Trades/Drafts (Nov & PSD/Rookie) - 2015

[stan]

Richmond to use pick 19 to Carlton for Yarran. Seems a senseless trade for them otherwise.

Carlton saying no to 19

Yarran contracted. Pick 12 or he stays

Thats all well and good but will you get the best out of him?

To answer my owm question possibly, with a new coach it may happen.

[Q.]

Richmond to use pick 19 to Carlton for Yarran. Seems a senseless trade for them otherwise.

Carlton saying no to 19

Yarran contracted. Pick 12 or he stays

[Turbo]

Richmond to use pick 19 to Carlton for Yarran. Seems a senseless trade for them otherwise.

Carlton saying no to 19

Yarran contracted. Pick 12 or he stays

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1445323429.364239.jpg (24.63 KiB) Viewed 573 times

[Jim05]

Richmond to use pick 19 to Carlton for Yarran. Seems a senseless trade for them otherwise.

Carlton saying no to 19

Yarran contracted. Pick 12 or he stays

$300k a year to play VFL and then walk for free next year?
He has already stated he wont play for them

[Turbo]

Richmond to use pick 19 to Carlton for Yarran. Seems a senseless trade for them otherwise.

Carlton saying no to 19

Yarran contracted. Pick 12 or he stays

$300k a year to play VFL and then walk for free next year?
He has already stated he wont play for them

Some would argue he didn't play for us this year

[gadj1976]

We're getting rid of Menzel??

For Pick 28 and Kerridge?

Someone wake me up when this nightmare is over.

[Brodlach]

We're getting rid of Menzel??

For Pick 28 and Kerridge?

Someone wake me up when this nightmare is over.

You think that's a poor deal for Carlton gadg?

[gadj1976]

We're getting rid of Menzel??

For Pick 28 and Kerridge?

Someone wake me up when this nightmare is over.

You think that's a poor deal for Carlton gadg?

You kidding me?

Kerridge is only ordinary. Menzel will be a star.

FFS, why do we keep giving blokes away that can play?

FOR PICK 28?????

[Brodlach]

We're getting rid of Menzel??

For Pick 28 and Kerridge?

Someone wake me up when this nightmare is over.

You think that's a poor deal for Carlton gadg?

You kidding me?

Kerridge is only ordinary. Menzel will be a star.

FFS, why do we keep giving blokes away that can play?

FOR PICK 28?????

Mine was a serious question mate.

[gadj1976]

So was my answer.

[Robran]

We're getting rid of Menzel??

For Pick 28 and Kerridge?

Someone wake me up when this nightmare is over.

Menzel to adel ??!!

[gadj1976]

[gadj1976]

BIG News unfolding between Adelaide and Carlton.

AFL's Mitch Cleary is reporting that a deal is pending which would see Carlton send Troy Menzel to the Crows, who will send Sam Kerridge and pick 28 the way of the Blues.

[gadj1976]

Aish to Collingwood. Collingwood a pick to North. Bastinac to Brisbane. Brisbane a pick to North.

North get two picks.

Collingwood lose a pick and gain Aish.

Brisbane lose a pick and get Bastinac.

[Q.]

Aish to Collingwood. Collingwood a pick to North. Bastinac to Brisbane. Brisbane a pick to North.

North get two picks.

Collingwood lose a pick and gain Aish.

Brisbane lose a pick and get Bastinac.

That's an awful deal for Brisbane.

[Spargo]

Aish to Collingwood. Collingwood a pick to North. Bastinac to Brisbane. Brisbane a pick to North.

North get two picks.

Collingwood lose a pick and gain Aish.

Brisbane lose a pick and get Bastinac.

That's an awful deal for Brisbane.

Sure is - what picks did we get?

[Brodlach]

North get pick 17
Brisbane get Bastinac and picks 34,38,40

According to the Herald Sun

[bennymacca]

Ch7 reported tonight that the Menzel deal is done and the paperwork will be lodged first thing tomorrow.

Not sure how I feel about the deal. Reckon it's slightly overs for the crows but Menzel has bigger upside

[whufc]

Ch7 reported tonight that the Menzel deal is done and the paperwork will be lodged first thing tomorrow.

Not sure how I feel about the deal. Reckon it's slightly overs for the crows but Menzel has bigger upside

Menzel has AMAZING upside compared to the mid range list clogger Kerridge is!

[Jim05]

Ch7 reported tonight that the Menzel deal is done and the paperwork will be lodged first thing tomorrow.

Not sure how I feel about the deal. Reckon it's slightly overs for the crows but Menzel has bigger upside

Menzel has AMAZING upside compared to the mid range list clogger Kerridge is!

Agreed. Kerridge is pretty much a tagger only, doesnt offer much at all.
If Menzels knees hold up it will be well worth it