by morell » Mon Jul 24, 2017 9:51 am
by The Bedge » Mon Jul 24, 2017 10:07 am
Dolphin Treasure wrote:Your an attention seeking embarsement..
by morell » Mon Jul 24, 2017 10:13 am
You've changed man.Zartan wrote:Would like to unreservedly, wholeheartedly apologise for my behavior Sat night, and for my stupid, disrespectful and insensitive posts.
I'm sorry to anyone that I may have offended, and in particular the Pulteney FC who didn't deserve that, and i'm extremely disappointed and embarrassed by my actions.
I'm also sorry to the IFFC for any unwanted attention it placed on the club, and any poor public perception it received as a result.
by Robb_Stark » Mon Jul 24, 2017 10:23 am
Zartan wrote:Would like to unreservedly, wholeheartedly apologise for my behavior Sat night, and for my stupid, disrespectful and insensitive posts.
I'm sorry to anyone that I may have offended, and in particular the Pulteney FC who didn't deserve that, and i'm extremely disappointed and embarrassed by my actions.
I'm also sorry to the IFFC for any unwanted attention it placed on the club, and any poor public perception it received as a result.
by cossi11 » Mon Jul 24, 2017 10:25 am
by morell » Mon Jul 24, 2017 10:57 am
Umpires overruling from 200m away when they're half blind to begin with is one of my biggest pet peeves. Have respect for your peer and colleague. Only time is if asked IMO. If you think you've seen something the other umpire hasn't, blow your whistle and have a quick chat but leave the call to the umpire who has control over the game.cossi11 wrote:Rather interesting outcome to a goal umpiring decision in our game on the weekend.
Brahma Lodge had a shot at goal and I wasn't in line with it but it did look like a point from where I was but the goal umpire gave it a goal (wasn't the BLFC goal umpire, so either league or ML goal umpire). The field umpire who was not in control of the play, who appeared to be more in line with the kick from the middle of the ground blew his whistle and ran in and overruled the decision to give it a goal. The field umpire that was in the forward 50 then blew his whistle and said 'you can't overrule from there' and then reversed it. It looked like he overruled an overrule haha
Later on I heard that apparently the field umpire in the forward 50 asked the goal umpire what his decision was and he said something like 'he said it is a point so i'll give it a point' to which the umpire responded, 'no what was your decision' and he said 'I thought it was a goal' so the umpire paid the all clear.
by ezydoesitbigfella » Mon Jul 24, 2017 12:16 pm
cossi11 wrote:Rather interesting outcome to a goal umpiring decision in our game on the weekend.
Brahma Lodge had a shot at goal and I wasn't in line with it but it did look like a point from where I was but the goal umpire gave it a goal (wasn't the BLFC goal umpire, so either league or ML goal umpire). The field umpire who was not in control of the play, who appeared to be more in line with the kick from the middle of the ground blew his whistle and ran in and overruled the decision to give it a goal. The field umpire that was in the forward 50 then blew his whistle and said 'you can't overrule from there' and then reversed it. It looked like he overruled an overrule haha
Later on I heard that apparently the field umpire in the forward 50 asked the goal umpire what his decision was and he said something like 'he said it is a point so i'll give it a point' to which the umpire responded, 'no what was your decision' and he said 'I thought it was a goal' so the umpire paid the all clear.
by Dogwatcher » Mon Jul 24, 2017 12:28 pm
Q. wrote:Hearing Fitzroy a-grade coach has walked, frustrated at certain players not wanting to play a's
by Dogwatcher » Mon Jul 24, 2017 12:35 pm
morell wrote:I'll be a bit against the grain here ... unlike me I know.
I reckon 15 is old enough to be a goal umpire. Whilst I would never condone abuse and I feel for him, it's a great life lesson that he's learnt and will hold him in good stead in the future.
My advise would be - back him in, pony up and put him there again.
Like falling off a bike, for a terrible analogy.
by carey » Mon Jul 24, 2017 1:08 pm
morell wrote:You've changed man.Zartan wrote:Would like to unreservedly, wholeheartedly apologise for my behavior Sat night, and for my stupid, disrespectful and insensitive posts.
I'm sorry to anyone that I may have offended, and in particular the Pulteney FC who didn't deserve that, and i'm extremely disappointed and embarrassed by my actions.
I'm also sorry to the IFFC for any unwanted attention it placed on the club, and any poor public perception it received as a result.
by human_torpedo » Tue Jul 25, 2017 8:55 am
by lovetotalkfooty » Tue Jul 25, 2017 1:47 pm
by old farmer » Tue Jul 25, 2017 1:58 pm
human_torpedo wrote:Absolutely shattered to have missed out on a Zartan alcohol fuelled posting spree. Only 1 other does it better, and that's the great man who posted above, nothing beats an after midnight Carey post or 2!!
I do find the whole goal umpiring saga interesting, given the grief I copped for having a boundary umpire who was alleged by Ingle Farm to be 'too young' to do it.. He was 20 years old at the time. That was in a B grade game as well. FWIW, I have seen 40 year old men umpire on field and in goal make dubious calls under pressure, so I don't think its fair to throw a kid under the bus, when professionals still require the help of video replays to make calls up to 6 times a game..
Lets hope Pulteney can recover from this massive blow, only 2 games plus 8% clear on top with 3 games to play now......... They should feel real hard done by, could be season defining
by human_torpedo » Tue Jul 25, 2017 2:10 pm
old farmer wrote:human_torpedo wrote:Absolutely shattered to have missed out on a Zartan alcohol fuelled posting spree. Only 1 other does it better, and that's the great man who posted above, nothing beats an after midnight Carey post or 2!!
I do find the whole goal umpiring saga interesting, given the grief I copped for having a boundary umpire who was alleged by Ingle Farm to be 'too young' to do it.. He was 20 years old at the time. That was in a B grade game as well. FWIW, I have seen 40 year old men umpire on field and in goal make dubious calls under pressure, so I don't think its fair to throw a kid under the bus, when professionals still require the help of video replays to make calls up to 6 times a game..
Lets hope Pulteney can recover from this massive blow, only 2 games plus 8% clear on top with 3 games to play now......... They should feel real hard done by, could be season defining
HAHAHAHAHA , your boundary umpire looked 5 years old not 20. Would have easily had anyone asking where his parents were. Anyway, please, comments on goal umpires from Trinity. Best you just leave it alone. I would back my kid in over anyone i have ever seen you guys produce.
Hope you are popping down for finals this year HT. you have been sorely missed by many.
Just make sure it is week 1.
by Views From the US » Tue Jul 25, 2017 2:58 pm
lovetotalkfooty wrote:Here is the ladder after 15 rounds:
Division 6 Ladder
26 - Pulteney (ELIZ, BL, TOS) - Do they rest any players before finals? Do they keep try new things before finals?
22 - Elizabeth (PUL, IF, BL) - Tough 3 weeks. Can they get revenge against all 3 teams who beat them last time?
22 - Brahma Lodge (WC, PUL, ELIZ) - Two tough away contests and the top side at home. Can they win 2 to lock in a top 3 spot?
20 - Ingle Farm (SW, ELIZ, HD) - Form team only having to play 1 finals side. Can they get enough percentage to finish 2nd?
20 - Trinity OS (ML, WC, PUL) - Can thy go 3-0 and finish in top 3? Percentage will go against them but can they get a home final?
2 games that will decided top 3. Brahma V Elizabeth, Ingle Farm V Elizabeth
Anyone wanna have a crack at how they will think it will finish and what the first week of the finals will look like.
by The Informer » Tue Jul 25, 2017 3:01 pm
Views From the US wrote:lovetotalkfooty wrote:Here is the ladder after 15 rounds:
Division 6 Ladder
26 - Pulteney (ELIZ, BL, TOS) - Do they rest any players before finals? Do they keep try new things before finals?
22 - Elizabeth (PUL, IF, BL) - Tough 3 weeks. Can they get revenge against all 3 teams who beat them last time?
22 - Brahma Lodge (WC, PUL, ELIZ) - Two tough away contests and the top side at home. Can they win 2 to lock in a top 3 spot?
20 - Ingle Farm (SW, ELIZ, HD) - Form team only having to play 1 finals side. Can they get enough percentage to finish 2nd?
20 - Trinity OS (ML, WC, PUL) - Can thy go 3-0 and finish in top 3? Percentage will go against them but can they get a home final?
2 games that will decided top 3. Brahma V Elizabeth, Ingle Farm V Elizabeth
Anyone wanna have a crack at how they will think it will finish and what the first week of the finals will look like.
Think you have to include Pulteney's games with Elizabeth, Brahma, and Trinity as games that will decide top 3. Plenty of scenarios are possible pending the result of those three games involving the ladder leader.
Before Round 18, if Pulteney lose next two;
Elizabeth beat IF, would have Pul, BL, Eli on 26 points, TOS 24, IF 22.
IF beat Eliz, Pul BL 26, Eliz IF TOS 24.
If Pulteney win next two;
Ladder could look like PUL 30 Eliza (24 or 22), BL 24, TOS 24, IF (22 or 24).
Then its all to play for in Round 18 with Pul v TOS and BL v Eliz
As Bruce would say, special few weeks coming up!
Speaking of umpires, a certain div 6 captain was penalized for throwing grass in the air as he was about to take a set shot for goal. Umpire blew his whistle and signalled a ball up. Did not know that you couldn’t throw in the air. Have I missed a rule change?!?
by Views From the US » Tue Jul 25, 2017 4:20 pm
The_Informer wrote:Views From the US wrote:lovetotalkfooty wrote:Here is the ladder after 15 rounds:
Division 6 Ladder
26 - Pulteney (ELIZ, BL, TOS) - Do they rest any players before finals? Do they keep try new things before finals?
22 - Elizabeth (PUL, IF, BL) - Tough 3 weeks. Can they get revenge against all 3 teams who beat them last time?
22 - Brahma Lodge (WC, PUL, ELIZ) - Two tough away contests and the top side at home. Can they win 2 to lock in a top 3 spot?
20 - Ingle Farm (SW, ELIZ, HD) - Form team only having to play 1 finals side. Can they get enough percentage to finish 2nd?
20 - Trinity OS (ML, WC, PUL) - Can thy go 3-0 and finish in top 3? Percentage will go against them but can they get a home final?
2 games that will decided top 3. Brahma V Elizabeth, Ingle Farm V Elizabeth
Anyone wanna have a crack at how they will think it will finish and what the first week of the finals will look like.
Think you have to include Pulteney's games with Elizabeth, Brahma, and Trinity as games that will decide top 3. Plenty of scenarios are possible pending the result of those three games involving the ladder leader.
Before Round 18, if Pulteney lose next two;
Elizabeth beat IF, would have Pul, BL, Eli on 26 points, TOS 24, IF 22.
IF beat Eliz, Pul BL 26, Eliz IF TOS 24.
If Pulteney win next two;
Ladder could look like PUL 30 Eliza (24 or 22), BL 24, TOS 24, IF (22 or 24).
Then its all to play for in Round 18 with Pul v TOS and BL v Eliz
As Bruce would say, special few weeks coming up!
Speaking of umpires, a certain div 6 captain was penalized for throwing grass in the air as he was about to take a set shot for goal. Umpire blew his whistle and signalled a ball up. Did not know that you couldn’t throw in the air. Have I missed a rule change?!?
So how long have you been tied up with Trinity for?
by old farmer » Tue Jul 25, 2017 4:26 pm
human_torpedo wrote:old farmer wrote:human_torpedo wrote:Absolutely shattered to have missed out on a Zartan alcohol fuelled posting spree. Only 1 other does it better, and that's the great man who posted above, nothing beats an after midnight Carey post or 2!!
I do find the whole goal umpiring saga interesting, given the grief I copped for having a boundary umpire who was alleged by Ingle Farm to be 'too young' to do it.. He was 20 years old at the time. That was in a B grade game as well. FWIW, I have seen 40 year old men umpire on field and in goal make dubious calls under pressure, so I don't think its fair to throw a kid under the bus, when professionals still require the help of video replays to make calls up to 6 times a game..
Lets hope Pulteney can recover from this massive blow, only 2 games plus 8% clear on top with 3 games to play now......... They should feel real hard done by, could be season defining
HAHAHAHAHA , your boundary umpire looked 5 years old not 20. Would have easily had anyone asking where his parents were. Anyway, please, comments on goal umpires from Trinity. Best you just leave it alone. I would back my kid in over anyone i have ever seen you guys produce.
Hope you are popping down for finals this year HT. you have been sorely missed by many.
Just make sure it is week 1.
Im pretty sure if you read my post you will see I was I agreeing with you re the goal umpiring situation.. But anyway
by human_torpedo » Tue Jul 25, 2017 4:34 pm
old farmer wrote:human_torpedo wrote:old farmer wrote:human_torpedo wrote:Absolutely shattered to have missed out on a Zartan alcohol fuelled posting spree. Only 1 other does it better, and that's the great man who posted above, nothing beats an after midnight Carey post or 2!!
I do find the whole goal umpiring saga interesting, given the grief I copped for having a boundary umpire who was alleged by Ingle Farm to be 'too young' to do it.. He was 20 years old at the time. That was in a B grade game as well. FWIW, I have seen 40 year old men umpire on field and in goal make dubious calls under pressure, so I don't think its fair to throw a kid under the bus, when professionals still require the help of video replays to make calls up to 6 times a game..
Lets hope Pulteney can recover from this massive blow, only 2 games plus 8% clear on top with 3 games to play now......... They should feel real hard done by, could be season defining
HAHAHAHAHA , your boundary umpire looked 5 years old not 20. Would have easily had anyone asking where his parents were. Anyway, please, comments on goal umpires from Trinity. Best you just leave it alone. I would back my kid in over anyone i have ever seen you guys produce.
Hope you are popping down for finals this year HT. you have been sorely missed by many.
Just make sure it is week 1.
Im pretty sure if you read my post you will see I was I agreeing with you re the goal umpiring situation.. But anyway
by carey » Tue Jul 25, 2017 5:02 pm
human_torpedo wrote:Absolutely shattered to have missed out on a Zartan alcohol fuelled posting spree. Only 1 other does it better, and that's the great man who posted above, nothing beats an after midnight Carey post or 2
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |