Finals Week 1

MW · Post by MW » Mon Sep 12, 2016 5:50 pm

Some of the comments on here... :lol:

Jim05 · Post by **Jim05** » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:13 pm

Wedgie wrote:Ironically that trip would have got two weeks in the old days of footy and would have got the same in the NRL.
I can see lots of broken legs happening soon.

Dustin Fletcher would of played 500 if the same leniency to tripping was offered back then[emoji1]

Grahaml · Post by **Grahaml** » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:14 pm

Brodlach wrote:
Wedgie wrote:
Brodlach wrote:
woodublieve12 wrote:If hartigan tripped anyone else he would have missed this week..

Still think it was an involuntary action

LOL

Wasn't a deliberate act but as I said at the time I thought he would/should miss a game for it

Who has a reflex to kick out at a player like that? It's unfathomable that anyone could even suggest it wasn't deliberate.

Now I don't personally think there was intent to hurt and it was no doubt a spur of the moment decision. He was just so desperate and so badly beaten that the only way to slow Thomas down was the stick the leg out. That's still deliberate and dangerous and needs to be met with a virtually automatic suspension IMHO.

Even though the final outcome benefits my own side, it's something that can never be allowed to creep into the game.

MW · Post by MW » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:17 pm

IMO it's the change of direction that throws the leg out. He is not deliberately trying to kick him

daysofourlives · Post by **daysofourlives** » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:30 pm

MW wrote:IMO it's the change of direction that throws the leg out. He is not deliberately trying to kick him

You cant be fn serious. Go outside, run in a straight line and then change direction. Do it 100 times, i bet not once do you throw your leg out to do it

MW · Post by MW » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:34 pm

daysofourlives wrote:
MW wrote:IMO it's the change of direction that throws the leg out. He is not deliberately trying to kick him

You cant be fn serious. Go outside, run in a straight line and then change direction. Do it 100 times, i bet not once do you throw your leg out to do it

Then why do we see this type of trip 5-6 times a year in identical fashion?

JK · Post by JK » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:42 pm

I reckon in the split second he's just trying to get any part of his body in the way of the player that's getting past him, so don't think there's an intention to hurt. But it's blatant tripping and he's a very lucky boy

Brodlach · Post by **Brodlach** » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:43 pm

JK wrote:I reckon in the split second he's just trying to get any part of his body in the way of the player that's getting past him, so don't think there's an intention to hurt. But it's blatant tripping and he's a very lucky boy

JK the voice of reason

Corona Man · Post by **Corona Man** » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:46 pm

JK wrote:I reckon in the split second he's just trying to get any part of his body in the way of the player that's getting past him, so don't think there's an intention to hurt. But it's blatant tripping and he's a very lucky boy

Probably no intent to hurt. Absolutely intent to stop. Throwing a leg to stop an opponent is dangerous territory in my view. The bloke is lucky, play on.

Grafter · Post by **Grafter** » Mon Sep 12, 2016 6:52 pm

Anybody interested in a precendent this Season ?? Round 2 Adel Oval Crows vs Power.. 1st Quarter, about 1.45 remaining... C.Dixon going one way & B. Smith going other way with the ball. C. Dixon throughs leg out and connects. No report.

nuggety goodness · Post by **nuggety goodness** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 7:33 am

Grafter wrote:Anybody interested in a precendent this Season ?? Round 2 Adel Oval Crows vs Power.. 1st Quarter, about 1.45 remaining... C.Dixon going one way & B. Smith going other way with the ball. C. Dixon throughs leg out and connects. No report.

And Nat Fyfes trip on Koby Stevens last year IIRC... identical issue. No report.

He was brownlow favorite and people were saying 'surely he cant lose the brownlow for that'...

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Booney · Post by **Booney** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 8:13 am

Grafter wrote:Anybody interested in a precendent this Season ?? Round 2 Adel Oval Crows vs Power.. 1st Quarter, about 1.45 remaining... C.Dixon going one way & B. Smith going other way with the ball. C. Dixon throughs leg out and connects. No report.

Precedent counts for nothing with the MRP. Hasn't for years, it's pointless us trying to compare incidents when the MRP doesn't.

stan · Post by **stan** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 8:14 am

valleys07 wrote:The ears of those at AFL house are probably still ringing after the barrage of abuse directed their way after the Sloane suspension.

Hartigan was never getting weeks. Adelaide fans would have booked a stopover in Melbourne en route to Sydney with sticks of Dynamite.

Nah mate AFL house dont listen to 5AA so they wont be worried about the vengeful Adelaide fans.

Booney · Post by **Booney** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 8:16 am

valleys07 wrote:The ears of those at AFL house are probably still ringing after the barrage of abuse directed their way after the Sloane suspension.

Hartigan was never getting weeks. Adelaide fans would have booked a stopover in Melbourne en route to Sydney with sticks of Dynamite.

No chance.....not with flights as expensive as they are! :lol:

carey · Post by **carey** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 8:21 am

Booney wrote:
valleys07 wrote:The ears of those at AFL house are probably still ringing after the barrage of abuse directed their way after the Sloane suspension.

Hartigan was never getting weeks. Adelaide fans would have booked a stopover in Melbourne en route to Sydney with sticks of Dynamite.

No chance.....not with flights as expensive as they are!

Especially going to the wrong airport :oops:

Brodlach · Post by **Brodlach** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 9:27 am

carey wrote:
Booney wrote:
valleys07 wrote:The ears of those at AFL house are probably still ringing after the barrage of abuse directed their way after the Sloane suspension.

Hartigan was never getting weeks. Adelaide fans would have booked a stopover in Melbourne en route to Sydney with sticks of Dynamite.

No chance.....not with flights as expensive as they are!

Especially going to the wrong airport

Only an idiot would do that

cracka · Post by **cracka** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 10:45 am

nuggety goodness wrote:
Grafter wrote:Anybody interested in a precendent this Season ?? Round 2 Adel Oval Crows vs Power.. 1st Quarter, about 1.45 remaining... C.Dixon going one way & B. Smith going other way with the ball. C. Dixon throughs leg out and connects. No report.

And Nat Fyfes trip on Koby Stevens last year IIRC... identical issue. No report.

He was brownlow favorite and people were saying 'surely he cant lose the brownlow for that'...

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Be interesting to go through the threads & look at any comments about those 2 incidents or is it just because he's a crows player there is an uproar

Post by **Wedgie** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 10:56 am

Nat Fyfes was as he was slipping and clumsy, Hartigans was slightly worse as he was on his feet and meant it but having said that I just watched a couple of replays and Hartigans wasn't as severe as I thought, it looked much worse in the pub when I was smashed! I'd give him the benefit of the doubt in hindsight as there wasn't much momentum if any behind it, too much doubt for it to cost a finals game. I'll admit my initial reactions/view on that one was wrong.Dixon's I can't find on YouTube. Stevie J the unlucky bloke of the weekend, too much doubt in my eyes.

Post by **Wedgie** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 11:01 am

The Giants aren't contesting Stevie Js suspension. Play on.

stan · Post by **stan** » Tue Sep 13, 2016 11:08 am

Wedgie wrote:The Giants aren't contesting Stevie Js suspension. Play on.

Did his job. Took Kennedy out of the game.

Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Re: Finals Week 1

Who is online