Essendon

[wenchbarwer]

Double it now Trav

My thoughts exactly

[dedja]

Double it now Trav

Go the Bombers

[Brodlach]

Doh!

I can’t help it, I’m just an idiot

[amber_fluid]

Doh!

I can’t help it, I’m just an idiot

We know

[dedja]

Doh!

I can’t help it, I’m just an idiot

Oi, you’ll hear from my lawyers

[Brodlach]

Doh!

I can’t help it, I’m just an idiot

We know

One of us, one of us.

[whufc]

Captain position is over-rated in modern day AFL. More of a media figurehead than anything else.

With all the leadership groups, position line leaders, 49 different coaches, their role is more about being a morale leader rather than a decision maker.

As long as the captain is a bloke who won't shirk a contest their ability / skill / footy brains isn't really overly important. Would be more important that they hold high training / lifestyle standards, is someone in your group that can relate up and down the football department hierarchy, up and down the age demographic of the playing group.

I mean Richmond won flags with Jack Higgins telling jokes as part of their pre game 'pump up'

[gadj1976]

Captain position is over-rated in modern day AFL. More of a media figurehead than anything else.

With all the leadership groups, position line leaders, 49 different coaches, their role is more about being a morale leader rather than a decision maker.

As long as the captain is a bloke who won't shirk a contest their ability / skill / footy brains isn't really overly important. Would be more important that they hold high training / lifestyle standards, is someone in your group that can relate up and down the football department hierarchy, up and down the age demographic of the playing group.

I mean Richmond won flags with Jack Higgins telling jokes as part of their pre game 'pump up'

Oh, I was with you till this. This is the biggest one. If you are making dumb footy brain mistakes, I reckon that undoes all the good work you do, especially given he's in defence.

[whufc]

Captain position is over-rated in modern day AFL. More of a media figurehead than anything else.

With all the leadership groups, position line leaders, 49 different coaches, their role is more about being a morale leader rather than a decision maker.

As long as the captain is a bloke who won't shirk a contest their ability / skill / footy brains isn't really overly important. Would be more important that they hold high training / lifestyle standards, is someone in your group that can relate up and down the football department hierarchy, up and down the age demographic of the playing group.

I mean Richmond won flags with Jack Higgins telling jokes as part of their pre game 'pump up'

Oh, I was with you till this. This is the biggest one. If you are making dumb footy brain mistakes, I reckon that undoes all the good work you do, especially given he's in defence.

Yeah i probably mean more in the case of don't do completely dumb shit like being undisciplined on field giving away 50m penalties or turning the ball over in stupid areas.

The other side is the amount of 'say' a captain would have in the teams strategies, tactics, zones ectt would be very limited. Yes, they would have to be smart enough to understand them and communicate them but they wouldn't be the ones creating plans against oppositions.

[daysofourlives]

Captain position is over-rated in modern day AFL. More of a media figurehead than anything else.

With all the leadership groups, position line leaders, 49 different coaches, their role is more about being a morale leader rather than a decision maker.

As long as the captain is a bloke who won't shirk a contest their ability / skill / footy brains isn't really overly important. Would be more important that they hold high training / lifestyle standards, is someone in your group that can relate up and down the football department hierarchy, up and down the age demographic of the playing group.

I mean Richmond won flags with Jack Higgins telling jokes as part of their pre game 'pump up'

Oh, I was with you till this. This is the biggest one. If you are making dumb footy brain mistakes, I reckon that undoes all the good work you do, especially given he's in defence.

Yeah i probably mean more in the case of don't do completely dumb shit like being undisciplined on field giving away 50m penalties or turning the ball over in stupid areas.

The other side is the amount of 'say' a captain would have in the teams strategies, tactics, zones ectt would be very limited. Yes, they would have to be smart enough to understand them and communicate them but they wouldn't be the ones creating plans against oppositions.

Cripps is as dumb as they come, very poor leader and reflected in Carltons lack of success.
There is no way he could possibly communicate the team tactics to the rest of the team, probably why no young player develops at Carlton.
Im not sure Merret was much better. The best player often is not the best captain, they are likely to be the best player because they are more likely to be in their own bubble and a more selfish player than someone like a McGrath.
I actually fear this might be a turning point for Essendon

[Armchair expert]

James Sicily mensa member

[gadj1976]

Cripps is as dumb as they come, very poor leader and reflected in Carltons lack of success.
There is no way he could possibly communicate the team tactics to the rest of the team, probably why no young player develops at Carlton.
Im not sure Merret was much better. The best player often is not the best captain, they are likely to be the best player because they are more likely to be in their own bubble and a more selfish player than someone like a McGrath.
I actually fear this might be a turning point for Essendon

You do make some ridiculous comments some times but even I think you've outdone yourself here.

[daysofourlives]

Cripps is as dumb as they come, very poor leader and reflected in Carltons lack of success.
There is no way he could possibly communicate the team tactics to the rest of the team, probably why no young player develops at Carlton.
Im not sure Merret was much better. The best player often is not the best captain, they are likely to be the best player because they are more likely to be in their own bubble and a more selfish player than someone like a McGrath.
I actually fear this might be a turning point for Essendon

You do make some ridiculous comments some times but even I think you've outdone yourself here.

What part is incorrect? Are you going to tell me everytime youve heard Cripps talk youre wowed by his intelligence and football smarts? There is no doubt Cripps and Merret are the most selfish players in their respective teams

[gadj1976]

Cripps is as dumb as they come, very poor leader and reflected in Carltons lack of success.
There is no way he could possibly communicate the team tactics to the rest of the team, probably why no young player develops at Carlton.
Im not sure Merret was much better. The best player often is not the best captain, they are likely to be the best player because they are more likely to be in their own bubble and a more selfish player than someone like a McGrath.
I actually fear this might be a turning point for Essendon

You do make some ridiculous comments some times but even I think you've outdone yourself here.

What part is incorrect? Are you going to tell me everytime youve heard Cripps talk youre wowed by his intelligence and football smarts? There is no doubt Cripps and Merret are the most selfish players in their respective teams

Yeh ok your descriptive dialog above.... that's changed my mind