Your clubs B&F 2009 winners

[Felch]

voting in finals = dumb and unfair.

That's why you give awards for best players in finals series/grand final instead.

Why unfair ? If anything, finals votes should be worth double ! If we use your logic FC, then we wouldn't give weekly awards either

My view, is if you are playing a game for the club, as part of the premiership season, then votes should be given.

We did give votes during finals a couple of years ago (only B grade, as A grade weren't in) but last year went back to finishing b&f votes after minor round - i think this was more because our secretary couldnt be stuffed printing up more vote cards though. We had a 'Best Finals Player' trophy last year instead.

[bird of prey]

i think clubs should give votes for finals games too. as someone stated earlier, these are the games that matter, and the better players will always stand up in these games and deliver when the club wants them to. i reckon the more deserving winner is the guy who gets the votes against the better teams in the bigger games, as opposed to the front runners who just get votes against the weaker teams (hope nobody gets offended by that comment).
for example a full forward who kicks a bag of goals against 3 crap teams, but crumbles against the better teams is no use to anyone really (except the teams %)

[Punk Rooster]

my

R1-18- B&F
Finals- Player of the Finals Award

[CoverKing]

Absolute stupid not including finals IMO.

BnF's are for a teams best n fairest player throughout the year. That is every game that side plays in the year. which includes finals.

Obviously u cant do Brownlows and association medals over finals because not every side is playing.

I cant believe clubs dont include finals. What a joke

[Footy Chick]

Sorry, I'd just like to re-hash that counting finals at association level would be dumb and unfair.

What people do at club level is completely up to the individual club. However, my preference is the same as Punk Roosters, as I said above.

[The Riddler]

St Paul's OS

A Grade
1st - Lachlan Kennett
2nd - Ivan Novosel
3rd - Scott Mumford

B Grade
1st - Michael Miller
2nd - Paul Hurst
3rd - Trent Mumford

[Footy Chick]

No surprises there Riddler..

Scotty sticking around next year?

[The Riddler]

No surprises there Riddler..

Scotty sticking around next year?

According to him last night he says he'll still be a Sainter in 2010.

[steiger]

Port Districts A1R - Glen Schreiber

Of course the finals should be counted in the clubs B&F count

[Pag]

Salisbury's counts were held last night:

A Grade:
B&F - Scott McPherson
R/U - Shaun Rowe

B Grade:
B&F - Kevin Smyth
R/U - Robbie Miles

C Grade:
B&F - Steve Ireland/Rick Lee
R/U - Phillip Marsh

D Grade:
B&F - Luke Keenihan
R/U - Daniel Davies

U18:
B&F - Mark Robb
R/U - Blair McKenzie

C7:
B&F - Stuart Wilson
R/U - Shane Smith

[Lads]

So doesn't include finals then at Plympton?
Does that seem a bit odd to other sides? We included finals in '07.

Count should be 18 home and away rounds only, finals is its own reward for all players for their hard work over a season.

PIGSY says,
Ingle Farms BNF will be held at maccas, after that raspberries at jack in the box 4 every 1.mums n dads are welcome 2 attend.

[THE FUZZ]

paralowies b and f this sat night. if mark boothey dont win it ill do a noody run down to hollywood plaza and back
i am a huge fan of this bloke. is deff the best footballer i have played with in my short career. absolute gun.

[carey]

what is a noody run?

pff boothey would'nt even get drunk 2day?

and doesnt have a p/ship tattoo .......................

[carey]

is a gun tho. 100% of that

[carey]

still a P O O F tho

[THE FUZZ]

carey are u angry cos i said boo is the best player ive played with
its ok ur in my top 100

[unknown source]

Golden Grove awards were held a week ago

A's - Jimmy Kuhndt won easily with John Boxer (A4 medallist 70 votes behind in second)
B's - Jamie Borghardt won his 3rd B&F at the club
C's - Nathan McGregor
D's - Michael Jolly
Under 18's - Ben Potter won his second B&F in a row

was boxer a surprise winner in the medal for you guys?? where did Kuhndt play??

[unknown source]

paralowies b and f this sat night. if mark boothey dont win it ill do a noody run down to hollywood plaza and back
i am a huge fan of this bloke. is deff the best footballer i have played with in my short career. absolute gun.

if boo dont win it hes coming to the lodge

[Q.]

HDFC B&Fs

A Grade
B&F: Matt Newton
R/U: Dylan Dwyer

B Grade
B&F: Sean Bird
R/U: Todd Birch

No surprises there, Matty and Dylan both had a stellar year. Birdy was a stalwart in the Ressies and Birchy has really matured as a player, stepping up to be a vital player in the A Grade. Congratulations lads

[unknown source]

Brahma Lodge
A grade - Quniton Taylor
runner up - Luke Paterson

B grade - Danny Walton
Runner up - Groover