Round 15 - live scores, results & shooting the breeze.

[Johno6]

Finally got a call right.

Either team under 15...... If only I backed it.

[Jim05]

That's the result we wanted!! Well done Geelong

Making up numbers like us.
Both of us would be smashed in a final, would rather not make it

[mighty_tiger_79]

So predictible, mob of pea hearts. We were never going to win that. Thompson once again sits on his hands while its going pear shaped.

Do you wanna trade coaches???

[Jim05]

So predictible, mob of pea hearts. We were never going to win that. Thompson once again sits on his hands while its going pear shaped.

Do you wanna trade coaches???

Thompson is rubbish, just doesnt try anything and if either of the Scott brothers stepped foot near the club id rip up my membership.

[mighty_tiger_79]

So you don't want to trade? ?

surely he is better than hird??

jim, your bombers might not be traveling that well but the cats arent much better at the minute

[Coach Bombay]

That's the result we wanted!! Well done Geelong

Making up numbers like us.
Both of us would be smashed in a final, would rather not make it

True jimmy, but hope is better than no hope at all, especially if you want players to commit long term.

[Jim05]

So you don't want to trade? ?

surely he is better than hird??

jim, your bombers might not be traveling that well but the cats arent much better at the minute

Hird atleast had us winning.
Thompson is useless, plays guys out of position constantly, team selection is a joke and he just sits on his hands all game.
Fine to sit all smug and content in the box when your winning but when you are losing I want to punch him in the mouth

[Rik E Boy]

That's the result we wanted!! Well done Geelong

Making up numbers like us.
Both of us would be smashed in a final, would rather not make it

Fancy a Norwood supporter saying this. In 1984 we were 3-6 and miles off it. Yeah, I don't think either side could win the flag but in every final the pressure goes up and you need to get finals into younger players.

I'd rather see us make the eight thanks,

regards,

REB

[Jim05]

That's the result we wanted!! Well done Geelong

Making up numbers like us.
Both of us would be smashed in a final, would rather not make it

Fancy a Norwood supporter saying this. In 1984 we were 3-6 and miles off it. Yeah, I don't think either side could win the flag but in every final the pressure goes up and you need to get finals into younger players.

I'd rather see us make the eight thanks,

regards,

REB

Final 5 is differant, neutral grounds aswell.
In this current setup there is absolutely no hope of 7th or 8th ever making a GF let alone win it. Id rather us put the cue in the rack and start playing kids instead of hasbeens like Chapman

[Rik E Boy]

I realise this Jim. My point is that when you put the cue in the Rack you lose that winning culture. I want to know that the Cats are out there trying to win every match. You can play the kids when finals are off the agenda. I reckon Carlton put the cue in the rack and they lost that winning culture that they had during the last century. They may never get that back.

Putting the cue in the rack is bullshit. I'd rather Murdoch, Horlin-Smith, Guthrie, Kersten and Simpson played in a final. Win or lose.

regards,

REB

[Jim05]

I realise this Jim. My point is that when you put the cue in the Rack you lose that winning culture. I want to know that the Cats are out there trying to win every match. You can play the kids when finals are off the agenda. I reckon Carlton put the cue in the rack and they lost that winning culture that they had during the last century. They may never get that back.

Putting the cue in the rack is bullshit. I'd rather Murdoch, Horlin-Smith, Guthrie, Kersten and Simpson played in a final. Win or lose.

regards,

REB

At this point of the season we are better off playing all the kids and see how they go even if it sacrifices wins.
Id rather not win another game for the season and give 7 or 8 kids a go than play old guys for maybe a couple of more wins at best

[LaughingKookaburra]

Carlton lost that culture because paying blokes under the counter became frowned upon.

And the culture terminology is bullshit. These cultures last a max 8-10 years and then you are back to square 1 and are scrubbers again (unless you get an allowance to compensate). You either got the cattle or you don't and that cattle needs to have desire to win the thing.

[bennymacca]

So you don't want to trade? ?

surely he is better than hird??

jim, your bombers might not be traveling that well but the cats arent much better at the minute

Hird atleast had us winning.
Thompson is useless, plays guys out of position constantly, team selection is a joke and he just sits on his hands all game.
Fine to sit all smug and content in the box when your winning but when you are losing I want to punch him in the mouth

You do realise that's because you cheated, correct?

[smac]

Thanks for the update, your honour.

[Rik E Boy]

Carlton lost that culture because paying blokes under the counter became frowned upon.

And the culture terminology is bullshit. These cultures last a max 8-10 years and then you are back to square 1 and are scrubbers again (unless you get an allowance to compensate). You either got the cattle or you don't and that cattle needs to have desire to win the thing.

Something that is bullshit lasts for eight to ten years? Youve just contradicted yourself. Carlton tanked and thought they could just switch it back on. When they did have a reasonable side again they couldn't even make a prelim. I disagree with you Kooka, I think there is plenty in the concept of a winning culture in Football and I believe all clubs at all levels try to attain it.

Regards,

REB

[JK]

I agree REB, there's also instances where culture impedes progress too .. St Kilda and Richmond always come to mind over the last 30 odd years. To be fair to the Saints, they were beaten in the biggy by 2 pretty exceptional sides, but prior to that they were more a night club than footy club.

[whufc]

What about Hodgeys call

"thats right it's ******* Gaz, gotta look after ******* gaz"

[saintal]

1/4 time

St K 1.2
Rich 6.2

Embarrassing first term. Cotchin with 3.

[Jim05]

Hawks by 76
Cyril with another hammy injury

[carey]

What about Hodgeys call

"thats right it's ******* Gaz, gotta look after ******* gaz"

What was all that about WHUFC? Did I miss something?