Match Review Panel

[saintal]

Simon Black lucky to get away with his strike last week? Only saw it a couple of times on replay but it wasn't his finest moment.

[Coach Bombay]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

[Jim05]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

Lucky he only got 3

[Coach Bombay]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

Lucky he only got 3

Why? His tackle on Taylor was worse and that was 2. Morris Jumped up and flipped himself to some degree. Adam Goodes would have gotten away with it.

[Booney]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

Well, I dont see how anyone could draw anything remotely racist from that anyway.

[OnSong]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

How is that fact?

[Jim05]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

Lucky he only got 3

Why? His tackle on Taylor was worse and that was 2. Morris Jumped up and flipped himself to some degree. Adam Goodes would have gotten away with it.

Repeat offender, obviously hasnt learnt his lesson. 4 weeks minimum IMO

[saintal]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

Lucky he only got 3

Why? His tackle on Taylor was worse and that was 2. Morris Jumped up and flipped himself to some degree. Adam Goodes would have gotten away with it.

Guys (stars) like Goodes and Franklin (Judd in previous years) will always get preferential treatment over lesser players. Not saying it's right but it's the way it goes. Nothing to do with skin colour IMO.

Two weeks for Goddard also.

[Coach Bombay]

Goodes, Franklin and Lovett-Murray all have had excellent luck and more recently Jurrah. When taking off your pants at private function is seen worse than what Jurrah did then you know that there is something not right. Do you honestly think that indigenous and non-indigenous players are treated 100% equally.

[Lightning McQueen]

It always seems to be players with "prime" numbers getting reported for the trivial things. Perhaps that is a deciding factor, every third prime number report gets let off.

[Lightning McQueen]

Goodes, Franklin and Lovett-Murray all have had excellent luck and more recently Jurrah. When taking off your pants at private function is seen worse than what Jurrah did then you know that there is something not right. Do you honestly think that indigenous and non-indigenous players are treated 100% equally.

Who uncladded?

[LMA]

Walker offered 3 weeks. If he was aboriginal he would of recieved a lighter penalty. Not racist just fact.

I'm sure Byron Pickett would disagree with that so called fact

[Coach Bombay]

Like I said, not being racist - i love what the indigenous players bring to the game and by no means would ever sledge or treat someone differently because of their skin colour. Just something that a lot of people have probably thought as well

[Johno6]

lol, whenever anyone has to say they arent being racist etc good chance its gonna be racist.


im not racist but,..........

[Coach Bombay]

how can it be discussed without people getting offended?

[Johno6]

unfortunately it probably cant

[Coach Bombay]

What if i said " Does anyone agree that in recent times there has been some incidents which may indicate some slight preferential treatment towards indigenous players" FFS feel like a bit of an asshole, should of said nothing

[OnSong]

I understand the point you're trying to make but yeah, someone is likely to be offended by the way you framed the statement.

It's like saying to your missus:

"Geez, you've put on a shitload of weight, but I'm not saying you're fat."

[saintal]

What if i said " Does anyone agree that in recent times there has been some incidents which may indicate some slight preferential treatment towards indigenous players" FFS feel like a bit of an asshole, should of said nothing

Agree to an extent with this. Just didn't see the connection with the MRP that's all.

Andrew Lovett may disagree with you though. Still think my club was far too hasty in flicking him to be honest.

[Jim05]

Cornes has just proved once again what a knob he is. Suggested Walker should have been awarded a 50m penalty because Morris got up and shoved him
And then the Crows conspiracy callers come on, conveniently forgetting that the AFL handed them the softest draw in history