SA Footy

Posted: **Tue Dec 13, 2011 2:44 pm**

I reckon Nickelback did it with Curb

Posted: **Tue Dec 13, 2011 5:09 pm**

CK wrote:Rather than open a new thread with a similar topic, have bumped this one.

Which acts, in your opinion, have NEVER "jumped the shark" musically? Acts that were still producing great music at the end as well as the beginning.

The one that triggered this just appeared on the MP3 here - Talking Heads. "Naked" was a great final album from them, and their previous album, "True Stories" had a couple of corkers on it.

(in one of life's coincidences, the original topic of this thread just appeared next on the MP3 - U2, with "Angel Of Harlem")

Hunters and Collectors were still producing great music at the end, and I can't pinpoint an album where I thought, yep, that's it from them.

I don't know that H&C ever jumped the shark but they lost me personally after Human Fraility. My wife was a big fan from the early days and kept going to see them live right up til the final gig but I balied long before that.
Again maybe not jumping the shark per say but Talking Heads lost me when they went to EMI (Little Creatures).

Posted: **Tue Dec 13, 2011 9:55 pm**

A little band called The Beatles........

Some will argue with Let it Be (1970)......but I can live with that if that's the worst of it :lol:

Posted: **Tue Dec 13, 2011 10:50 pm**

Leaping Lindner wrote:I don't know that H&C ever jumped the shark but they lost me personally after Human Fraility.

No, H&C certainly jumped the shark right after Human Frailty. Prior to this H&C released groundbreaking avant-garde art-rock music. Everything since Human Frailty was pub-jukebox bogan-rock music.

Posted: **Wed Dec 14, 2011 6:01 am**

KRS has never jumped the shark.

He's just been making the same album for the past twenty years...

Posted: **Wed Dec 14, 2011 7:39 am**

Pseudo wrote:
Leaping Lindner wrote:I don't know that H&C ever jumped the shark but they lost me personally after Human Fraility.

No, H&C certainly jumped the shark right after Human Frailty. Prior to this H&C released groundbreaking avant-garde art-rock music. Everything since Human Frailty was pub-jukebox bogan-rock music.

Funny, I pulled out a couple of their albums the other day - first time in a LONG time. Agree with LL and Pseudo though What's A Few Men and Ghost Nation still had a few strong moments. At the time I considered they jumped the shark with 'Cut' - a 92 album which came out at a time that every dinosaur rawk band from the 80s - in the wake of Achtung Baby (sorry to mention it again) - seemed to be discovering samples and sequencers

Posted: **Wed Dec 14, 2011 11:37 am**

CK wrote:Rather than open a new thread with a similar topic, have bumped this one.

Which acts, in your opinion, have NEVER "jumped the shark" musically? Acts that were still producing great music at the end as well as the beginning.

The one that triggered this just appeared on the MP3 here - Talking Heads. "Naked" was a great final album from them, and their previous album, "True Stories" had a couple of corkers on it.

(in one of life's coincidences, the original topic of this thread just appeared next on the MP3 - U2, with "Angel Of Harlem")

Hunters and Collectors were still producing great music at the end, and I can't pinpoint an album where I thought, yep, that's it from them.

Taylor Swift.

But she did only turn 22 yesterday. :lol:

Posted: **Wed Dec 14, 2011 11:33 pm**

overloaded wrote:I reckon Nickelback did it with Curb

I reckon they did it the moment they formed.

Posted: **Thu Dec 15, 2011 7:37 am**

Barto wrote:
overloaded wrote:I reckon Nickelback did it with Curb

I reckon they did it the moment they formed.

I cannot stand them on any level. Any band that writes about "I like your pants around your feet" and then, in a future song, namechecks Cheech and Chong to sound "hip" doesn't cut it IMHO.

Posted: **Thu Dec 15, 2011 8:02 am**

Nickleback - Leading the way for all "Cock rock" bands of the future.

Posted: **Thu Dec 15, 2011 8:20 am**

Always hated NIckleback but now some of their lyrics have been put on here I'm starting to warm to them!

Still not as good as the US country hit "She thinks my tractor's sexy" though! :lol:

SA Footy

Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark

Re: Musically Jumping The Shark