SAAFL Division 4 2013

[No.43]

Yeah word of that deal has come through, although according to the man in question hes happy at the bulls, hoping we do retain him!

[Cohiba]

Yeah sorry, a 6 pack of west coast coolers

there is NOTHING wrong with West Coast Coolers!

So very 70's FC.......

[Footy Chick]

Early 80's Cohiba ;-)

The original RTD!

[No.43]

Does any1 have a link to this weeks budget?

[woodublieve12]

Does any1 have a link to this weeks budget?

http://www.talkingamateurs.com.au/footy-budget.html

[BurraBoys]

Team of the year.....meh
Id rather coach the team i picked

Aish on Half Back? He played out of a Forward Pocket against us

Congrats to those who made it though!

[No.43]

Burraboys can you post it mate, that link only has last weeks budget

[BurraBoys]

http://www.talkingamateurs.com.au/Budge ... und_24.pdf

[No.43]

Fair few iffy selections

[BurraBoys]

Fair few iffy selections

I felt like the selectors tried have an even spread from all teams rather than picking the best players

[Robb_Stark]

are these the actual positions they would play if they had to or just the best players of the year

[woodublieve12]

be all righht if they spelt the players names right

PEGORARO

[Robb_Stark]

Footy Chick will you be at another club next year ??? few clubs on the look out for head trainer

[BurraBoys]

are these the actual positions they would play if they had to or just the best players of the year

Id say neither for a few of the selections

[Cohiba]

Team of the year.....meh
Id rather coach the team i picked

Aish on Half Back? He played out of a Forward Pocket against us

Congrats to those who made it though!

Looking at all the TOY's I think that more than just a few of those selected would have multi tasked in different positions as needs dictated on the day.

[BurraBoys]

Don't doubt that Cohiba. My point is, here is a guy (Aish) who has kicked 24 goals for the season playing most of the year forward and on the ball. Why pick him on half back? No doubt he could play a role there in a game where this team was assembled together. You either justify an individuals selection in there proper position, or don't pick them.

I for one would definatley have him in the team. Just not there. This has probably resulted due to the selectors going for an 'even spread' across the clubs. Let nothing be taken away from the guys that have been named though.

Another example would be Steele from Brahma. 21 Votes in the medal playing as a midfielder and 2nd in his club BnF. Spry gets one vote in the medal for the team that finished bottom. Spry may have well been Greenacres best player this year. IMO he was but it seems Steele has been left out as the selectors felt they could not pick more than 3 from any one club. The 3 picked from Brahma could not be denied there positions so a very deserving player is missed.

The good thing about these sorts of things though is the discussion they create!

[Cohiba]

Don't doubt that Cohiba. My point is, here is a guy (Aish) who has kicked 24 goals for the season playing most of the year forward and on the ball. Why pick him on half back? No doubt he could play a role there in a game where this team was assembled together. You either justify an individuals selection in there proper position, or don't pick them.

I for one would definatley have him in the team. Just not there. This has probably resulted due to the selectors going for an 'even spread' across the clubs. Let nothing be taken away from the guys that have been named though.

Another example would be Steele from Brahma. 21 Votes in the medal playing as a midfielder and 2nd in his club BnF. Spry gets one vote in the medal for the team that finished bottom. Spry may have well been Greenacres best player this year. IMO he was but it seems Steele has been left out as the selectors felt they could not pick more than 3 from any one club. The 3 picked from Brahma could not be denied there positions so a very deserving player is missed.

The good thing about these sorts of things though is the discussion they create!

I agree that the selection does allow for debate... Steele was stiff as was Jarrad Rantassa-Clark...I guess a case could have been also made for guys like Paul Wooton Peter Lovell , as well as host of defenders such as Patrick Johns, Jon Floereani, Brett Sparrnon, Dave Walliford and Patrick Johns who all had a great season and would have been worthy of selection. Still not a bad line up...

[BurraBoys]

Patrick Johns was so good you named him twice

[Cohiba]

Patrick Johns was so good you named him twice

There you go.... good one

[Robb_Stark]

F.P F.F F.P
Tim Aloisi Steven Wellington J.Vanderhaak


H.F.F C.H.F H.F.F
Jarrad Clark-Rantasa Peter Lovell Joel Aish


WING CENTRE WING
Mark Rowe Ryan Viney Heath Deer


H.B.F C.H.B H.B.F
George Long Cuong Phan Lepka

B.P F.B B.P
Burra Boy Drew Hosking Luke Broadbent

RUCK Scott Peterson
ROVER Tim Dunkley
RUCK ROVER Lee Dugan

BENCH
1.Steven Cravin (2nd ruck)
2.Micheal Spry
3.Christian Puccini

Trainer Footy Chick
Water Girl Footy Chick
Rub Downs Dicky Lambert