Should an umpire be allocated to a game if.....

[zedman]

Zedman, how was the Kenilworth B Grade umpire on Saturday?

tbh..i didnt take a hell of a lot of notice..but..the gg umpire with the cap was..um..sh!t?..missed so many frees it got ridiculous..the a grade umps were very old..but actually did ok..one of them was the same we had the week before and he had been terrible the week before..maybe the pairing up needs to be looked at..some dont work well with others and some work well

[LaughingKookaburra]

I think the umpiring has improved this year in the magoos. Yes the Glenunga umpire is the worst by an absolute mile. To be completely honest though I find the club umpires in the reserves to be better than the league reps in the A's on majority of occasions. Not as hot on the umpires as I used to be, I done it once and it opened my eyes up, mind you though I was the only umpire and I umpired at Kenilworth (Full oval)