SAAFL Div 3 & 3R (2010)

[zedman]

They were handy in 06&07. Who are the new faces zed.

cant say..my informant is not 100% reliable..i will be having a look anyway..and top end is on it i reckon

[teaoby]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

[piccachu]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

i reckon i would take the 2 iggies boys in stephan white and joe pedler, in desperate need of a forward (do far this year) and pedler can play any were

[teaoby]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us.

[SATCHEL]

Greig or Jones From Portland. Would slot straight in to line up.

[teaoby]

Greig or Jones From Portland. Would slot straight in to line up.

Div3 not C3

[Iron Fist]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us.

When I read piccachu's 2, I thought them for sure, but you make a good point with hanson and flynn aswell.
So the 2 I would take are PAOC's ruckman (only guy I have seen compete all day with Perko), so that our on ballers get first use all day. and probably Hanson.

very good question though

[piccachu]

[quote][may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us./quote]

fair call on the Para Hills boys, i rate them very highly also, on puccini i would obviously have him in my side but at the moment our on ballers and small forwards have been kicking all the goals for us so not in desperate need of another one of those types.

obviously wanders is a gun but again i dont think our side needs another on baller,
i reckon next in line for us would be a Dalwood or Parham so Perkins doesnt have to shoulder the load alone

[teaoby]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us.

When I read piccachu's 2, I thought them for sure, but you make a good point with hanson and flynn aswell.
So the 2 I would take are PAOC's ruckman (only guy I have seen compete all day with Perko), so that our on ballers get first use all day. and probably Hanson.

very good question though

Flynn vs Pedler is a toss up

if you want purely a CHF flynn everytime. utility then pedler. after the w/e id have no hesitation in taking hanson over white.

[teaoby]

[may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us./quote]

fair call on the Para Hills boys, i rate them very highly also, on puccini i would obviously have him in my side but at the moment our on ballers and small forwards have been kicking all the goals for us so not in desperate need of another one of those types.

obviously wanders is a gun but again i dont think our side needs another on baller,
i reckon next in line for us would be a Dalwood or Parham so Perkins doesnt have to shoulder the load alone

id take Margatich over parham. although hes been in and out this year.

[SATCHEL]

Greig or Jones From Portland. Would slot straight in to line up.

Div3 not C3

Promote from within i say

[Jimmy_041]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us.

When I read piccachu's 2, I thought them for sure, but you make a good point with hanson and flynn aswell.
So the 2 I would take are PAOC's ruckman (only guy I have seen compete all day with Perko), so that our on ballers get first use all day. and probably Hanson.

very good question though

You can have him - he sponges too many beers off everyone at the Alma.

[Iron Fist]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us.

When I read piccachu's 2, I thought them for sure, but you make a good point with hanson and flynn aswell.
So the 2 I would take are PAOC's ruckman (only guy I have seen compete all day with Perko), so that our on ballers get first use all day. and probably Hanson.

very good question though

You can have him - he sponges too many beers off everyone at the Alma.

deal. hope he likes west end
cause if he trys to sponge at the thunder dome then thats all he will get.

[Jimmy_041]

Lost him now - he's a chardonnay drinker

Likes those little umbrellas as well

[teaoby]

Lost him now - he's a chardonnay drinker

Likes those little umbrellas as well

[threestars]

who from any other club (in div3) would you take if you could have 1 player and runnerup or 2 because its tough.

may surprise some, but id take pooch. we dont have a true small forward (well we do but hes playing b's) and pooch kicks so many goals. even if you target him.

and id take hanson or flynn-sinodinos over the iggies pair. put those 2 in iggies team and they would be unstopabble. white you can counter by floating someone back. but yeah ped's hasnt really fired against us.

When I read piccachu's 2, I thought them for sure, but you make a good point with hanson and flynn aswell.
So the 2 I would take are PAOC's ruckman (only guy I have seen compete all day with Perko), so that our on ballers get first use all day. and probably Hanson.

very good question though

Flynn vs Pedler is a toss up

if you want purely a CHF flynn everytime. utility then pedler. after the w/e id have no hesitation in taking hanson over white.

In all due respect though, White has kicked 18 more goals than any other player in Div 3, why wouldn't you want him?

[piccachu]

In all due respect though, White has kicked 18 more goals than any other player in Div 3, why wouldn't you want him?

i agree. at this stage for me i have only seen both play once this year and white killed us hanson still kicked a few but wasnt as damaging as white, but have seen hanson tear us to shreds in previous years.

so to solve all arguments they have both got a guernsey waiting for them at the dome,

on a differnent note i think Connelly from iggies is probably the most underrated player in the comp, has killed us every time we play iggies

[Mr Beefy]

Greig or Jones From Portland. Would slot straight in to line up.

Obviously not in front of new recruit Nugget?

[Jets]

I am suprised that Robert Douglas and Josh Moody haven't been mentioned more on this topic. Both Guns who would play top quality Div 1 Footy IMHO

[Iron Fist]

I am suprised that Robert Douglas and Josh Moody haven't been mentioned more on this topic. Both Guns who would play top quality Div 1 Footy IMHO

If I was an opposition club Moody would definately be one of the blokes Id look at taking. he has proved he can play div 1 footy by winning a flag with Goodies last year.