Match Review Panel

[Booney]

Late? I'd argue that one.

High? Got him shoulder to shoulder.

Concussed? Dont need to be hit in the head to be concussed.

[HH3]

Late? I'd argue that one.

High? Got him shoulder to shoulder.

Concussed? Dont need to be hit in the head to be concussed.

Totally agree. Looks like he floated to the ground. A malicious shirtfront wouldve upended him. At no time does he receive contact to the head that I can see, be it from a shoulder or from the ground.

Shit call, and Im not even a Port supporter.

I might just not be up with the times though because I think this is a fair hit and Im a Roos supporter.

Watch at the 45 second mark.

[Johno6]

was 100% late IMO.

if you have a chance to pull up and you dont good chance its late

[The Sleeping Giant]

Late? I'd argue that one.

High? Got him shoulder to shoulder.

Concussed? Dont need to be hit in the head to be concussed.

Only see what you want to see.

[Booney]

Late? I'd argue that one.

High? Got him shoulder to shoulder.

Concussed? Dont need to be hit in the head to be concussed.

Only see what you want to see.

Perhaps, but I wouldn't think I'm alone.

[Johno6]

can anyone post the footage, then we can all see what we wanna see
but on the day i thought it was easily late.

[saintal]

Check previous page Johno.

[Johno6]

sorry mate, my bad.

after watching the vision again. not as late as i first thought
but def had time to pull out, and unfortunately these days that warrants a suspension.
as crap as that may be

[The Sleeping Giant]

And he got him in the head.

[scoob]

sorry mate, my bad.

after watching the vision again. not as late as i first thought
but def had time to pull out, and unfortunately these days that warrants a suspension, if you are not chris judd.
as crap as that may be

[The Sleeping Giant]

After watching it a few more times, definitely hit him in the head, with what looks like a raised arm. Late enough to stop the action but chose not too. Libbas head doesn't hit the ground either.

Cop the 3 and stop whinging.

[CoverKing]

I thought Liberatore was a hard little nut? I cant believe how soft the bump was and I am even more puzzled by a bloke with a good record getting two weeks for that.

Stop being so one eyed mate. In this day and age, he got what he deserved

[Turbo]

u do make a good point, i would do the same.

minson also suspended for 1 week by the bulldogs for his actions.

Storm in a teacup. What a joke!!!

[Squids]

ur mumma is so


oh carp I'm coping a week for that

[Johno6]

Mods ban him!!!

[Lightning McQueen]

Late? I'd argue that one.

High? Got him shoulder to shoulder.

Concussed? Dont need to be hit in the head to be concussed.

I'm a Port supporter and I thought it was late, avoidable, front on, reckless and weak.

He should've been preparing to tackle anyway, that way he would've aborted if Libba got rid of the ball.

Dumb move in today's game.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Supporters should be more pissed off with the player who gets suspended.

[HH3]

I bet all the people that say he deserves to be suspended were the same people whinging that the games getting too soft when they started changing the rules.

This is what AFL should STILL be...

[The Sleeping Giant]

Nope. I've accepted the changes, and aussie rules is still the greatest sport in the world.

[Johno6]

dems da rules now