EP Football - PLFL, GFFL, MWFL, FWFL, EEFL

[bluestheboy]

BTB you forgot the word "allegedly"
If Semmler had made deliberate contact with an umpire as your club has reported him for
then dont you think the umpire would have red carded him and reported him.
As for a dog act BTB I honestly thought that you guys were better than that.
You won the game fair and square.
now it seems you want to make sure that our participation in the final series is curtailed
by means other than on the field fighting for the pill.
Your Club has a proud and long history of Success on and off the field......
not anymore it seems.

Was really paraphrasing to make a point about the difference in reaction. Actually I have never mentioned the name of the alleged perpetrator.
And to be fair, if the alleged incident did not happen then that will be backed up by the 2 umpires in charge of the game. In particular Umpire Staunton who was holding the alleged card at the time of the alleged incident. So if this is how the alleged incident happened then you have nothing to worry about.
As for our clubs proud history, this minor incident will not alter that.

[lincolnsdirtysecrets]

I dont mean to excuse the actions of this person but umpire Staunton being involved makes this all the more more beleivable. I don't like bagging umpires but Staunton is not up to A grade standard. Are the umpires that short that he can get a game.
It is very frustrating playing a game with him in control. He makes Pappy look good.
I feel sorry for whatever grade gets him in the finals

[Mark Dreher]

20091022_orangutan.jpg (153.17 KiB) Viewed 2158 times

After the fact picture of Tasman Captain Coach standing on the mark.

Please note handbag is held in other hand cut out by photo.

On a serious note, would you honestly think that an umpire would drop a charge of manhandling an umpire. Not likely.
For once i agree with CU, waybacks have the right to have it investigated. If it proven completely incorrect by umpires version of events you would expect Carl to get an appology as well.

[Media Park]

Damn I ran out of popcorn.

[coyote ugly]

Tribunal hearing has been confirmed for tonight. I will post results after.
Talk is 2 to 3 weeks down here if it is found that he deliberatly knocked the card from the umpires hand. Rumour has it the roosters defence will be the wind blew it out of his hand.

[Eagle-in12]

what are peoples thoughts of the outcome of all this ? Surely Carl should start preparing for 2013 preseason ?

[Media Park]

what are peoples thoughts of the outcome of all this ? Surely Carl should start preparing for 2013 preseason ?

Brand new poster, first effort on the site, an Eagles supporter thinking CS should miss the finals.
Is that to make your chances of winning easier?

[Eagle-in12]

Could be , but as a supporter of local footy this incident needed to be looked at. forget about name or talent, could you all imagine if it was a MPFC player ,

[captian cook]

what are peoples thoughts of the outcome of all this ? Surely Carl should start preparing for 2013 preseason ?

Brand new poster, first effort on the site, an Eagles supporter thinking CS should miss the finals.
Is that to make your chances of winning easier?

CS may well have played his last game in lincoln for a while as i believe his 2013 preseason could be north of here!!

[Eagle-in12]

Media Park, what are the odds for the PLFL premiership ?

[Media Park]

Media Park, what are the odds for the PLFL premiership ?

Tasmans with Semmler 2-1
Mallee Park 5-1
Tasmans without Semmler 7-1
Waybacks 10-1
Lincoln South 10-1

*Odds quoted for comedic effect, not actually taking bets

[coyote ugly]

Could be , but as a supporter of local footy this incident needed to be looked at. forget about name or talent, could you all imagine if it was a MPFC player ,

I had never thought about it that way. One could only imagine the uproar from you all. Or is it just that you are all racist?

[Eagle-in12]

Could be , but as a supporter of local footy this incident needed to be looked at. forget about name or talent, could you all imagine if it was a MPFC player ,

I had never thought about it that way. One could only imagine the uproar from you all. Or is it just that you are all racist?

The uproar would be huge!

[Ken Whelan Fan]

Only one racist on the site....theyve got a letter to prove it havent they CU?

[Media Park]

Only one racist on the site....theyve got a letter to prove it havent they CU?

[Eagle-in12]

Who's posting the results from tonight's hearing CU ?

[the star]

Few people watching this forum for 9 o clock on a Wednesday night!

[Media Park]

Few people watching this forum for 9 o clock on a Wednesday night!

#kangaroocourtfootball makes us wonder.
Either no games or 20 we're guessing.

[Ken Whelan Fan]

Is CU still in his hole at Centenary this morning?

[coyote ugly]

I had a few too many cans last night kwf. I am in a big hole at the moment.

Semmler objection was dismissed by tribunal. Free to play this week