PAFC 2025

[MW]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

[bertiebeatle1]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

Get one for Bergman or NWM in return

[Dutchy]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

still get in earlier in the other rounds.

Hearing they will get NAGA access to Cochrane in '26 draft also, which will ease the pain of this year

[MW]

not getting pick 4 for Bergman (if ladder stays the same as it is now).
NWM is no certainty either, and you'll need to give up a heap to get him too.

[Booney]

Be going well to outbid Adelaide for Wanganeen-Milera's services.

[bertiebeatle1]

Considering Bergman's likely landing spot is St Kilda, i'm not discounting anything

[DOC]

Booney.

You have identified a lack of development in the player range 30-60 ish.

Development coach issue?

[Brodlach]

Thought I’d look it up for incoming trades and free agents only

2018
Burton
Mayes
Lycett

2019
Buzza

2020
Allir
Fantasia


2021
Finlayson
Skinner

2022
JHF
Rioli
Evans


2023
Ratugolea
Soldo
Sweet
Zerk Thatcher

2024
Ratkins
Lukosius
Richards

[Brodlach]

Logan Evans signs on for 3 years

Thoughts Booney?

[Booney]

Logan Evans signs on for 3 years

Thoughts Booney?

Just discussing on Twitter, 2 years probably right.

He's played 15 games and he's 19. Last year he had Farrell and Houston flanking him this year he's had Sinn ( 10 games ), Burgoyne ( 36 ) and Jones ( 56 ) working around him. Not sure he's lost his form, he hasn't played 20 games and has lots of promise.

[Booney]

Booney.

You have identified a lack of development in the player range 30-60 ish.

Development coach issue?

Absolutely it is.

[Lightning McQueen]

Keep performing like this for the remainder of the year, and you run a greater risk of losing Butters and Bergman. Pull the trigger now and give Carr more time at the helm. Carr gets a free hit remainder of the year.

Butters I don't have concerns about, Bergman I think will be gone.

Butters loves Kenny, he's the main reason we've held on to him, he wants a flag and it isn't coming from us any time soon, he is gone at seasons end IMO.

Where there is smoke there is generally fire, talk of Boak departing over the years was always extinguished straight away, Houston never died down once it came to light nor has any other decent Adelaide based AFL player in recent history.

[Fricky]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

If Butters and Bergman go you should get 3 first rounders back. All depends on which clubs the players want to go to
Essendon - 5, 9
Hawks - 8
Richmond - 2, 3
Saints - 6 + Nasiah
Bulldogs - 14
Geelong - 12

[Booney]

Keep performing like this for the remainder of the year, and you run a greater risk of losing Butters and Bergman. Pull the trigger now and give Carr more time at the helm. Carr gets a free hit remainder of the year.

Butters I don't have concerns about, Bergman I think will be gone.

Butters loves Kenny, he's the main reason we've held on to him, he wants a flag and it isn't coming from us any time soon, he is gone at seasons end IMO.

Where there is smoke there is generally fire, talk of Boak departing over the years was always extinguished straight away, Houston never died down once it came to light nor has any other decent Adelaide based AFL player in recent history.

Butters is made of stern, loyal stuff as Boak is and there's a bit behind the scenes that will make Butters decision to leave a lot harder.

[Lightning McQueen]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

If Butters and Bergman go you should get 3 first rounders back. All depends on which clubs the players want to go to
Essendon - 5, 9
Hawks - 8
Richmond - 2, 3
Saints - 6 + Nasiah
Bulldogs - 14
Geelong - 12

Will be Dogs, Cats or Hawks..............in that order IMO.

[Fricky]

Privately Carr must be thinking this is the best result for him, there will need to be some patience which is what he needs. Lets say they finished top 4 this year there would have been huge pressure on him to make the next step, now he will get time, and some better draft picks

Not a first rounder though

If Butters and Bergman go you should get 3 first rounders back. All depends on which clubs the players want to go to
Essendon - 5, 9
Hawks - 8
Richmond - 2, 3
Saints - 6 + Nasiah
Bulldogs - 14
Geelong - 12

Will be Dogs, Cats or Hawks..............in that order IMO.

You'd take pick 8 for Bergman but surely you're not taking a single pick for Butters

[Booney]

Geelong gave up 13,15 and 20 for Jeremy Cameron, he's the only player I can think of in recent memory that you could compare to with the talent on offer.

So it's 3 x 1st rounders or 2 x + the player you have that we want.

Edit - Cameron had played 171 games at GWS, Butters has played 126

[Fricky]

So
Bergman to Hawks for Pick 8
Butters to Essendon for Picks 5, 9, 24 (they also have 27)

[MW]

Geelong gave up 13,15 and 20 for Jeremy Cameron, he's the only player I can think of in recent memory that you could compare to with the talent on offer.

So it's 3 x 1st rounders or 2 x + the player you have that we want.

Edit - Cameron had played 171 games at GWS, Butters has played 126

Geelong also got back 2 x 2nd rounders, so if you want 3 x 1sts you'll be giving up a couple of 2nd rounders as well as Butters.
Also key position are normally valued more than midfielders.
Personally I think you'll get 2 x 1sts for him

[wenchbarwer]

Geelong gave up 13,15 and 20 for Jeremy Cameron, he's the only player I can think of in recent memory that you could compare to with the talent on offer.

So it's 3 x 1st rounders or 2 x + the player you have that we want.

Edit - Cameron had played 171 games at GWS, Butters has played 126

As good as Butters is, and I really rate him, I'm always taking a gun KPF over a gun midfielder