div 3 to 7 medal winners!

[schimma]

D3 DG MC KAY MEDAL Craig Frinsdorf Old Ignatians
D4 AEC TRELOAR MEDAL Dale Laslett Portland
D5 JB DICKER MEDAL Adam Forth Greenacres
D6 AG BERT MEDAL Luke Warburton Westminster OS
Luke Warburton won the D6 Medal in 2006

D7 KC SIMS MEDAL Shaun Holland Paralowie
D1R EA DAVOREN MEDAL Ryan Bowman Henley
D2R EP NAZER MEDAL Phil Noble SMOSH Wst Lakes
Phil Noble won the D3RMedal in 2007
D3R HW MAIN MEDAL Darren Iron Salisbury
D4R CG TIDEMAN MEDAL Nicholas Kriewaldt Adelaide Lutheran
Nicholas Kriewaldt won the D5R Medal in 2007

D5R GP WILSON MEDAL Robert Brauer Plympton
D6R RH ELIX MEDAL Kosta Amanatidis Colonel Light Gdns
D7R FJ MONTEN MEDAL Wesley Legrand Adelaide University
C1 P COLLINS MEDAL Peter Uncle Tea Tree Gully
C2 JA BURCHELL MEDAL Shaun Lindholm Edwardstown
C3 RB LAMBERT MEDAL Jason Soar Flinders Park
Jason Soar won the D5 Medal in 1999

C4 HD NAYLOR MEDAL William Evans Adelaide University
C5 FS HONE MEDAL Phillip Jordan Golden Grove
U18 Yellow HJ MUTTON MEDAL Dene Steele Salisbury West
U18 Blue F COCKBURN MEDAL Shaun Hinsley North Haven
This is North Haven’s first under age SAAFL medal

well done to Phil Noble back to back medals. Good night bet a few lads are a bit under the weather today.

[Johno37]

Has anyone noticed that the 'Top 4 medal contenders from each club' list, gave the players in descending order of votes attained?

Good work, SAAFL.

haha yeah i noticed that... so thats how u knew who had the best chance from your club, the top guy.... frickin clever chappys

[blublurag]

Has anyone noticed that the 'Top 4 medal contenders from each club' list, gave the players in descending order of votes attained?

Good work, SAAFL.

haha yeah i noticed that... so thats how u knew who had the best chance from your club, the top guy.... frickin clever chappys

How's this one...we were advised by SAAFL to bring the top 3 votegetters to the Div 1/2 medal count. One of the guys in the top 3 list advised by SAAFL was suspended during the year. Not much chance he is going to win it.

[FOURTH ESTATE]

Is a certian umpire still umpiring Adelaide Uni games?
It might explain how Wes LeGrand receives so many votes.
Don't get me wrong he is a very good player but also seemed to get the votes when playing at home even if he wasn't the best platyer on the field.
Just something I have noticed after having played against Uni for the last 10-15 years in that grade???????????????

[The Big Shrek]

What happens if the two umpires can't agree on votes? Does the home umpires view prevail?

[Keepitreal]

Is a certian umpire still umpiring Adelaide Uni games?
It might explain how Wes LeGrand receives so many votes.
Don't get me wrong he is a very good player but also seemed to get the votes when playing at home even if he wasn't the best platyer on the field.
Just something I have noticed after having played against Uni for the last 10-15 years in that grade???????????????

Makes a mockery of the medal system and totally devalues it, not knocking his ability as can play, but certainly others in comp are as good or better and until saafl want to take ownership of club umpire pool, install a fair system where a whole divisions umpires then umpire either the div above or below this type of blatant favouritism will continue to happen.

Season 2009 simple solution nominate 1 B Grade player to your club umpire who gets the 3 vote every game and if all other 9 clubs do the same will have a 10 club tie for the medal and really highlight the need for change and impartiality.

[Johno37]

i thought the away umpire gave the votes, or his views were the dominate ones.
i dunno

[zedman]

Has anyone noticed that the 'Top 4 medal contenders from each club' list, gave the players in descending order of votes attained?

Good work, SAAFL.

thought that last week and it was proven correct..we all knew a ff would win div 5..forth scudds and smith all top of the 4 in respective clubs

[nuggety goodness]

so when will clubs get lists of vote getters from each team? is that expected soon?

[BigDaddy]

All clubs should have picked up their list of votegetters last night

[carey]

D3 DG MC KAY MEDAL Craig Frinsdorf Old Ignatians
D4 AEC TRELOAR MEDAL Dale Laslett Portland
D5 JB DICKER MEDAL Adam Forth Greenacres
D6 AG BERT MEDAL Luke Warburton Westminster OS
Luke Warburton won the D6 Medal in 2006

D7 KC SIMS MEDAL Shaun Holland Paralowie
D1R EA DAVOREN MEDAL Ryan Bowman Henley
D2R EP NAZER MEDAL Phil Noble SMOSH Wst Lakes
Phil Noble won the D3RMedal in 2007
D3R HW MAIN MEDAL Darren Iron Salisbury
D4R CG TIDEMAN MEDAL Nicholas Kriewaldt Adelaide Lutheran
Nicholas Kriewaldt won the D5R Medal in 2007

D5R GP WILSON MEDAL Robert Brauer Plympton
D6R RH ELIX MEDAL Kosta Amanatidis Colonel Light Gdns
D7R FJ MONTEN MEDAL Wesley Legrand Adelaide University
C1 P COLLINS MEDAL Peter Uncle Tea Tree Gully
C2 JA BURCHELL MEDAL Shaun Lindholm Edwardstown
C3 RB LAMBERT MEDAL Jason Soar Flinders Park
Jason Soar won the D5 Medal in 1999

C4 HD NAYLOR MEDAL William Evans Adelaide University
C5 FS HONE MEDAL Phillip Jordan Golden Grove
U18 Yellow HJ MUTTON MEDAL Dene Steele Salisbury West
U18 Blue F COCKBURN MEDAL Shaun Hinsley North Haven
This is North Haven’s first under age SAAFL medal

well done to Phil Noble back to back medals. Good night bet a few lads are a bit under the weather today.

i'm still feeling very sick now mate had a huge night and i was'nt even guna drink!

[Johno37]

becuase i didnt win.. can i protest and ask for a recount?

[Pag]

Congrats to Daz Iron in D3R, had a really consistent year rucking almost 100% of the time, very much deserved.

[the trojan war]

Congrats to Daz Iron in D3R, had a really consistent year rucking almost 100% of the time, very much deserved.

Pag, How come your A's struggled yet were still able to produce a B grade medallist? You would think the club would give someone who's "consistent" and obviously fit if he's "rucking almost 100% of the time" ago in the 1's!

[Pag]

Congrats to Daz Iron in D3R, had a really consistent year rucking almost 100% of the time, very much deserved.

Pag, How come your A's struggled yet were still able to produce a B grade medallist? You would think the club would give someone who's "consistent" and obviously fit if he's "rucking almost 100% of the time" ago in the 1's!

B Grade have been a good side for a few years now mate, problem with the club seems to be we have a lot of good B grade footballers but not many who can step up and be consistent A graders. Some young blokes in there who will be good A Graders in 2-3 years but not enough at the moment to be competitive on a consistent basis in A3.

[The Lethal 1]

Is it no surprise that Wesley Legrand won again...if only he could win in a grade that doesn't use club umpires week to week, wouldn't get so many votes me thinks...

[The Ash Man]

Is it no surprise that Wesley Legrand won again...if only he could win in a grade that doesn't use club umpires week to week, wouldn't get so many votes me thinks...

exactly

[Bradman]

Is it no surprise that Wesley Legrand won again...if only he could win in a grade that doesn't use club umpires week to week, wouldn't get so many votes me thinks...

exactly

see him in the advertiser today!!!
with his six medals around his neck
Pfft

Would be nice if he made the comment that club umpires picked his name everyweek
what this does is taints everyone else who has won a medal as you wonder if any others have had their medals given to them such as him

[mypaddock]

Wes Legrand is clearly the best player in DIV 7 reserves and was clearly the best in DIV 6 reserves last yr. Yes the club umpires may vote for him as would other club umpires vote for their own players i would imagine. If the guy was an average footballer then yes you could question the validity of his medals but he is a cut above anybody else in the B/D grade. Should be playing higher but as stated before plays with his mates. And I have no affiliation with Uni whatsoever!

[Bradman]

Wes Legrand is clearly the best player in DIV 7 reserves and was clearly the best in DIV 6 reserves last yr. Yes the club umpires may vote for him as would other club umpires vote for their own players i would imagine. If the guy was an average footballer then yes you could question the validity of his medals but he is a cut above anybody else in the B/D grade. Should be playing higher but as stated before plays with his mates. And I have no affiliation with Uni whatsoever!

i dont know the bloke
not having a go at him as he doesnt put the votes in

But the 2 games i saw he was nowhere near the best 3 players on the day
not a hope
but yet he got a couple bog

as i said takes the gloss of it as you look and wonder what other games he got votes and shouldnt