Would like to get people's opinion on promotion and relegation.
Should it be changed so that only 1 side goes up and 1 side goes down for the higher Divisions?
From my perspective it would be nice to only go up if you have achieved your goal (won the flag). If you lost it, you get another crack next year. Also, you would only go down if you have had a really awful year. My Club actually got relegated from Div 2 to Div 3 one year after winning 7 games. A little harsh. Another example would be Woodville Souths promotion after coming from 4th on the ladder to lose the GF in 2004. I suspect they may have liked another year in Div 2.
Obviously, in Division 3, 2 sides would go down to allow the Div 4 finalists to come.
I have nominated Division 3 as the level to split it but that may not be the right level. I set it at this level as below Division 3 there does seem to be a greater difference in quality and promoting 2 teams would seem to be more realistic.