Rd 3 North vs Port Review Thread

[redandblack]

You think I'm the only biased poster on this topic?

You're telling me that North posters aren't biased about Alleway

I think I'm actually the only poster who actually has quoted facts to back up my argument.

PS: Big Phil has started a thread for this discussion.

[klaan]

You think I'm the only biased poster on this topic?

You're telling me that North posters aren't biased about Alleway

I think I'm actually the only poster who actually has quoted facts to back up my argument.

PS: Big Phil has started a thread for this discussion.

R & B, you would have to be the most biased poster on this whole site. It is clear that you have blind faith in everything that is West Adelaide and I applaud you for it.

What is clear is that all West Adelaide players are best in their position in the competition and Andy Collins is the best coach and a master manipulator of all of those around him including your good self!

I wish we had him at South when we had the chance a few years back.

[The Sleeping Giant]

You think I'm the only biased poster on this topic?

You're telling me that North posters aren't biased about Alleway

I think I'm actually the only poster who actually has quoted facts to back up my argument.

PS: Big Phil has started a thread for this discussion.

I like this one better.

Alleway is ahead of White. Alleway has had one bad game this year, and he was no orphan that night.

[johntheclaret]

Phil,

On the stats Radio had Alleway with 28 hit outs (I think it was you who said it?)
Stewart only kicked 1 point according to me, but if you add up the points on the stats they come to 15 anyway.

I thought you won free kick for a rushed behind these days. I don't recall North getting any frees and just on that, If you do get a free, where do you take it from ?

[Wedgie]

From the edge of the goal square mate, Sturt got one against us last week.

[redandblack]

West got one Saturday and it was taken from the behind line on that difficult angle.

PS: Thanks klaan, but the only West player I've said is the best in his position is Ferguson. I was laughed at for that (and still am), but most serious football judges agree with me. You're making up the rest, mate

[Wedgie]

Hmmm, my aplogies, it must he from where it gets taken out then, cheers.

[CENTURION]

Thanks for that, TSG.

It gives me the opportunity to compare Ferguson and Alleway's recent form.

Ferguson - State CHB and 2nd best on ground. Alleway?

Ferguson - Polled way ahead of Alleway or any other KPP in last year's MM. Alleway polled in only one game.

Round 1, 2010?

At one stage, a while ago, Alleway may well have been one of the very best KPP's, but I think his form over the last year or so has dropped off, possibly because he looked to have been playing injured. If he gets back to top form, he may well be again, but he certainly hasn't been for a long time. Given the choice between Alleway, Ferguson and Chambers, I'd think most would have Alleway 3rd.

I'm not sure he's even the best KPP at North Adelaide, let alone the League.

To answer one of your trademark posts, TSG:

if you think it's Alleway

Magarey Medal votes is possibly one of the worse ways to compare players.

Yeah, Ebert was shit & he won 4!

[beenreal]

Thanks for that, TSG.

It gives me the opportunity to compare Ferguson and Alleway's recent form.

Ferguson - State CHB and 2nd best on ground. Alleway?

Ferguson - Polled way ahead of Alleway or any other KPP in last year's MM. Alleway polled in only one game.

Round 1, 2010?

At one stage, a while ago, Alleway may well have been one of the very best KPP's, but I think his form over the last year or so has dropped off, possibly because he looked to have been playing injured. If he gets back to top form, he may well be again, but he certainly hasn't been for a long time. Given the choice between Alleway, Ferguson and Chambers, I'd think most would have Alleway 3rd.

I'm not sure he's even the best KPP at North Adelaide, let alone the League.

To answer one of your trademark posts, TSG:

if you think it's Alleway

Magarey Medal votes is possibly one of the worse ways to compare players.

Yeah, Ebert was **** & he won 4!

That comment is a clear demonstration of how the true "tongue in cheek" meaning of a post can get lost in electronic translation.

[CENTURION]

tongue in cheek? ok, ok, yes it was. I should have put in lol and and

[Big Phil]

Was interesting to hear Clint Alleway speak on the 5AA SANFL show last night. He mentioned that young Brad Robertson for the Magpies was a fomer student of his (Clint is a teacher at Salisbury High School) but also made mention that one his opponents, Magpies debutant Jamie Solly, was actually a current student of his.

Speaking of debutants, Scott Lycett was impressive on debut and at 203cm has very good skills and works well around the ground. I agree with Jeremy Clayton, who said on the same 5aAA show that he will go on to bigger things in the AFL.

I wonder if the Maggies had got up yesterday whether or not Mr Alleway would have marked young Jamie's work in a different way !!? ( )

It's not all that often, I would think, that a teacher and student would play against each other in league football ?

[the joker]

Was really impressed with both Lycett and Solly for the maggies. Certainly 2 players to watch out for in the future.

Ports Future or the Gold Coasts Future

[wycbloods]

Was interesting to hear Clint Alleway speak on the 5AA SANFL show last night. He mentioned that young Brad Robertson for the Magpies was a fomer student of his (Clint is a teacher at Salisbury High School) but also made mention that his direct opponent, 17 year old Magpies debutant Scott Lycett, was a current student of his.

Scott was impressive on debut and at 203cm has very good skills and works well around the grounds. I agree with Jeremy Clayton, who said on the same show, he will go on to bigger things in the AFL.

I wonder if the Maggies had got up yesterday whether or not Mr Alleway would have marked young Scott's work in a different way !!? ( )

It's not all that often, I would think, that a teacher and student would play against each other in league football ?

Pretty sure Mellor played against Didak when he was teaching him at blackfriars.

[the joker]

Was interesting to hear Clint Alleway speak on the 5AA SANFL show last night. He mentioned that young Brad Robertson for the Magpies was a fomer student of his (Clint is a teacher at Salisbury High School) but also made mention that his direct opponent, 17 year old Magpies debutant Scott Lycett, was a current student of his.

Scott was impressive on debut and at 203cm has very good skills and works well around the grounds. I agree with Jeremy Clayton, who said on the same show, he will go on to bigger things in the AFL.

I wonder if the Maggies had got up yesterday whether or not Mr Alleway would have marked young Scott's work in a different way !!? ( )

It's not all that often, I would think, that a teacher and student would play against each other in league football ?

Jim Solly is also a Student of his.

[Slots It Through]

Was interesting to hear Clint Alleway speak on the 5AA SANFL show last night. He mentioned that young Brad Robertson for the Magpies was a fomer student of his (Clint is a teacher at Salisbury High School) but also made mention that his direct opponent, 17 year old Magpies debutant Scott Lycett, was a current student of his.

Scott was impressive on debut and at 203cm has very good skills and works well around the grounds. I agree with Jeremy Clayton, who said on the same show, he will go on to bigger things in the AFL.

I wonder if the Maggies had got up yesterday whether or not Mr Alleway would have marked young Scott's work in a different way !!? ( )

It's not all that often, I would think, that a teacher and student would play against each other in league football ?

Jim Solly is also a Student of his.

I think Jim Solly and Scott Lycett go to different schools how can they both be a student of his?

[the joker]

Was interesting to hear Clint Alleway speak on the 5AA SANFL show last night. He mentioned that young Brad Robertson for the Magpies was a fomer student of his (Clint is a teacher at Salisbury High School) but also made mention that his direct opponent, 17 year old Magpies debutant Scott Lycett, was a current student of his.

Scott was impressive on debut and at 203cm has very good skills and works well around the grounds. I agree with Jeremy Clayton, who said on the same show, he will go on to bigger things in the AFL.

I wonder if the Maggies had got up yesterday whether or not Mr Alleway would have marked young Scott's work in a different way !!? ( )

It's not all that often, I would think, that a teacher and student would play against each other in league football ?

Jim Solly is also a Student of his.

I think Jim Solly and Scott Lycett go to different schools how can they both be a student of his?

Scott goes to Henley and Jamie goes to Salisbury so maybe Clint changed Schools over the summer. but Jamie has been one of his students.

[Big Phil]

I think Jim Solly and Scott Lycett go to different schools how can they both be a student of his?

Actually, I reckon it might have been Solly he was talking about now that I think of it...

Was getting my young Magpie debutants mixed up, will change the originial post

[Big Phil]

Scott goes to Henley and Jamie goes to Salisbury so maybe Clint changed Schools over the summer. but Jamie has been one of his students.

Nah, if it was Jamie that is at Salisbury High then it was him who Clint was talking about on radio last night, because I do remember him actually saying "I teach at Salisbury High"...

Have edited my original post, as mentioned above, was just getting my young Maggies players on debut mixed up...

[the joker]

Was interesting to hear Clint Alleway speak on the 5AA SANFL show last night. He mentioned that young Brad Robertson for the Magpies was a fomer student of his (Clint is a teacher at Salisbury High School) but also made mention that one his opponents, Magpies debutant Jamie Solly, was actually a current student of his.

Speaking of debutants, Scott Lycett was impressive on debut and at 203cm has very good skills and works well around the ground. I agree with Jeremy Clayton, who said on the same 5aAA show that he will go on to bigger things in the AFL.

I wonder if the Maggies had got up yesterday whether or not Mr Alleway would have marked young Jamie's work in a different way !!? ( )

It's not all that often, I would think, that a teacher and student would play against each other in league football ?

i am pretty sure that in Heals last year at Centrals he was a Teacher and David Kellett was one of his students, so they were teacher and student plus Team mates

[the joker]

Scott goes to Henley and Jamie goes to Salisbury so maybe Clint changed Schools over the summer. but Jamie has been one of his students.

Nah, if it was Jamie that is at Salisbury High then it was him who Clint was talking about on radio last night, because I do remember him actually saying "I teach at Salisbury High"...

Have edited my original post, as mentioned above, was just getting my young Maggies players on debut mixed up...

either way they will both be very good players for the Gold Coast