2025 Adelaide Footy League - Division 6

[Mythical Creature]

This Ingle Farm player is not the victim in this. Carrying on, that you are going to support him etc.
There is a reason there is a national deregistration policy and this is it. The fact that he was on 11 games prior to this, it is not a 1 time offence. Far from it. Now that he has been banned for more than 16 it also protects players and clubs from other leagues as he can't go anywhere else now.
Hope the Fitzroy player is ok, as that is not expected to happen on a footy field.
He is someone who should be supported, he is the victim

[citycoaster17]

The way they both go down, and he walks away as if he's had the stuffing knocked out of him makes that one of the stranger things i've ever seen.

The spectators didn’t even know what happened. Yep it was a punch but not sure it was worth 16 games. I’ve seen worse get stuff all. The Portland captain a few years ago got 8 or something for more than that. Don’t condone violence on the footy field and he should never have hit, him just not sure it was worth 16.

I don't know Hollywood...It wasn't just a punch, it was a sucker punch the other bloke didn't see coming, and by the looks of the lack of interaction prior in the video, would have no reason to think that sort of impact would be coming his way. Seems like a pretty gutless act on face value, and not something that is in the heat of the moment where a brain snap could occur. Just my opinion looking at the video.

[whufc]

4th Quarter (15 minutes in) 100:39

Brandon received 10 for striking and 4 for rough conduct (falling on the player after the hit). This has taken a few weeks to finalise for a couple of reasons - firstly was us trying to exhaust every avenue where this doesn't end up in a national dereg.. that became evident quickly was never going to be the case, so the second was negotiating to a degree an early plea to avoid Brandon having to front the tribunal to effectively be told he can never play again, and obviously the emotional impact that goes with that.

Brandon was on 11 games - 1 game meant no more AdFL that was obvious, and was never getting less than 4 games for striking, so really the number of games he received became academic.. our (my) concern is his future, keeping him involved in the club and remaining a mentor for younger lads, plus the potential to coach his son in the future.

Make no mistake, this incident has had a deep impact on Bran and his family.. he knows he ****** up, he hasn't shied away from that, and he's cut up not only about not playing, but the impact his actions have had on Rayner, his own family and the club.

As a club we will remain supportive to him - think what you like, but he's a quality bloke and he is a major reason we have been able to turn things around... end of the day he's a human with feelings who made a mistake and has to live with it.

We have made massive strides forward as a club in recent years, this incident doesn't define us, we will continue to press forward and drive standards / change from within.

Imagine turning around as an umpire and seeing the two blokes on the ground.

[whufc]

4th Quarter (15 minutes in) 100:39

Brandon received 10 for striking and 4 for rough conduct (falling on the player after the hit). This has taken a few weeks to finalise for a couple of reasons - firstly was us trying to exhaust every avenue where this doesn't end up in a national dereg.. that became evident quickly was never going to be the case, so the second was negotiating to a degree an early plea to avoid Brandon having to front the tribunal to effectively be told he can never play again, and obviously the emotional impact that goes with that.

Brandon was on 11 games - 1 game meant no more AdFL that was obvious, and was never getting less than 4 games for striking, so really the number of games he received became academic.. our (my) concern is his future, keeping him involved in the club and remaining a mentor for younger lads, plus the potential to coach his son in the future.

Make no mistake, this incident has had a deep impact on Bran and his family.. he knows he ****** up, he hasn't shied away from that, and he's cut up not only about not playing, but the impact his actions have had on Rayner, his own family and the club.

As a club we will remain supportive to him - think what you like, but he's a quality bloke and he is a major reason we have been able to turn things around... end of the day he's a human with feelings who made a mistake and has to live with it.

We have made massive strides forward as a club in recent years, this incident doesn't define us, we will continue to press forward and drive standards / change from within.

Your a legend mate and being upfront and honest is a trait you have always shown and has earnt you so much respect.

Not sure I buy into blokes that can whack another bloke so easily and repeatedly (as the lifetime suspension would suggest) can play the good guy card at any level. But glad Ingle Farm are still looking after the bloke, i think as clubs we do have that responsibility and thats part of our community impact so good on Ingle Farm.

All the best for the year going forward.....would love to see for you Ingle Farm getting a flag.

[MW]

Good riddance. This is the reason we lost so many players in the early 2000's because they got sick of getting their noses broken behind play to guys like this.

[wenchbarwer]

Good riddance. This is the reason we lost so many players in the early 2000's because they got sick of getting their noses broken behind play to guys like this.

100% this. The fact he was already one game away from an AdelFL life ban, and 5 from a national ban shows this isn't a one-off. The sport is much better off without people like this involved.

The footage of him lamely falling over after he king hit the bloke in a misguided attempt to garner sympathy is an absolute joke.

[ROUNDTHETRAPS]

Disgraceful, just watched the footage. the way the Ingle farm bloke gets up after the incident with his chest out looking for the next bloke was really poor. Playing the victim too. The game is better off without him out there.

[MW]

It's the reason the life ban rule was introduced. I don't by the 'good guy' crap either. Can't hide behind playing footy to be a thug and then be a good guy off the field.

[Courtney Fish]

Are you allowed to be involved in a club if you are deregistered by the league?

Was thinking the same thing, could he coach or does the deregistration just cover playing?

If there is genuine remorse then I think it is great that the club is supporting him, many wouldn't.

You'd think remorse would come after the first 11 games suspension.
He was yellow carded earlier this year against us for a late cheap shot.
The sport is better for having these career thugs removed from the game.
And Ingle Farm want to keep him involved mentoring the young lads. Seriously? What a role model.

[The Bedge]

Have you all got it off your chest now? Geez Weetra didn't get this much interest when he walked off the oval and headbutted a spectator earlier this year!

Brandon is not the victim, nor are we trying to make out that he is - but he is human, and whilst you cast aspersions on his character, nobody knows what is happening behind the scenes either.

He is remorseful, he knew he ****** up, he's owned it from the start - doesn't make it an easier pill for him to swallow when footy has been his life for so long. Yes he should've learned from previous indiscretions, agreed, but don't act like getting 12 games in AdFL is hard given the penalty guidelines - was only a couple years ago 4 week suspensions for dangerous tackles were being handed out like lollipops.

He's not a career thug FFS - one of his suspensions came as a kid in an U18 competition.. he's played good level footy for most of his life, and for the most part without incident. None the less, his days are over, he acknowledges that.

Yes, I and the club will continue to support him - through his own personal battles, but also his experience and behaviour / consequences can hopefully help guide and prevent some other young lad coming through and hopefully stop them from going down a path. His story can be a lesson to others.

Should also not be lost that the 14 games is top end penalties that we accepted in lieu of a tribunal - had we fronted, and received say 8 and 2, would there be the same level of publicity? Would old mate have run an article and posted the video? Perhaps then i wouldn't have had to spend hours last night deleting comments on our social media pages, or receiving abusive messages from people who felt they had some god given right to tell me what they think.

[MW]

If he has personal battles that make him susceptible to assaulting people on the football field, then it is negligent from the club to allow him to play knowing this.

[The Bedge]

Round 12
Ingle Farm vs Houghton
Rosewater vs St Pauls OS
West Croydon vs Para Hills
Fitzroy vs OSB Lonsdale
Blackfriars vs Adelaide Lutheran.

Another very interesting round of matches - don't think there has been a round this year that hasn't had one or more games that are viewed with interest. Ingle Farm hosting Houghton for the Bryant Family Cup tomorrow is as big as any. The Bryant Family Cup in an annual trophy we play - it's largely in memory of Timmy Bryant, and raising awareness around mental health.. looking out for your mates. Timmy's brother Daniel was a premiership player with us and club captain before heading to Houghton, whilst Timmy played at Ingle Farm and I'm incredibly proud to have coached him and called him a mate. Unfortunately for the Farmers, we have never claimed the cup.. and tomorrow doesn't look like changing that with a number of troops down.

Rosies will be eager to bounce back against St Pauls, who have taken all in their path since losing to Ingle Farm by 14 goals a month ago. Now sitting second the Saints are eyeing that coveted top 2 spot, but Rosewater at home will be hard to beat. If the weather stays good it'll be a shoot out between the two sides big key forwards.

Weetra will kick a dozen a least against an improving West Croydon, but that'll be the only excitement in this match. The Roos will get another win and their season back on track, back in the finals hunt.

Fitzroy vs OSB should be a cracker, and a game the Sullies would be confident in creating an upset.. the only side to beat Roys this season, and match up well. For the sides fighting for top 5 spots, they'll be hoping for a Roys win to try and create some space in the ladder, but this one will go down to the wire. No Kaesler or Loveridge named for OSB hurts, but their forward line is as big and potent as anyones.

[LaughingKookaburra]

If he has personal battles that make him susceptible to assaulting people on the football field, then it is negligent from the club to allow him to play knowing this.

I’m pretty harsh on this incident personally, however there wouldn’t be a footy club in SA that doesn’t have someone with known personal battles taking the field each week.

[The Bedge]

If he has personal battles that make him susceptible to assaulting people on the football field, then it is negligent from the club to allow him to play knowing this.

Approx 1 in 4 men experience ill mental health - that's only the numbers that are reported and seek help, that number could be significantly greater.

In a footy club, with 100 players, this equates to the best part of 25 players at one time that area having troubles, going through hard times, battling demons etc.. sometimes football is the best outlet for them and the best we can do as a club is to support them and help them navigate best we can. If you believe that's being negligent then fine, i'll wear that.

If I genuinely believed there was risk about a player belting someone then I would certainly take steps to ensure that didn't occur... but i'm not in the business of excluding people otherwise.

[MW]

I am fully aware of mental health stats. Not sure why I got involved in this so won't comment further.

[BenchedEagle]

I absolutely feel for Ingle Farm here. To have a split second decision from 1 player to have such a heavy impact on the club is no doubt devastating.
Sooo shite for them to have to deal with a damning article come out with a video replay on repeat. I have no doubt the Advertiser will start boosting it on social media for clicks (ad revenue)

I don't know the player at all so cant comment on him, but I hope he gets the personal support he needs. I hope this turns into a positive life change for him. Maybe his story can be a warning for IF's younger players who maybe showing early signs of playing on the edge.

[hollywood7477]

See Dan Gorringe has put it up on his socials. Saw it just then on Facebook.

[whufc]

See Dan Gorringe has put it up on his socials. Saw it just then on Facebook.

Yep, sadly his reaction afterwards in what appears to be an attempt to make it look like he was hit means it's going to go seriously viral. By the end of the weekend its going to be everywhere on every social platform.

[morell]

I don't feel for Brandon at all but having been through the ringer with the actions of one person associated with our club earlier this year I can tell you it absolutely sucks being a club rep in these circumstances

Feel for everyone else involved at Ingle Farm and indeed the bloke that got belted

Reckon the virtue signalling pile on from people who should know better on here could probably be taken down a notch or two. Clubs are made up of hundreds of people, many of them not saints or scholars. Making some of them pariahs might solve the problem for footy but could make the societal problem worse

[woodublieve12]

Zero sympathy. Tried doing an eddie Guerrero and thankfully got caught.