Adelaide and Suburban Cricket Association 2010/11

[Jabber]

I dont wear a thigh pad, but i know if it was brought up during a match and i was on either the fielding or batting side my response would be the same: "how about we just get on with the game"

Question about the rules: Is it legal to wear your thigh pad on the outside?
I forced a Mitchell Park batsman in Section 2 (official umpire) to remove it or put it on the inside.
I could have been wrong, the umpire didnt know but made him take it off.
Is it legal or should just be banned anyway because it looks pathetic?

Gee mate, that's a bit pedantic, if the player wants to look like a rabbit, let him.

[Tubby]

Yes i was extremely disapointed that it didnt get presented, especially after all the hard work that i and a few others had done to get it some meaning back into it. He shouldnt have had to look to far because i believe it is in our committee room.

It adds character to hand over a trophy to the opposition after you lose, and it was unfortunate that this was not done.

I can pass this onto the cricket director and have this presented to you guys in the most appropriate way possible. The bloke it was named after deserves it, and this time round you blokes deserve it too.

It is important that Plympton v Morphies continue the trophy, i know we have a lot of banter on here but generally its all in a bit of fun. Especially for a couple of clubs that, to be honest, haven't brought home a whole heap of silverware in section one of late, its good to play for something and get that intense finals-like feeling going.

Jabber / Plympton Forum users,

Wouldn't happen to know where the " Mosse Harley Trophy " is would you, we asked about it after the game on the weekend but your Captain wasn't to keen on looking for it.

Cheers Jabber !!!

[Booney]

Well done Bradman didn't take you long to resort to name calling.

No response i see as to how your team mates carried on after the game?

Must be proud of that behaviour.

oh cmon
twat is name calling?? seriously!
how do you reckon you would carry on with something as petty as that in a section 4 game
ive played plenty of cricket in my life and at alot higher level and have seen worse things handled alot better than that.

if we carried on that bad why didnt they report anyone?
telling them they were unsportmanlike and that we wouldnt shake hands not a big deal i wouldnt think.
anyway life goes on

Who is the Belair captain in question Brad.Man.?

[Gowser]

Very dissapointed with the spirit of todays game, I expect my boys to not put any pressure on there mates who are umpiring. Left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth.

Especially to save 1 lousy point.

Regardless of how bad a decision was, surely you can't expect batsmen to walk on LBW decisions?

[caleb777]

Batsman cant walk on lbws! thats ridiculous. There is no person in a better position then the umpire.

[Jabber]

Who on earth would walk on an LBW decision?

And what bowler in ASCA actually expects to get an LBW decision?

It baffles me when bowlers throw thier arms up in the air, wicket keepers stand with hands on hips, and captains are shaking heads after LB's are turned down. I reckon you need to be almost straddling the stumps witht he ball hitting your ankle on the full before i'll cry foul of an LB decision.

1. When you have a proper umpire sometimes they come out with the most bewildering decisions on LB, i'd rather them not give any of them. The first thing you do when you have a proper ump is appeal for everything, because you've got no idea what kind of decision they are going to come up with.

2. If you are umpiring yourself you know that its going to have to be extremely plum to get the decision, if you dont get it, then move on.

Batsman cant walk on lbws! thats ridiculous. There is no person in a better position then the umpire.

[CoverKing]

I pretty much walked on Sunday! I would be very suprised if I see another lbw more out than I was on Sunday!

[Amateur Footy]

I pretty much walked on Sunday! I would be very suprised if I see another lbw more out than I was on Sunday!

That would make 2 LBWs in 2 days

[Westsider]

Very dissapointed with the spirit of todays game, I expect my boys to not put any pressure on there mates who are umpiring. Left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth.

Especially to save 1 lousy point.

Regardless of how bad a decision was, surely you can't expect batsmen to walk on LBW decisions?

Who said he should walk, the umpire should have been a man instead of a pussy and gave it out, its was that plumb! Both of them were. Apparently hitting below the knee roll of a batsman wearing keeping pads is too high. What a freaking joke.

How about when you play a cut shot and absolutely smash it with the edge to the keeper and dont walk because the umpire is young kid.

Hope you enjoy the 1 point guys. You ******* deserved it.

[bazza1]

Very dissapointed with the spirit of todays game, I expect my boys to not put any pressure on there mates who are umpiring. Left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth.

Especially to save 1 lousy point.

Regardless of how bad a decision was, surely you can't expect batsmen to walk on LBW decisions?

Where did I mention an LBW in my post? Sure there were a couple questionable decisions re LBW but I was referring to a caught behind decision.
Your getting confused with Facebook Convos Gowsy


Rusty should of walked tho

[smithy]

Who on earth would walk on an LBW decision?

.

Happened in the SCA, early 80's Jabber.
I'm sure you can appreciate what Paul Kinnear was bowling like at the time.
He was the bowler in question, the batsman from Porties shall remain anonymous on here but he's still reminded of it every year.

[Bulldogs007]

Jabber / Plympton Forum users,

Wouldn't happen to know where the " Mosse Harley Trophy " is would you, we asked about it after the game on the weekend but your Captain wasn't to keen on looking for it.

Get your facts right mate, the captain was asked if the presentation was going ahead and seeing most of the Plympton lads had left to go home and have a shower etc the decision was made not to have it....Nothing about where is the trophy.....you got a good reliabe source there mate.

[woodublieve12]

Yes i was extremely disapointed that it didnt get presented, especially after all the hard work that i and a few others had done to get it some meaning back into it. He shouldnt have had to look to far because i believe it is in our committee room.

It adds character to hand over a trophy to the opposition after you lose, and it was unfortunate that this was not done.

I can pass this onto the cricket director and have this presented to you guys in the most appropriate way possible. The bloke it was named after deserves it, and this time round you blokes deserve it too.

It is important that Plympton v Morphies continue the trophy, i know we have a lot of banter on here but generally its all in a bit of fun. Especially for a couple of clubs that, to be honest, haven't brought home a whole heap of silverware in section one of late, its good to play for something and get that intense finals-like feeling going.

Jabber / Plympton Forum users,

Wouldn't happen to know where the " Mosse Harley Trophy " is would you, we asked about it after the game on the weekend but your Captain wasn't to keen on looking for it.

very well put jabber...

[woodublieve12]

Who on earth would walk on an LBW decision?

And what bowler in ASCA actually expects to get an LBW decision?

It baffles me when bowlers throw thier arms up in the air, wicket keepers stand with hands on hips, and captains are shaking heads after LB's are turned down. I reckon you need to be almost straddling the stumps witht he ball hitting your ankle on the full before i'll cry foul of an LB decision.

1. When you have a proper umpire sometimes they come out with the most bewildering decisions on LB, i'd rather them not give any of them. The first thing you do when you have a proper ump is appeal for everything, because you've got no idea what kind of decision they are going to come up with.

2. If you are umpiring yourself you know that its going to have to be extremely plum to get the decision, if you dont get it, then move on.

Batsman cant walk on lbws! thats ridiculous. There is no person in a better position then the umpire.

im not sure whats goin on jabber but that is 2 posts i agree with....

[3RUNS-SHORT]

WYC's off season recruiting drive has paid off

2 games in mate. still a long year ahead!

[woodublieve12]

Jabber / Plympton Forum users,

Wouldn't happen to know where the " Mosse Harley Trophy " is would you, we asked about it after the game on the weekend but your Captain wasn't to keen on looking for it.

Get your facts right mate, the captain was asked if the presentation was going ahead and seeing most of the Plympton lads had left to go home and have a shower etc the decision was made not to have it....Nothing about where is the trophy.....you got a good reliabe source there mate.

just a quick query, why weren't the pfcc lads told to wait til after the trophy presentation to get changed or go home????

[Gowser]

Very dissapointed with the spirit of todays game, I expect my boys to not put any pressure on there mates who are umpiring. Left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth.

Especially to save 1 lousy point.

Regardless of how bad a decision was, surely you can't expect batsmen to walk on LBW decisions?

Where did I mention an LBW in my post? Sure there were a couple questionable decisions re LBW but I was referring to a caught behind decision.
Your getting confused with Facebook Convos Gowsy

Not at all my friend. Just making a point is all.
PS: I also had some discussions on Sunday a person involved during that game (RE: our convo) and will take this to the committee. The response i got on Sunday was inexcusable, embarrassing and unacceptable.

[wycbloods]

I pretty much walked on Sunday! I would be very suprised if I see another lbw more out than I was on Sunday!

That would make 2 LBWs in 2 days

I don't think the BBW from Saturday counts AF.

[CoverKing]

I pretty much walked on Sunday! I would be very suprised if I see another lbw more out than I was on Sunday!

That would make 2 LBWs in 2 days

that it would! Although I don't think I was out Sunday but ohwell! Hopefully i get some luk next week (and not a opening partner that wants to get revenge and run me out)

[Moe]

I pretty much walked on Sunday! I would be very suprised if I see another lbw more out than I was on Sunday!

That would make 2 LBWs in 2 days

that it would! Although I don't think I was out Sunday but ohwell! Hopefully i get some luk next week (and not a opening partner that wants to get revenge and run me out)

Errrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr........... This one confuses Moe CK. Were you out LBW on Sunday in your opinion or not?