V President and once all coaching roles are finalised I will post.

How many clubs are still trying to fill coaching positions? Surely clubs would want this sorted before Xmas.