SAAFL Div 5 & 5R (2009)

[Lightning McQueen]

I just read the Centrelink Cup write-up, the Smithfield part of it was around the mark, good to see Timmy Mac get a mention, could've possibly had a couple of others in there, not a bad effort for a stab in the dark. Obviously has done some homework, Fairhurst has been in and out recently with a niggling injury. There's no secret that Taylor and Bondy go alright, Meatbags slipped under the radar, Go you good thing.

[Lightning McQueen]

yeah no worries carey..tbh i wasnt trying to give sh1t to anyone in this whole debate..just having some fun with the writer..he had plenty of laughs off of us last year so it was payback

and ive wasted another half day at work

Ha, I get stroppy when I get interrupted whilst on here.

[Keepitreal]

When you see the criticism handled out here though, you can understand why they remain anon, particularly if they actually play.
A football writer becomes an easy target for verbal and physical confrontation in a game, I promise you that.

If the articles they submit refer personally or having digs at individuals that are totally false there should be some form of recourse, they shouldn't be allowed to continue and hide their identity but have the balls to sign their name to the crap they write and face the consequences or write well researched articles and not make them personal.

[Keepitreal]

i would certainly believe that DW..but really a writer shouldnt be a player..for the many reasons i wont bore you with

just for example and this was done quick..here are some posters

pulteney : heater31
plympton : jabber
rosewater : pigdog/bulldog_lover
blacks : sprint
wos : dragons/one eyed
elizabeth : dw/duncs?
kenilworth : laughing kookaburra/zedman
smithfield : LM
ingle farm : keepitreal
hope valley : valleys07/sdemon

i would think they could all be relied upon for good, accurate information

i dont believe keepitreal knows what his on about!!!!!!

Yeh your right, have previously stated that although he has built up some considerable girth, Dutchy can still find the footy.

[Dogwatcher]

When you see the criticism handled out here though, you can understand why they remain anon, particularly if they actually play.
A football writer becomes an easy target for verbal and physical confrontation in a game, I promise you that.

If the articles they submit refer personally or having digs at individuals that are totally false there should be some form of recourse, they shouldn't be allowed to continue and hide their identity but have the balls to sign their name to the crap they write and face the consequences or write well researched articles and not make them personal.

No argument there.

[Lightning McQueen]

Pulteney
Westminster
Plympton
Rosewater
Smithfield

[Jabber]

Everyone makes mistakes, however, I personally would avoid writing about specific players unless I was very sure about what I was writing about (ie. had seen for myself or had been given information). Plenty of other stuff to write about anyway.

I wrote an article in our club e-newsletter about a game where i said that a particular player played a blinder, because he had doen every game that year, and i'd done it before and it had been correct...

Turns out he was in melbourne that particular week...

With Chris Shep they would have just seent hat he was amongst the goals and whacked him in there i guess.

[hawkseye]

Pulteney
Westminster
Plympton
Rosewater
Smithfield

I will go the same LM except i will take HV

[valleys07]

Pulteney
Westminster
Plympton
Rosewater
Smithfield

I will go the same LM except i will take HV

Same LM

[pigdog]

Personally, I think Rosewater, Hope Valley & Elizabeth are just making up the numbers this year. They are good sides, but not great sides, and not good enough to challenge for a Div 4 berth.

Rosewater making up the number`s You idiot.

What a stupid comment PIGDOG. I think on our day we can match it with most sides, the thing is when is our day.... You should no Rosewater m8...

MATE no more beers for you i was calling the other guy an idiot for what he said . get with the program big fella

[Bradman]

Everyone makes mistakes, however, I personally would avoid writing about specific players unless I was very sure about what I was writing about (ie. had seen for myself or had been given information). Plenty of other stuff to write about anyway.

I wrote an article in our club e-newsletter about a game where i said that a particular player played a blinder, because he had doen every game that year, and i'd done it before and it had been correct...

Turns out he was in melbourne that particular week...

With Chris Shep they would have just seent hat he was amongst the goals and whacked him in there i guess.

You have written many a good article in your clubs newsletters
1 about 6 years ago was a classic re Roswater and Smithfield!

[Jabber]

Everyone makes mistakes, however, I personally would avoid writing about specific players unless I was very sure about what I was writing about (ie. had seen for myself or had been given information). Plenty of other stuff to write about anyway.

I wrote an article in our club e-newsletter about a game where i said that a particular player played a blinder, because he had doen every game that year, and i'd done it before and it had been correct...

Turns out he was in melbourne that particular week...

With Chris Shep they would have just seent hat he was amongst the goals and whacked him in there i guess.

You have written many a good article in your clubs newsletters
1 about 6 years ago was a classic re Roswater and Smithfield!

Yes.. that particular one certainly hit the headlines...

I actually had a look at that one a few months ago, couldnt believe that i wrote half the stuff i did!!!

[The Bartman]

Pulteney
Westminster
Plympton
Rosewater
Smithfield

I will go the same LM except i will take HV

Same LM

Yes please LM.

[MADDOG3]

Pulteney v Blackfriars OS... 21 points, could never write BOS off but Pulteney should get the chocolates at home
Kenilworth v Westminster OS... 45 points, Kookas will fight it out at home, but WOS too strong and will be keen to bounce back from last week
Ingle Farm v Plympton... 100 points, for Plympton, anything short of a GF this year is a failure
Rosewater v Hope Valley... 12 points, I'm gonna go a smokey with the Valleys, bout time they stood up
Elizabeth v Smithfield (shouldn't this always be match of the round?)... 25 points, time for Smithies to win one at Argana Park!!!

[Jimmy_041]

Pulteney v Blackfriars OS
Kenilworth v Westminster OS
Ingle Farm v Plympton
Rosewater v Hope Valley
Elizabeth v Smithfield

[Bully]

Pulteney v Blackfriars OS
Kenilworth v Westminster OS
Ingle Farm v Plympton
Rosewater v Hope Valley
Elizabeth v Smithfield

pultney
west minst
plympton
rosies
smithfield

[Lightning McQueen]

Everyone makes mistakes, however, I personally would avoid writing about specific players unless I was very sure about what I was writing about (ie. had seen for myself or had been given information). Plenty of other stuff to write about anyway.

I wrote an article in our club e-newsletter about a game where i said that a particular player played a blinder, because he had doen every game that year, and i'd done it before and it had been correct...

Turns out he was in melbourne that particular week...

With Chris Shep they would have just seent hat he was amongst the goals and whacked him in there i guess.

You have written many a good article in your clubs newsletters
1 about 6 years ago was a classic re Roswater and Smithfield!

Care to elaborate

[Lightning McQueen]

3 very handy inclusions this week for the Centrelink Cup, Andrew "Meaty's" Mathews wont have carry the side again, he'll still rack up 30+ touches though and snare a couple of majors.

[Jabber]

Everyone makes mistakes, however, I personally would avoid writing about specific players unless I was very sure about what I was writing about (ie. had seen for myself or had been given information). Plenty of other stuff to write about anyway.

I wrote an article in our club e-newsletter about a game where i said that a particular player played a blinder, because he had doen every game that year, and i'd done it before and it had been correct...

Turns out he was in melbourne that particular week...

With Chris Shep they would have just seent hat he was amongst the goals and whacked him in there i guess.

You have written many a good article in your clubs newsletters
1 about 6 years ago was a classic re Roswater and Smithfield!

Care to elaborate

Not really... if thats ok

Wasn't my finest hour

[Felch]

Everyone makes mistakes, however, I personally would avoid writing about specific players unless I was very sure about what I was writing about (ie. had seen for myself or had been given information). Plenty of other stuff to write about anyway.

I wrote an article in our club e-newsletter about a game where i said that a particular player played a blinder, because he had doen every game that year, and i'd done it before and it had been correct...

Turns out he was in melbourne that particular week...

With Chris Shep they would have just seent hat he was amongst the goals and whacked him in there i guess.

You have written many a good article in your clubs newsletters
1 about 6 years ago was a classic re Roswater and Smithfield!

Yes.. that particular one certainly hit the headlines...

I actually had a look at that one a few months ago, couldnt believe that i wrote half the stuff i did!!!

Was that the one that Rosies used to fire themselves up for that finals game at Rosewater Oval ? I remember seeing it copied and attached to light poles all around the ground. Interesting day that one, ended in a rather ugly brawl between supporters after the game.