SA Footy

All we need is mickyj to come on gloating and that should set this thread up for some good banter / abuse.

Wasn't there unfortunately but...

Weren't North supporters complaining about the umpiring being biased in the previous game @ Prospect?
Perhaps the Eagles are getting a free ride every week?

Trent Plucktrum wrote:

Aerie wrote:

Trent Plucktrum wrote:The last decision would be the worst bit of complete bias umpiring that I've every seen any WWT supporter that actually witnessed it and thought it was there is a complete liar.

Need to see the replay. At the game Campbell had prior opportunity (ran for a few metres) and when he was tackled it looked like he didn't get rid of it correctly. Granted they don't seem to pay those any more, although they should. There were 50 other worse calls during the game.

Good work sit on the fence you obviously didnt see it but bask in the glory of the best run of bias umpiring I've ever seen

Turn it up , bad decision maybe , bias me thinks not.

on the rails wrote:All we need is mickyj to come on gloating and that should set this thread up for some good banter / abuse.

He won't be far away they won thats the only time he posts

Trent Plucktrum wrote:

Aerie wrote:

Trent Plucktrum wrote:The last decision would be the worst bit of complete bias umpiring that I've every seen any WWT supporter that actually witnessed it and thought it was there is a complete liar.

Need to see the replay. At the game Campbell had prior opportunity (ran for a few metres) and when he was tackled it looked like he didn't get rid of it correctly. Granted they don't seem to pay those any more, although they should. There were 50 other worse calls during the game.

Good work sit on the fence you obviously didnt see it but bask in the glory of the best run of bias umpiring I've ever seen

Was on outer wing. Will sit on fence till I see the replay. Umpiring wasn't bias, just terrible.

on the rails wrote:All we need is mickyj to come on gloating and that should set this thread up for some good banter / abuse.

Not going to gloat OTR Was an intriguing game of footy to watch !!
Either side did not deserve to lose !!

Trent Plucktrum wrote:

on the rails wrote:All we need is mickyj to come on gloating and that should set this thread up for some good banter / abuse.

He won't be far away they won thats the only time he posts

funny

Mickyj wrote:

on the rails wrote:All we need is mickyj to come on gloating and that should set this thread up for some good banter / abuse.

Not going to gloat OTR Was an intriguing game of footy to watch !!
Either side did not deserve to lose !!

True re losing but losing because of shit umpring decision is not the way to lose!

LEH wrote:Wasn't there unfortunately but...

Weren't North supporters complaining about the umpiring being biased in the previous game @ Prospect?
Perhaps the Eagles are getting a free ride every week?

GEEZ LEH if you went to a game you might see this post as being so frigging stupid !!

LEH wrote:Wasn't there unfortunately but...

Weren't North supporters complaining about the umpiring being biased in the previous game @ Prospect?
Perhaps the Eagles are getting a free ride every week?

The umpring was poor both ways all day but the last free kick was a disgrace and cost us the win!

Another big game we stuffed up. Sick of it.

Mic wrote:Another big game we stuffed up. Sick of it.

True in a tight game kicking 1-5 in the last hurt us although the Eagles kicked poorly for the first half. George Thring kicks his very getable set shot and we are 8 points up and win.

This loss could well and truly cost us the double chance.

A win is a win and we'll take it.

For years I've been frustrated and vocal at how the umpires seem to put away the whistle in the last quarter and play different rules to the rest of the game. I've also been just as vocal and frustrated about how they don't pay blatant free kicks in front of North goals but would pay them elsewhere on the ground especially holding the ball.
Ironic that they decided to do the opposite to normal for both things today in the last seconds of the game.
There's so many of them that are so bad, it has to be their coach. We need 12 league field umpires every week and have got about 6 up to standard if that.
Any game that's less than 2 goals difference in the SANFL is just pot luck as to what sort of brain fade the nearest (and not always the nearest!) has that week and when he has it.
Complete incompetence that costs teams spots on the ladder at the moment and could potentially cost a team a premiership down the track.
People talk about the integrity of the game being put at risk if the Crows enter the comp, give me that any day if you can bring along a few competent umpires to look after games! Even if they're not competent just be ******* consistent, that's all we and players ask!

I'm not.
I'm asking a question as to whether the Eagles are getting a 'good ride' when playing North - is it tactical in terms of tackling technique, etc.?
Has Godden 'seen' something in 'the tapes' that is a perceived weakness?

I find your responses interesting to say the least.

on the rails wrote:

Mic wrote:Another big game we stuffed up. Sick of it.

True in a tight game kicking 1-5 in the last hurt us although the Eagles kicked poorly for the first half. George Thring kicks his very getable set shot and we are 8 points up and win.

This loss could well and truly cost us the double chance.

I'm not yet convinced we are a top 3 side.

LEH wrote:I'm not.
I'm asking a question as to whether the Eagles are getting a 'good ride' when playing North - is it tactical in terms of tackling technique, etc.?
Has Godden 'seen' something in 'the tapes' that is a perceived weakness?

I find your responses interesting to say the least.

The Eagles get a good run every game mate, reckon the stats over the last couple of years will back that up

JK wrote:

LEH wrote:I'm not.
I'm asking a question as to whether the Eagles are getting a 'good ride' when playing North - is it tactical in terms of tackling technique, etc.?
Has Godden 'seen' something in 'the tapes' that is a perceived weakness?

I find your responses interesting to say the least.

The Eagles get a good run every game mate, reckon the stats over the last couple of years will back that up

They're the Hawthorn of the SANFL. At least with Hawthorn you can understand it as the AFL would want a side with a huge membership to be up there.

Wedgie wrote:There's so many of them that are so bad, it has to be their coach. We need 12 league field umpires every week and have got about 6 up to standard if that.

Agreed.

JK wrote:The Eagles get a good run every game mate, reckon the stats over the last couple of years will back that up

Compile them and show us then mate.