phantompanther wrote:a smokey from south could be parry who looks in prime condition
Your joking - this is a serious topic not a laugh-a-thon. He will be lucky to poll 1 vote Almost every player in the league looks in prime condition this time of the year but unfortunaltely that is not a criteria for MM votes!
Still a very amusing post!
Drebin, sorry mate, but not taking the piss. What I saw of Weatherley on Saturday night made me think he is one of the best recruits to land in SA in years. One of the best kicks I have ever seen and he can mark a ball as well!!
A Bulldog in winter; a WTDCC Eagle and OICC Wolf in Summer!
bulldogproud wrote:Drebin, sorry mate, but not taking the piss. What I saw of Weatherley on Saturday night made me think he is one of the best recruits to land in SA in years. One of the best kicks I have ever seen and he can mark a ball as well!!
Sorry - I really though you were taking the piss! He looks like he is going okay but needs to do a little more than he is at the moment and as a FF he has only kicked 2 goals in each game in our 3 trials. He is missing a few marks thanks to soft hands - playing in Country Vic hasn't helped him. Looked alright when he had a run on the ball but I can't see him getting too many MM votes.
phantompanther wrote:a smokey from south could be parry who looks in prime condition
Your joking - this is a serious topic not a laugh-a-thon. He will be lucky to poll 1 vote Almost every player in the league looks in prime condition this time of the year but unfortunaltely that is not a criteria for MM votes! Still a very amusing post!
Far be it for anyone to have an opinion which differs to your own huh?
bulldogproud wrote:Drebin, sorry mate, but not taking the piss. What I saw of Weatherley on Saturday night made me think he is one of the best recruits to land in SA in years. One of the best kicks I have ever seen and he can mark a ball as well!!
Sorry - I really though you were taking the piss! He looks like he is going okay but needs to do a little more than he is at the moment and as a FF he has only kicked 2 goals in each game in our 3 trials. He is missing a few marks thanks to soft hands - playing in Country Vic hasn't helped him. Looked alright when he had a run on the ball but I can't see him getting too many MM votes.
A bit harsh on Weatherley arent you Drebin - im sure he wouldnt like to read this comin from someone which supports his own club sayin that already only after a couple of trial games.
phantompanther wrote:a smokey from south could be parry who looks in prime condition
Your joking - this is a serious topic not a laugh-a-thon. He will be lucky to poll 1 vote Almost every player in the league looks in prime condition this time of the year but unfortunaltely that is not a criteria for MM votes! Still a very amusing post!
Far be it for anyone to have an opinion which differs to your own huh?
That was my opinion CP. Seriously do you think Parry is a MM smokey as well? Based on what - he looks in prime condition at this time of the year? As I said so do lot's of players but past form and expectation is normally what you base a prediction on this time of the year and unless I have been mssing something Parry hasn't exactly been a contender in past years. I would have though there were at least half a dozen more South players that would be more of a realistic chance and the same goes for Weatherly at North as another example.
Listen any human who thinks weatherly could win a medal (magarey) must have been shot in the war and got a medal for bravery and at the same time got brain damage, the best forward seen in the last 6 years was bradshaw and he got maybe 8 votes, seen weatherly twice and not in the same league and id argue that hargy would kick more goals at full forward
Top 5
Centrals 46/46 votes
Norths 46/46votes
Ports 46/46 votes
Eagles 44/46 votes (please note that north supporters must really hate the eagles)
Norwood 12/46 votes
Sturt 12/46 votes
West 11/46 votes
Souths 10/46 votes
Gay Bays 3/46 votes (dont worry the three people who voted for the bays have been detained in Glenside Hospital
Magarey Medal
P Thomas 7 votes
B Haynes 4 votes
Clayton 4 votes
Gill & Ladhams 3 votes
Bullen & Kenna & Whiteman & Vince Rugalo 2 votes (vince would like to thaank his mum and dad for each casting a vote
Lots of other 1 vote
Farmer Medal
Schell 26 votes
Cupido & Weatherman 5 votes
Clive Shithouse 4 votes
Passador 2 votes
Few others on 1 vote
phantompanther wrote:a smokey from south could be parry who looks in prime condition
Your joking - this is a serious topic not a laugh-a-thon. He will be lucky to poll 1 vote Almost every player in the league looks in prime condition this time of the year but unfortunaltely that is not a criteria for MM votes! Still a very amusing post!
Far be it for anyone to have an opinion which differs to your own huh?
That was my opinion CP. Seriously do you think Parry is a MM smokey as well? Based on what - he looks in prime condition at this time of the year? As I said so do lot's of players but past form and expectation is normally what you base a prediction on this time of the year and unless I have been mssing something Parry hasn't exactly been a contender in past years. I would have though there were at least half a dozen more South players that would be more of a realistic chance and the same goes for Weatherly at North as another example.
Thats the whole point, it doesn't matter what I think because IT'S SOMEONE ELSES OPINION!! Parry wouldn't be my choice, but I'm not about to accuse the bloke of "joking" or turning something into a "Laugh-a-thon" for his own belief .. For someone who as recently as today derided someone for a personal attack toward yourself, that post seemed somewhat hypocritical ... See which sentence you come up with from the following words - Cake, Have, Too, It, And, Eat, My ...
phantompanther wrote:a smokey from south could be parry who looks in prime condition
Your joking - this is a serious topic not a laugh-a-thon. He will be lucky to poll 1 vote Almost every player in the league looks in prime condition this time of the year but unfortunaltely that is not a criteria for MM votes! Still a very amusing post!
Far be it for anyone to have an opinion which differs to your own huh?
That was my opinion CP. Seriously do you think Parry is a MM smokey as well? Based on what - he looks in prime condition at this time of the year? As I said so do lot's of players but past form and expectation is normally what you base a prediction on this time of the year and unless I have been mssing something Parry hasn't exactly been a contender in past years. I would have though there were at least half a dozen more South players that would be more of a realistic chance and the same goes for Weatherly at North as another example.
Thats the whole point, it doesn't matter what I think because IT'S SOMEONE ELSES OPINION!! Parry wouldn't be my choice, but I'm not about to accuse the bloke of "joking" or turning something into a "Laugh-a-thon" for his own belief .. For someone who as recently as today derided someone for a personal attack toward yourself, that post seemed somewhat hypocritical ... See which sentence you come up with from the following words - Cake, Have, Too, It, And, Eat, My ...
Yeah CP - where was my personal attack in my original post - I put up an opinion. I didn't attack the poster personally, make fun of his name (as was the case with me earlier today)- I just disagreed with his opinion as I did with bulldogproud who picked a player from my club. How was I supposed to know they were not taking the piss or joking because how many others on here would pick Parry or Weatherly as a smokey for the MM?
