AFL Round 14

[Booney]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

So they got it wrong, but not 50m penalty wrong.

Good work AFL.

[Zelezny Chucks]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

So they got it wrong, but not 50m penalty wrong.

Good work AFL.

So from now on players can just keep going until told to stand or they call play on by that logic

[MW]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

So they got it wrong, but not 50m penalty wrong.

Good work AFL.

I'm confused, the whistle was blown for a mark, no verbal 'play on' from the ump but it should have been given play on so that negates the 50m penalty? Right...

[amber_fluid]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

So they got it wrong, but not 50m penalty wrong.

Good work AFL.

I'm confused, the whistle was blown for a mark, no verbal 'play on' from the ump but it should have been given play on so that negates the 50m penalty? Right...

Why would it be play on anyway?
They make the rules up as they go nowadays

[mots02]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

Based on this, she must have consulted with @wedgie - he's the only other person in the world who came up with the same conclusion

[dedja]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

Based on this, she must have consulted with @wedgie - he's the only other person in the world who came up with the same conclusion

... or they're the same person

[amber_fluid]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

Based on this, she must have consulted with @wedgie - he's the only other person in the world who came up with the same conclusion

... or they're the same person

Does she mention 119 often?

[tigerpie]

She's saying he marked it and played on before the umpire said anything like stand or play on so the correct call was play on.
Ump should've said stand and then if they moved it's 50.
What a crock!
Let's face it 4 umpires is not working.
There's now instances, one in the game yesterday, where there's 3 umpires in the area and they wait for each other to blow the whistle.

One example in ports game.
GWS bloke gets tackled from behind, umpire is behind said tackler. GWS player never takes possession, umpire couldn't see whether he did or not cause he's behind the GWS player.
Blows his whistle, and guesses the player has taken possession pays holding the ball.
There's no way that umpire could see. Out and out guess, and where there should've been an umpire that had a better view, there was silence.

[mots02]

I did find it amusing that Laura Kane has tried to say that the umpire stuffed up and that it should have been play on and not 50m because the umps didn't make any decision that's 50m all day everyday.

Based on this, she must have consulted with @wedgie - he's the only other person in the world who came up with the same conclusion

... or they're the same person

Does she mention 119 often?

119 times per week on average

[bertiebeatle1]

L Kane not doing herself any favours at the moment. Was really hoping she would succeed as she said all the right things when she was appointed but she is struggling big time. Looks well and truly out of her depth. Multiple issues weekly (mainly due to umpiring & rule changes)

[Armchair expert]

Zak Butters cops a week for his brutal right hook

[Jim05]

Zak Butters cops a week for his brutal right hook

Was very lucky to get off one earlier in the year wasn’t he?

[The Bedge]

Wasn't worth a suspension FFS.

Although I also didn't think Dixon's bump was worth 3 either.

[MW]

Zak Butters cops a week for his brutal right hook

could be "body of work"...he's been close a couple times this year and they finally pinched him

[tigerpie]

Zak Butters cops a week for his brutal right hook

Brownlow punters be dark.

[tigerpie]

L Kane not doing herself any favours at the moment. Was really hoping she would succeed as she said all the right things when she was appointed but she is struggling big time. Looks well and truly out of her depth. Multiple issues weekly (mainly due to umpiring & rule changes)

Talk the afl are changing the father sons points structure and are trying to push it through for this year's draft.
Voss not happy as it effects the Campo boys. Her and Dillon under some pressure.
Kane does speak really well but have to agree shes earning her money right now with weekly issues.

The term they need to pull their finger out and get the game in order has new meaning.
Yeah yeah I'm out I know.

[The Dark Knight]

Zak Butters cops a week for his brutal right hook

could be "body of work"...he's been close a couple times this year and they finally pinched him

I wonder if Port will reference Jesse Hogan's incident from round 6 in an attempt to downgrade his one match ban?

[whufc]

L Kane not doing herself any favours at the moment. Was really hoping she would succeed as she said all the right things when she was appointed but she is struggling big time. Looks well and truly out of her depth. Multiple issues weekly (mainly due to umpiring & rule changes)

Talk the afl are changing the father sons points structure and are trying to push it through for this year's draft.
Voss not happy as it effects the Campo boys. Her and Dillon under some pressure.
Kane does speak really well but have to agree shes earning her money right now with weekly issues.

The term they need to pull their finger out and get the game in order has new meaning.
Yeah yeah I'm out I know.

Pretty fair from Carlton. Understanding rules do change etc but clubs would plan far more than one year ahead and definitely take into account potential father sons especially ones like the Camporeales who have been elite footballers through most of their junior footy in the SANFL system.

I feel like any major change to the rules like that the AFL should be required to at least give a couple years notice.

[MW]

Carlton deliberately traded out 3rd round picks for multiple 4th rounders to use for the Campo boys, if they change the rules on them now without notice it f..ks them up royally. Has to be a min. 2 year phase in period.

[Booney]

L Kane not doing herself any favours at the moment. Was really hoping she would succeed as she said all the right things when she was appointed but she is struggling big time. Looks well and truly out of her depth. Multiple issues weekly (mainly due to umpiring & rule changes)

Talk the afl are changing the father sons points structure and are trying to push it through for this year's draft.
Voss not happy as it effects the Campo boys. Her and Dillon under some pressure.
Kane does speak really well but have to agree shes earning her money right now with weekly issues.

The term they need to pull their finger out and get the game in order has new meaning.
Yeah yeah I'm out I know.

Yeah. Nah. Out of her depth right now.