Matthew Elliott has got to GO!!!!!

[Hondo]

NFC if you stop with the trolling posts singling 1 guy out when there's more than just him struggling then we won't have to publicly question young guys like Deitz and they can get the time they need

The team overall is showing good improvement from last year why don't you write about something positive and support your state team?

Might help too if you checked the stats 1st next time

[jackpot jim]

Team showing Improvement PIGS
2 Pura cup wins solely were achieved on the Back of Stand Out performances by Boof, Tait and Dizzy.
Boof has now Gone.
Taity will spend little time with SA again.
Dizzy is a washed up Bowler that is well below his best according to u guys.

Genuine Improvement will only occur when the young Guns start to Perform and apart from Fergy and to a Lesser extent Delmont, this just hasn't occured.
Elliott increasing his ave from 13 to 29 at the age of 36 isnt part of the solution for the future, so why Perservere with him?

[NFC]

Team showing Improvement PIGS
2 Pura cup wins solely were achieved on the Back of Stand Out performances by Boof, Tait and Dizzy.
Boof has now Gone.
Taity will spend little time with SA again.
Dizzy is a washed up Bowler that is well below his best according to u guys.

Genuine Improvement will only occur when the young Guns start to Perform and apart from Fergy and to a Lesser extent Delmont, this just hasn't occured.
Elliott increasing his ave from 13 to 29 at the age of 36 isnt part of the solution for the future, so why Perservere with him?

Exactly.

[bulldogproud]

If you ask any of the SA selectors or players you will also find that Herb is of great assistance to the younger guys through his advice and leadership. One of the problems SA has had in recent seasons is that it has gained a batting lineup with very little experience at State level. Do you expect the younger guys to just come in and be 'lambs to the slaughter' or would you like them to have some experienced players help them to settle?
Cheers

[jackpot jim]

This debate seems to be going nowhere.
We've all had our say on the matter with nobody on either side preparing to back down so it probably time to leave it at that.
It seems we all want whats Best for SA cricket and whatever it takes to be done to get SA back near the top, playing exciting , competitive Cricket, so lets just hope those in charge with ability to make this happen GETS IT RIGHT in the very near Future.!
Cheers.

[westcoastpanther]

perhaps NFC could change his name to NFI......

[magpie in the 80's]

the last post

[redden whites]

I am still picking myself up off the floor at the thought of recruiting Lou Vincent ...is it April 1st?

[Hondo]

I was on the other side of the debate but I have to say 'well said' JJ

[LBT]

NFC if you stop with the trolling posts singling 1 guy out when there's more than just him struggling then we won't have to publicly question young guys like Deitz and they can get the time they need

The team overall is showing good improvement from last year why don't you write about something positive and support your state team?

Might help too if you checked the stats 1st next time

Fair call but Deitz is 31 or 32 now, not a youngster.

[Hondo]

Is he? Well that helps my arguement where were you earlier LBT?

[bulldogproud]

I also say well said, JJ. I will defend Herb to the death though. I should probably stay out of these debates as I know Herb personally and love the guy!!
Cheers

[mal]

I also say well said, JJ. I will defend Herb to the death though. I should probably stay out of these debates as I know Herb personally and love the guy!!
Cheers

I admire you sticking up for Herb
I wish he would bat in the middle order [can you ask him ?]

[bulldogproud]

Will try. I think Aerie may have a better chance of getting a yes from him though.
Do you want to open the batting for SA, Mal?
Cheers

[SOTTERS]

I also say well said, JJ. I will defend Herb to the death though. I should probably stay out of these debates as I know Herb personally and love the guy!!
Cheers

Im with you there BULLDOGPROUD Herb is a great bloke and a Kyabram champion.

[NFC]

perhaps NFC could change his name to NFI......

So Elliott's doing a good job of opening the batting?

[bulldogproud]

Better than anyone else in South Australia. In fact he has been the topscorer in SA's innings' more than any other player in the lineup.
Cheers

[mighty_tiger_79]

If you ask any of the SA selectors or players you will also find that Herb is of great assistance to the younger guys through his advice and leadership. One of the problems SA has had in recent seasons is that it has gained a batting lineup with very little experience at State level. Do you expect the younger guys to just come in and be 'lambs to the slaughter' or would you like them to have some experienced players help them to settle?
Cheers

we understand that Herb is good with the young kids coming through, so make him a batting coach or something so he can keep up this allegedly good work that he does in the nets, where it belongs.....in the nets........

[redden whites]

Hello is anyone there.......Where are the knockers today

[mighty_tiger_79]

what disgraceful shot to play at that stage of the innings

poor form