North's players from Spell_check's list

[spell_check]

Dudley Hill

[Ian]

710-

[Adelaide Hawk]

One name from the 1951 GF:

A Souter

[Leaping Lindner]

K.Burns = Ken
G.Foulis = George
H.Hardwick = No record
P.McNamara = Thomas Pervical
R.May = Alfred Ronald
A.Mangelsdorf = No Record
G.Storer = Garfield
R.Taylor = Robert
R.Taylor = Ronald
L.Tuckey = Len

Two Missing "Zeds"

Cecil Zeugofage
Robert Zeven

[Leaping Lindner]

One name from the 1951 GF:

A Souter

A = Alec

(PS - Welcome aboard Adelaide Hawk! )

[Leaping Lindner]

A
F Alexander = Fred
OLIVER ARBON = Maurie (already listed)
John Ashurst
Geoff Askin
Don Atkinson
John Ashby = Should this be Graham (player from the 60's?)

[spell_check]

Two "is that the same player" questions:

Robert Taylor - West?
Ronald Taylor - Torrens and South?

[Ian]

7 added, 1 removed, and 10 new/corrected 1st names total now 716



Should these 2 be removed?

H.Hardwick = No record
A.Mangelsdorf = No Record

Ive changed that one, Leaping Lindner would have more idea than most people I know, if John should be on the list as well, someone let me know

John Ashby = Should this be Graham (player from the 60's?)

[spell_check]

A Mangelsdorf could be Herbert, who is on the list.

[Leaping Lindner]

B

Corrections -
H. Beaton (only have record of one Beaton playing for North - Arthur - already listed)
KENNETH BOWDEN (should this be Keith Edgar ???)

Newies

David Barraclough
Richard Boyley
Malcolm Bradshaw

Also a couple if we are including early players (pre 1907)

Arthur Brown (Medindie and North) (1888-1898)
Herbert Brown (Medindie and North) (1888-1898)
Jim Beasley (North's first interstate rep - 1894)

[Leaping Lindner]

Two "is that the same player" questions:

Robert Taylor - West?
Ronald Taylor - Torrens and South?

Not sure spelly
Robert (middle initial B) played 1962,1964-1969
Ronald (middle initial J) played one game in 1945 (also played 6 games with Norwood-North)
If that's a help.

[Leaping Lindner]

C
ALEXANDER CAMERON (I think this is Newton Alexander)
John Crow (spelt Crowe)

Newbies

Sydney Clarke
Cecil Cockshell
David Cole (1910's)
David Cole (1980's)
Darcy Coleman
Terry Collins
David Crawford
William Crowe
Fred Curnow

[Leaping Lindner]

D

Leonard Dangerfield (Norwood-North only)
Leonard Daniel
Ivan Davey
Clem Dayman
Howard Dayman
Barry Dew
Gustave Dewell
Robert Dilliway
Herbert Dillon
Gary Disher
George Donnisthrorpe
Percy Doyle
Rudolph Drabsch
Willis Draper
Charles Drew
Vernon Drew
Cyril Duberal
Percy Dunn

[spell_check]

Two "is that the same player" questions:

Robert Taylor - West?
Ronald Taylor - Torrens and South?

Not sure spelly
Robert (middle initial B) played 1962,1964-1969
Ronald (middle initial J) played one game in 1945 (also played 6 games with Norwood-North)
If that's a help.

It does, because in my Magarey Medal votes, Ron Taylor polled votes for Torrens in 1984 and 1985, so he's different.

If anyone has a copy of Bloods Sweat and Tars, it could be established when Robert Taylor played for West.

[Leaping Lindner]

E

Jack Earl
Thomas Earl
Keith Eatts
Barry Edwards
Brian Edwards
Harold Effick
George Elliott
Russell Elliott
Ken Errington
Alec Ewers

(pre-1907)
Joseph Earl
Stanley Eaton
Edward Ewers

[Leaping Lindner]

F

Ray Farrant
Graeme Farrell
Norm Ferguson
Harry Ferris
John Filmer
Percy Fleet
Albert Fooks
Percy Frost
Charles Fullarton
Harry Furber
Brian Furler
Jack Furness
Norm Fuss
Russell Fuss

[spell_check]

I've been chewing over the pre-1907 players quite a bit. I have included some prominent players in the lists at the moment. I'm not sure how accurate the records are back then, so I was thinking I could have a separate thread for the players who exclusively played before 1907. What do you think? (And I pose this question to everyone else).

There are a few more "Same as" questons I would like to ask, too:

David Crawford - Norwood (1913-15)
William Crowe - Norwood (1909-10)
Frederick Curnow - South
There is a Leonard Dangerfield for Glenelg, too.
Clem Dayman - Port

[Leaping Lindner]

G

Trevor Graham
Leslie Gregory
Alex Greve
Victor Griggs
Lance Gum
Andrew Gunn

[spell_check]

And some more Q's:

Charles Drew - Glenelg
Brian Edwards - Glenelg

[spell_check]

Leaping, this is another question I asked to Legs11 on the Norwood thread about WW2 players, and included is his reply. What is your opinion on this?


5.
Robert Jervis
Robert Bertram
William Jordon

I have a theory in why these names aren't in The Men of Norwood. Because of the pairing of the teams in 1942-44, players are credited with games played for whatever pair they played for. But I have read that Bob Hank played for Port-Torrens in 1944, but is not on The Power from Port website. I think this is because of him not living in the Port Adelaide zone at the time. It is for that reason Jervis, Bertram and Jordon do not appear in the book, I feel. And also, players may not be credited for the other club if they were already a one of the clubs i.e one player was at Torrens in 1941, and continued on for Port-Torrens in 1942, but is not in The Power from Port records. What do you think about this? Should I keep these player on the Norwood list or not?

5.
Robert Jervis
Robert Bertram
William Jordon

I have a slightly different theory on these guys, and others who played in that era. Basically, players were credited with having continued their careers with either Norwood or North footy clubs, as long as they had played for either club before 42-44, or continued for either club from 45 onwards. However, these players only played between 42-44, so which clubs do you put them under??? Hope that makes sense