by Aerie » Sat Oct 14, 2023 10:04 am
by Aerie » Sat Oct 14, 2023 10:06 am
Tony Clifton wrote:There shouldn't be finals in Div 2
Instead have "relegation/promotion" matches
Div 1 7th vs Div 2 2nd
Div 1 8th vs Div 2 1st
Winners play Div 1 the next year
Like those promotion matches they have at Wembley for the soccer
by Shark_Hunter » Sat Oct 14, 2023 6:52 pm
by Arry Gablett » Sat Oct 14, 2023 6:59 pm
Shark_Hunter wrote:Northerns take a hattrick to beat TTG in the last over!
by DOC » Sun Oct 15, 2023 10:19 am
by Minimum Chips » Sun Oct 15, 2023 11:25 am
Aerie wrote:Tony Clifton wrote:There shouldn't be finals in Div 2
Instead have "relegation/promotion" matches
Div 1 7th vs Div 2 2nd
Div 1 8th vs Div 2 1st
Winners play Div 1 the next year
Like those promotion matches they have at Wembley for the soccer
I like it. Great idea.
by Tony Clifton » Sun Oct 15, 2023 1:40 pm
Minimum Chips wrote:Aerie wrote:Tony Clifton wrote:There shouldn't be finals in Div 2
Instead have "relegation/promotion" matches
Div 1 7th vs Div 2 2nd
Div 1 8th vs Div 2 1st
Winners play Div 1 the next year
Like those promotion matches they have at Wembley for the soccer
I like it. Great idea.
Would your thinking be then that the top 2 in Div 2 at the end of the minor round get automatic promotions? A bit like in the UK for "winning the league"? Or the losers of the above games then play the top 2 from Div 2 with the winners qualifying for Div 1 the next season?
by Arry Gablett » Sun Oct 15, 2023 5:50 pm
Tony Clifton wrote:Minimum Chips wrote:Aerie wrote:Tony Clifton wrote:There shouldn't be finals in Div 2
Instead have "relegation/promotion" matches
Div 1 7th vs Div 2 2nd
Div 1 8th vs Div 2 1st
Winners play Div 1 the next year
Like those promotion matches they have at Wembley for the soccer
I like it. Great idea.
Would your thinking be then that the top 2 in Div 2 at the end of the minor round get automatic promotions? A bit like in the UK for "winning the league"? Or the losers of the above games then play the top 2 from Div 2 with the winners qualifying for Div 1 the next season?
SO DO THEY GET TO PLAY FOR A PREMIERSHIP OR JUST PROMOTION?
Yep, 7th and 8th from Division 1 play 1st and 2nd from Division 2
Winners play in Division 1 the following season
by Arry Gablett » Sun Oct 15, 2023 5:51 pm
Tony Clifton wrote:Minimum Chips wrote:Aerie wrote:Tony Clifton wrote:There shouldn't be finals in Div 2
Instead have "relegation/promotion" matches
Div 1 7th vs Div 2 2nd
Div 1 8th vs Div 2 1st
Winners play Div 1 the next year
Like those promotion matches they have at Wembley for the soccer
I like it. Great idea.
Would your thinking be then that the top 2 in Div 2 at the end of the minor round get automatic promotions? A bit like in the UK for "winning the league"? Or the losers of the above games then play the top 2 from Div 2 with the winners qualifying for Div 1 the next season?
Yep, 7th and 8th from Division 1 play 1st and 2nd from Division 2
Winners play in Division 1 the following season
by Tony Clifton » Sun Oct 15, 2023 6:05 pm
Arry Gablett wrote:SO DO THEY GET TO PLAY FOR A PREMIERSHIP OR JUST PROMOTION?
by Aerie » Sun Oct 15, 2023 7:37 pm
Tony Clifton wrote:Arry Gablett wrote:SO DO THEY GET TO PLAY FOR A PREMIERSHIP OR JUST PROMOTION?
In my idea? Promotion
by Arry Gablett » Sun Oct 15, 2023 8:37 pm
by Eagles2014 » Mon Oct 16, 2023 12:50 pm
Arry Gablett wrote:Surely they get to play for a flag in finals
Isn’t that why we play
Minor premier automatic
The premier if it’s not the minor premier goes up
If the minor premier is in the gf then the other gf participant
The division 1 teams that finish last and second last don’t get another chance stay up just because
The season will show that the top 3 or so in division 2 are competitive against all division 1 teams
by whufc » Mon Oct 16, 2023 12:54 pm
by Eagles2014 » Mon Oct 16, 2023 12:59 pm
whufc wrote:There has to be a premiership in div2. It can't even be a discussion to not have one. No need to over complicate it.
Div 1 and Div 2 have their own medals for best player, best bowler, best batter. Div 1 takes the names from the current trophies and div2 creates new names for the trophies.
Has to be promotion for the minor premiers at very least. You need the best team of the entire season playing div1 the next year.
by whufc » Mon Oct 16, 2023 1:24 pm
Eagles2014 wrote:whufc wrote:There has to be a premiership in div2. It can't even be a discussion to not have one. No need to over complicate it.
Div 1 and Div 2 have their own medals for best player, best bowler, best batter. Div 1 takes the names from the current trophies and div2 creates new names for the trophies.
Has to be promotion for the minor premiers at very least. You need the best team of the entire season playing div1 the next year.
It will be 2 up and 2 down, that way 10 of the 13 Clubs would have played Div 1 in the first two years.
There will be finals in both divisions also.
by Gosaints » Mon Oct 16, 2023 2:35 pm
Arry Gablett wrote:Surely they get to play for a flag in finals
Isn’t that why we play
Minor premier automatic
The premier if it’s not the minor premier goes up
If the minor premier is in the gf then the other gf participant
The division 1 teams that finish last and second last don’t get another chance stay up just because
The season will show that the top 3 or so in division 2 are competitive against all division 1 teams
by C Horse » Tue Oct 17, 2023 4:07 pm
Eagles2014 wrote:[
Just getting in a year early - no 4th Grade next season and one less junior team, let’s face reality that 4th Grade is made up of old farts that should be retired, fill ins who will play at home only, lads up from Juniors who are never going to play 1st Grade. Given them a chance to go back to their local clubs like Grange and Fulham etc and play a level of cricket more their standard. You seen the standard of 4th Grade lately, is diabolical! Got a third Womens team playing in ATCA with all the numbers. Think WT is definitely a grade club that has been doing all the right things for many, many years.
by Eagles2014 » Tue Oct 17, 2023 5:21 pm
C Horse wrote:Eagles2014 wrote:[
Just getting in a year early - no 4th Grade next season and one less junior team, let’s face reality that 4th Grade is made up of old farts that should be retired, fill ins who will play at home only, lads up from Juniors who are never going to play 1st Grade. Given them a chance to go back to their local clubs like Grange and Fulham etc and play a level of cricket more their standard. You seen the standard of 4th Grade lately, is diabolical! Got a third Womens team playing in ATCA with all the numbers. Think WT is definitely a grade club that has been doing all the right things for many, many years.
You make me laugh eAgles2014 - if it was any other club youd be looking for blood but WT pull out of D grade and they are ahead of their time are they? if saca had any balls they'd put them to D2 and bring Sturt up.
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |