bosshogg wrote:Can someone pm me with what sfl spy said please, the bloke sounds like a goose...
Something about Biglands should be playing association. A very foolish remark and lucky to only escape with 14 days.
by Swooper16 » Tue Jul 22, 2008 10:15 am
bosshogg wrote:Can someone pm me with what sfl spy said please, the bloke sounds like a goose...
by Swooper16 » Tue Jul 22, 2008 12:11 pm
cyclops wrote:Sorry tatts i disagree.I believe the B grade has become so boring now its not funny.I think one day the B grade comp will replace the c grade on a sunday and that the u-18s should and eventually will become curtain raser to the A grade.
by bass_player » Tue Jul 22, 2008 12:49 pm
Swooper16 wrote:cyclops wrote:Sorry tatts i disagree.I believe the B grade has become so boring now its not funny.I think one day the B grade comp will replace the c grade on a sunday and that the u-18s should and eventually will become curtain raser to the A grade.
I see your point in that successful junior programs and A grade flags are what its all about and in the end B grade premierships dont mean much to anyone other that those that are involved in them however i still think you are way off the mark.
When was the last time a club with a weak B grade won an A grade premiership? You neednt look any further then the Emus third premiership of their current 4 to see how important depth in a club is. Aaron hill & ritter both go down with serious injuries in the prelim. Losing players of this quality would usually spell the end of your premiership hopes but we were able to call on Coletti and N Bayly (from memory) who were more then good enough to step up. If we didnt have such a strong B grade to call upon do you think we still would have won if we called up 2 C graders who probably train twice a year?
Also taking away the B grade you will find that many u/18s will be exposed to play at a standard they not yet ready for.
As a wise man* once told me "The B grade are the mortar that hold the bricks together"
* The Mexican
by The Mexican » Tue Jul 22, 2008 1:24 pm
bass_player wrote:Swooper16 wrote:cyclops wrote:Sorry tatts i disagree.I believe the B grade has become so boring now its not funny.I think one day the B grade comp will replace the c grade on a sunday and that the u-18s should and eventually will become curtain raser to the A grade.
I see your point in that successful junior programs and A grade flags are what its all about and in the end B grade premierships dont mean much to anyone other that those that are involved in them however i still think you are way off the mark.
When was the last time a club with a weak B grade won an A grade premiership? You neednt look any further then the Emus third premiership of their current 4 to see how important depth in a club is. Aaron hill & ritter both go down with serious injuries in the prelim. Losing players of this quality would usually spell the end of your premiership hopes but we were able to call on Coletti and N Bayly (from memory) who were more then good enough to step up. If we didnt have such a strong B grade to call upon do you think we still would have won if we called up 2 C graders who probably train twice a year?
Also taking away the B grade you will find that many u/18s will be exposed to play at a standard they not yet ready for.
As a wise man* once told me "The B grade are the mortar that hold the bricks together"
* The Mexican
Disco (I still don't know why you guys call him that) and Bayly were very fortunate to have a premiership medal around their necks considering the B's lost
by The Dutchman » Tue Jul 22, 2008 1:25 pm
by shoe boy » Tue Jul 22, 2008 1:46 pm
The Dutchman wrote:I think poor old Cyclops raises some good points about the lack of depth in the comp though boys...he could just say it better![]()
While Morphies is strong and half of their B grade can push for an A grade spot, some clubs are forced to play blokes who dont train, weigh over 100kg and are over 40yrs old. Some B grade teams dont trouble the scorers too often.
The percentage of players from an U/18 team who are likely to play A grade would be higher than the percentage of B grade players at most clubs i suspect.
I dont see the point in playing bigger bodies who will have less of an A grade future at a club. And holding kids back only creates a bigger hole to fill once the older blokes finally retire, which sends a club further downhill.
Do you think the Emus would be where they are today if they didnt give their kids a go? Exposing kids to a higher standard, instead of holding them back will only benefit a footy club in the long run.
So there might be some merit in promoting the U/18 comp a bit more which would improve the depth of the comp.
Is that what you were getting at Cyclops?
by rodney fox » Tue Jul 22, 2008 2:03 pm
by Swooper16 » Tue Jul 22, 2008 2:10 pm
The Dutchman wrote:I think poor old Cyclops raises some good points about the lack of depth in the comp though boys...he could just say it better![]()
While Morphies is strong and half of their B grade can push for an A grade spot, some clubs are forced to play blokes who dont train, weigh over 100kg and are over 40yrs old. Some B grade teams dont trouble the scorers too often.
The percentage of players from an U/18 team who are likely to play A grade would be higher than the percentage of B grade players at most clubs i suspect.
I dont see the point in playing bigger bodies who will have less of an A grade future at a club. And holding kids back only creates a bigger hole to fill once the older blokes finally retire, which sends a club further downhill.
Do you think the Emus would be where they are today if they didnt give their kids a go? Exposing kids to a higher standard, instead of holding them back will only benefit a footy club in the long run.
So there might be some merit in promoting the U/18 comp a bit more which would improve the depth of the comp.
Is that what you were getting at Cyclops?
by The Mexican » Tue Jul 22, 2008 2:10 pm
rodney fox wrote:What are the games this week?
We have Christies at home should be an interesting game. What are they travelling like lovetotalkfooty?
How's Mckee been fairing lately, I hear a few of the boys aren't very impressed with what he's been doing, any truth?
by rodney fox » Tue Jul 22, 2008 2:14 pm
The Mexican wrote:rodney fox wrote:What are the games this week?
We have Christies at home should be an interesting game. What are they travelling like lovetotalkfooty?
How's Mckee been fairing lately, I hear a few of the boys aren't very impressed with what he's been doing, any truth?
Reynella at home on Sunday Rodney, should be a cracker with a sizable crowd once again, bring Shrivery down for a look, would be good to catch up again... Beware Tony doesn't come into your changerooms after the game, i know it's after sign on date but you never know where he may be next year...
by The Dutchman » Tue Jul 22, 2008 2:31 pm
by Fair Play » Tue Jul 22, 2008 2:44 pm
rodney fox wrote:What are the games this week?
We have Christies at home should be an interesting game. What are they travelling like lovetotalkfooty?
How's Mckee been fairing lately, I hear a few of the boys aren't very impressed with what he's been doing, any truth?
by a2m » Tue Jul 22, 2008 4:43 pm
by Hills » Tue Jul 22, 2008 4:53 pm
bosshogg wrote:Now cmon guys leave mckee alone, it's not his fault he hasn't played any higher than div 3, I'm sure he would be a star in a div 7 comp or something, and as for meekins my services are up for a price next season, just pay me double what mckee is getting I have been a star since I was 5 ask my brother he got drafted because they thought he was me...
by Fair Play » Tue Jul 22, 2008 4:56 pm
Hills wrote:bosshogg wrote:Now cmon guys leave mckee alone, it's not his fault he hasn't played any higher than div 3, I'm sure he would be a star in a div 7 comp or something, and as for meekins my services are up for a price next season, just pay me double what mckee is getting I have been a star since I was 5 ask my brother he got drafted because they thought he was me...
Bosshog do you get off by pumping yourself up?
Your a tool!
by Hills » Tue Jul 22, 2008 5:03 pm
Fair Play wrote:Hills wrote:bosshogg wrote:Now cmon guys leave mckee alone, it's not his fault he hasn't played any higher than div 3, I'm sure he would be a star in a div 7 comp or something, and as for meekins my services are up for a price next season, just pay me double what mckee is getting I have been a star since I was 5 ask my brother he got drafted because they thought he was me...
Bosshog do you get off by pumping yourself up?
Your a tool!
Hills Knowing A.B personally I know he would not talk himself up like this and believe he is being targetted by someone else.
by lovetotalkfooty » Tue Jul 22, 2008 5:30 pm
Fair Play wrote:rodney fox wrote:What are the games this week?
We have Christies at home should be an interesting game. What are they travelling like lovetotalkfooty?
How's Mckee been fairing lately, I hear a few of the boys aren't very impressed with what he's been doing, any truth?
Agree that Rhino probably hasn't been fantastic and this week will be big for the both of your clubs. In his defence it is hard to be a star when you weigh in around 160kgs
by a2m » Tue Jul 22, 2008 5:50 pm
by efc » Thu Jul 24, 2008 11:54 am
by Zelezny Chucks » Thu Jul 24, 2008 12:55 pm
efc wrote:Who is the SFL side looking at joining the Hills Football league next season. Believe it might be the country division
Football
Other Footy Leagues
SFL
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |

