Dr. Pink wrote:Nobody close to beating Moonta.
Will thereby some player movement out of some clubs mid season as top side is too strong
Beaten by the Southern Eagles.
Well done to the Southern Eagles beating Moonta as they looked a long way off the week before v Kadina. I’m busy seeding so haven’t seen any football for a few weeks but was told a mile off against Kadina.
Lucky “The Sack” is playing for them this week or it might be 2 losses in a row, who would have thought
Dirty dog wrote:
Moonta won’t drop a game this year! Won by around 20 goals last week with 6 regular A graders out and 5 of those are superstar country footballers, ex afl, SANFL, mail medal winners types.
Dirty dog wrote:
Moonta won’t drop a game this year! Won by around 20 goals last week with 6 regular A graders out and 5 of those are superstar country footballers, ex afl, SANFL, mail medal winners types.
Dropped the gf
Congrats Kadina
Huge win by Kadina. I had given up making comments on here about YP footy because it was Moonta by lots and lots until yesterday had known other reasons to think otherwise.
Moonta were at full strength with the Port boys back and their coach Goldsack all playing.
Hats off to Egg but I hope he can resist the temptation to have a drink as he’s done a great job being off it for a few years now. What about the temptation though
Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
locky801 wrote:Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
Will finish bottom 3 with Wallaroo and Ardrossan. You could combine all 3 and they still be 5 goals worse than the top 3 or 4 sides.
locky801 wrote:Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
Will finish bottom 3 with Wallaroo and Ardrossan. You could combine all 3 and they still be 5 goals worse than the top 3 or 4 sides.
And everyone thought Moonta would win the GF in a canter as well
locky801 wrote:Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
Will finish bottom 3 with Wallaroo and Ardrossan. You could combine all 3 and they still be 5 goals worse than the top 3 or 4 sides.
How many player points do each club receive, are they the same. Or do you what each club gets?
locky801 wrote:Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
Will finish bottom 3 with Wallaroo and Ardrossan. You could combine all 3 and they still be 5 goals worse than the top 3 or 4 sides.
How many player points do each club receive, are they the same. Or do you what each club gets?
Sliding scale, if you play in the GF you get 10. The maximum is 15 and after that you can apply to the SANFL for more under exceptional circumstance’s. Ardrossan and Bute have extra points, Ardrossan 17 and Bute 20.
locky801 wrote:Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
Will finish bottom 3 with Wallaroo and Ardrossan. You could combine all 3 and they still be 5 goals worse than the top 3 or 4 sides.
How many player points do each club receive, are they the same. Or do you what each club gets?
Sliding scale, if you play in the GF you get 10. The maximum is 15 and after that you can apply to the SANFL for more under exceptional circumstance’s. Ardrossan and Bute have extra points, Ardrossan 17 and Bute 20.
Not Much different to the top 4 clubs who receive 10 or 12 points, to the bottom 4 - 15 points + extra . The top 4 or 5 teams seam to finish in the finals every year and Bute, Wallaroo, Paskerville and Ardrossan always seam to be a long way of them. Is it poor recruiting or is is a just their turn to struggle. I know Wallaroo always seam to be strong in juniors which may result in a stronger seniors if they can retain them, but wouldn't the league be better if all 9 clubs where competitive.
locky801 wrote:Have heard Bute may have picked up a few players from Broadies in the Amateurs, not sure how reliable the info is but if correct certainly picked up some talent
Will finish bottom 3 with Wallaroo and Ardrossan. You could combine all 3 and they still be 5 goals worse than the top 3 or 4 sides.
How many player points do each club receive, are they the same. Or do you what each club gets?
Sliding scale, if you play in the GF you get 10. The maximum is 15 and after that you can apply to the SANFL for more under exceptional circumstance’s. Ardrossan and Bute have extra points, Ardrossan 17 and Bute 20.
Not quite correct. Points are worked out on win/loss ratio over previous 3 seasons, not on ladder finishing position. For 2023 the points are Moonta 8, CMS 8, Kadina 11, Cougars 11, Eagles 12, then all of Pasky, Bute, Ardrossan and Wallaroo on 15.
So the team that won the Grand Final are on 4 less points then one of the bottom teams? That's only 1 decent player and those Botton sides are trying to close the gap of 10 goals. Hazbeen do you know what point are allocated for 2024 and if any club as asked for extra?
The match results on PlayHQ clearly show what the points allocation is. In 2023 the points allocation was Moonta 10, CMS 10, Eagles 11, Kadina 13, Wallaroo 15, Pask 15, Ardrossan 17, Bute 20. Im assuming Hazbeen meant 2024 above but based on 2023 I can’t see those 2024 points as being correct unless the YPFL has overhauled their points allocation somewhat.
Down the Hill wrote:The match results on PlayHQ clearly show what the points allocation is. In 2023 the points allocation was Moonta 10, CMS 10, Eagles 11, Kadina 13, Wallaroo 15, Pask 15, Ardrossan 17, Bute 20. Im assuming Hazbeen meant 2024 above but based on 2023 I can’t see those 2024 points as being correct unless the YPFL has overhauled their points allocation somewhat.
Yes, sorry meant 2024.
Additional points have been granted following applications from 3 clubs but I can't publicise them until the board is made aware.
Down the Hill wrote:The match results on PlayHQ clearly show what the points allocation is. In 2023 the points allocation was Moonta 10, CMS 10, Eagles 11, Kadina 13, Wallaroo 15, Pask 15, Ardrossan 17, Bute 20. Im assuming Hazbeen meant 2024 above but based on 2023 I can’t see those 2024 points as being correct unless the YPFL has overhauled their points allocation somewhat.
Yes, sorry meant 2024.
Additional points have been granted following applications from 3 clubs but I can't publicise them until the board is made aware.
Not Much different to the top 4 clubs who receive 10 or 12 points, to the bottom 4 - 15 points + extra . The top 4 or 5 teams seam to finish in the finals every year and Bute, Wallaroo, Paskerville and Ardrossan always seam to be a long way of them. Is it poor recruiting or is is a just their turn to struggle. I know Wallaroo always seam to be strong in juniors which may result in a stronger seniors if they can retain them, but wouldn't the league be better if all 9 clubs where competitive.[/quote]
Bute, Pasky and Ardrossan have very low Junior numbers. Not a lot of A and B graders coming through each year. No point investing in big name big price recruits if you don’t have a good bunch of locals.
