SAAFl Div 6 & 6R (2009)

[Browny25]

who are you!?

[carey]

why must comments stop? isnt this a public forum? there have been some very good points made and i agree with alot of them i also think morell has conducted himself very well in reply but why must it stop? i didnt see anyone sticking up for harvey and CLG when they were getting smashed into on here? its a forum i thought thats what a site like this was about.

[carey]

Discussion contents reflect the views of individual participants only. SAFooty.net bears no responsibility for accuracy of participant comments and will bear no legal liability for discussion results.


would'nt this cover it?
from the bottom of your screen

[hawkseye]

Discussion contents reflect the views of individual participants only. SAFooty.net bears no responsibility for accuracy of participant comments and will bear no legal liability for discussion results.


would'nt this cover it?
from the bottom of your screen

This looks like it could get interesting.
I agree with you Carey.

[morell]

why must comments stop? isnt this a public forum? there have been some very good points made and i agree with alot of them i also think morell has conducted himself very well in reply but why must it stop? i didnt see anyone sticking up for harvey and CLG when they were getting smashed into on here? its a forum i thought thats what a site like this was about.

Your complaints about the first game between us this year were a perfectly valid criticism and I would not want that to stop, they were about a particular incident, with particular pieces of evidence, however;

The over general, exaggeration and character assassinations that have been prevalent over the past week really aren't necessary and are hurting a great many (innocent) people involved with the club. GEESKIP's post as an example.

[morell]

A pertinent article;

http://media.saafl.asn.au/footynews/?iId=75

[zedman]

i tend to agree with carey..ive seen farmers, ovies, kilburn,units and even my own club subjected to heaps..it is the internet..and they are opinions..censorship doesnt really work..and neither do threats to the sites owners..(although it seems to have done something)..a pack mentality can exist at times..you get that anywhere in a public forum on the net..you cant make people say what they dont think ..however unfair it may look it is the impression some get when they play mpfc..its hard to change and it only takes one stupid act to waste all the good ones..thats fact..thats what has to be drummed into any offenders head..your act just cost us a whole years worth of built up good work

we played mpfc in a trial this year and there was nothing all day..our impression is of a changed club, but..see how easily that can change with just one bad act..its not fair for you guys but its the way it is when you have a reputation..just ask LM and smithfield..they had done plenty to change their image and then some idiot goes and nearly puts it all back 3 years with one stupid act

peace

[morell]

Slander (or libel in this case) is still illegal. Regardless of any supposed freedom of expression an internet forum provides.

I post on BigFooty quite regularly, try and mention certain incidents or alleged incidents on there and you will be quickly banned. Forum hosts understand this risk which is why I think the owners of this site are rightfully treading very carefully.

[Dutchy]

OK Boys and Girls, some good points here and some worthwhile discussion, the one Ammo game I saw this year was MP v Lockleys and saw nothing untoward apart from a MP player giving it to some Lockleys fans after the win, personally Id be celebrating with my team mates but each to their own.

Just remember if there is a post on here that you have concerns over and/or have broken the site rules hit the Report Post button on the bottom right of each post and/or PM a Moderator. Every poster has a responsibility, Mods arent robots and dont read every single post suprisingly.

Thanks
Dutchy
on behalf of the Owners and Mods

[hawkseye]

Thats alot of posts Dutchy!

[zedman]

you gotta get the juniors back up and running..whilst a club has juniors it has a chance..old scholars feed off their schools..district clubs need juniors

Absolutely agree. It would help if you blokes stopped nicking them all!

yeah we are close geographically but any junior players we got this year from mpfc were because no teams were available on your end..now as for goodwood and edwardstown and mitcham..thats another story..they pillage and plunder like nobodys business

[Groover]

why must comments stop? isnt this a public forum? there have been some very good points made and i agree with alot of them i also think morell has conducted himself very well in reply but why must it stop? i didnt see anyone sticking up for harvey and CLG when they were getting smashed into on here? its a forum i thought thats what a site like this was about.

ah hem. . .

[carey]

why must comments stop? isnt this a public forum? there have been some very good points made and i agree with alot of them i also think morell has conducted himself very well in reply but why must it stop? i didnt see anyone sticking up for harvey and CLG when they were getting smashed into on here? its a forum i thought thats what a site like this was about.

ah hem. . .

WTF is ah hem?

[watchdog]

Thats alot of posts Dutchy!

WOW over 17,000 posts Dutchy!! That equates to 1 post per day for the last 47 years. How long has this website been running for, anyone know???

[pfranny]

.

Plus we had a broken nose and split jaw from two other cowardly acts.

This is a statement that has greatly angered many people at the club. The split jaw was a result from a head clash. Nothing but a football incident. The Mitchell Park player involved was also slightly injured, he is a life member of the club and has never once been reported, a fairer player you could not find.[quote]

this is wrong there was a head clash but that wasnt the incident that resulted in a split jaw...the one that did was when one of our players went to lay a tackle and your player raised his elbow was prob the most obvious of all that incidents that day and what gets me is he had the ball and prob also the opportunity to clear it from the defence but chose to do that instead and it resulted in a goal

[MW]

Who gives a f*&k honestly.
Toughen up people or go play another sport.
Every side has a combination of good fair players and ordinary thugs. Deal with it and move on.

[Groover]

why must comments stop? isnt this a public forum? there have been some very good points made and i agree with alot of them i also think morell has conducted himself very well in reply but why must it stop? i didnt see anyone sticking up for harvey and CLG when they were getting smashed into on here? its a forum i thought thats what a site like this was about.

ah hem. . .

WTF is ah hem?

Sorry was just meant to say that if u read a few pages back i have stood up for harve's and the CLGFC

[Ian]

How long has this website been running for, anyone know???

Oct 27, 2005

[dee man]

it is interesting to find people finding it strange that i take the time to talk to other teams after a game.their are a number reasons why i do this.i like to show my respect to players and coaches,whether we win,lose or draw.after spending two hours plotting a way to win ,i still have enough character to appreciate young men going to battle showing off the best game in the world.also if i can in any small way by my observations,help a player or even a coach improve or see something from a different point,i see that as my duty as a coach of football,if this against the grain of what is acceptable,then i have been waisting my time in this great game for over 30 years.hope this answers your question

Morell, Im a glenunga player and I can say with confidence that Saturdays game was nothing but a fair game with guys going in for hard balls and was a fair game....I thought MP were to be commended for their efforts and I saw nothing untoward about the club.

The coach at the end of the game was to be respected for coming over and giving us a talk about a similar situation their club went through.. Im not sure whether it was a clean contest because a few guys were out, but You guys were nothing but fair and the game was played in good spirit!!!

Does Mitchell Pks coach go over and talk to every club? Im sure i read he did to Paralowie and i know in the past he has done it to West Croydon. Does this come across as unusual to anyone? I know its the done thing after a GF.

[Jabber]

Jabber - why is it "highly unbelievable" to think that a Div6 A grade team couldnt beat a Div1r team?

Have you played Div 1R?

No but last year i umpired D2res, D4, D5, D6, D7 and i've made my observation on that, is that cool??