StrayDog wrote:marbles wrote:morell wrote:Ohhhh Fanny.
It's so weird how much I like you. Reminds me of marbles.
fanny is very lovable
I reckon you're right. I've never met one that I didn't like.
Snatched the words right from my mouth.
by Magellan » Tue Mar 20, 2018 2:59 am
StrayDog wrote:marbles wrote:morell wrote:Ohhhh Fanny.
It's so weird how much I like you. Reminds me of marbles.
fanny is very lovable
I reckon you're right. I've never met one that I didn't like.
by Grenville » Tue Mar 20, 2018 5:00 am
Magellan wrote:StrayDog wrote:marbles wrote:morell wrote:Ohhhh Fanny.
It's so weird how much I like you. Reminds me of marbles.
fanny is very lovable
I reckon you're right. I've never met one that I didn't like.
Snatched the words right from my mouth.
by johntheclaret » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:15 am
morell wrote:You can't be this thick.UK Fan wrote:Booney wrote:The SANFL aren't the governing body, the SA Football Commission is.
Let's just clear that up so UK stops posting it.
http://websites.sportstg.com/get_file.cgi?id=3477014
Just quoting the laws of the game
Do AFL teams play under AFL or SANFL rules when in SA?
by Magellan » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:20 am
Grenville wrote:Magellan wrote:StrayDog wrote:marbles wrote:fanny is very lovable
I reckon you're right. I've never met one that I didn't like.
Snatched the words right from my mouth.
Clam up you two, stop flapping your lips.
by johntheclaret » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:28 am
Booney wrote:Semantics and UK's lack of understanding aside, does anyone actually believe the SANFL ( SA Football Commission ) will tell the AFL what's happening with Port and Adelaide's SANFL sides and the AFL will accept it?
I go back to my earlier point, Port Adelaide is one of several clubs to state they have not had any discussions with the AFL about a national reserves competition, not since 2014 anyway.
by jo172 » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:29 am
UK Fan wrote:jo172 wrote:UK Fan wrote:Booney wrote:Semantics and UK's lack of understanding aside, does anyone actually believe the SANFL ( SA Football Commission ) will tell the AFL what's happening with Port and Adelaide's SANFL sides and the AFL will accept it?
I go back to my earlier point, Port Adelaide is one of several clubs to state they have not had any discussions with the AFL about a national reserves competition, not since 2014 anyway.
I'm not the one making up everything changed in 1990. As per my link updated by the afl in 2015.
SANFL/Safc yet again I believe JTC covered off on that technicality yesterday.
SANFL with Olsen in charge will roll over we all know they will.
All you've shown is a misunderstanding of the word "govern" and refused to even attempt to engage with the numerous ways above you've been proven wrong
Blah blah
What part of what jTC explained to u so eloquently yesterday didn't you understand.
by johntheclaret » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:50 am
morell wrote:It was a simpler time em dubs, back then the SANFL was boss and things were clear.MW wrote:morell wrote:Man I wish I was still stuck in 1989.
Listen to some Tears for Fears. Watch the Goonies and then Major League when mum wasn't looking. Pour over the Beckett only to realise my cards sucked. Play some knock off Pac Man on my Atari.
Good times man, good times.
Why are you describing my childhood?
Then this whole fangdangled Victorian league came along and dang they just ruined it all!!
Soon enough they'll be running their own reserves league!
Don't they know the "N" stands for National!!
by johntheclaret » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:52 am
Magellan wrote:morell wrote:Don't they know the "N" stands for National!!
To distinguish the game of 'Australian Rules' from other codes who also went by the name 'football', if my understanding's correct.
by jo172 » Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:56 am
by johntheclaret » Tue Mar 20, 2018 9:21 am
jo172 wrote:John, criticising others for not contributing to the debate when both you and UK Fan have refused to engage with a couple of pretty simple concepts in:
- World Series Cricket occurring despite a "governing body"
- the possibility of people being able to organise private leagues (despite the obvious logistic difficulties; and
- the anti-competitive conduct provisions in Competition and Consumer Law Act.
by jo172 » Tue Mar 20, 2018 9:25 am
johntheclaret wrote:jo172 wrote:John, criticising others for not contributing to the debate when both you and UK Fan have refused to engage with a couple of pretty simple concepts in:
- World Series Cricket occurring despite a "governing body"
- the possibility of people being able to organise private leagues (despite the obvious logistic difficulties; and
- the anti-competitive conduct provisions in Competition and Consumer Law Act.
Sorry no, I don’t know anything about World Series cricket so I don’t see the point in debating it as I’m not sure what the relevance one sport has to another under completely different circumstances.
I suspect what you are saying is that a bunch of wealthy people got to gether and organised some cricket market he’s outside the official body. I guess they had enough money to pay for it, pay for the venues, cover insurance and all the trimmings and the players contracts. I’d assume, but don’t know, the players were either out of contract, or had to sacrifice their contracts and be bought out. I don’t know ?
I’m sure if they were under contract and breeches that contract against the wishes of their Club or the official body, then that Club/ Body would have a right to take legal action?
johntheclaret wrote:I’m pretty sure the anti competitive conduct provisions are either covered or don’t apply. Otherwise how could any sports body operate. Do you think you could just start up another AFL team without getting the green light from the AFL Governing body and without complying to a significant number of pro-quo’s, rules and regulations?
by MW » Tue Mar 20, 2018 9:28 am
by VALE PARK » Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:39 am
by morell » Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:47 am
I am poking fun an was trying to be lighthearted. Meant no offense.johntheclaret wrote:morell wrote:It was a simpler time em dubs, back then the SANFL was boss and things were clear.MW wrote:morell wrote:Man I wish I was still stuck in 1989.
Listen to some Tears for Fears. Watch the Goonies and then Major League when mum wasn't looking. Pour over the Beckett only to realise my cards sucked. Play some knock off Pac Man on my Atari.
Good times man, good times.
Why are you describing my childhood?
Then this whole fangdangled Victorian league came along and dang they just ruined it all!!
Soon enough they'll be running their own reserves league!
Don't they know the "N" stands for National!!
Mate, you are like a schoolyard bully. You’ve offered nothing to the discussion other than throw insults and then when that doesn’t work you revert to ridicule and encourage your little buddies to join in.
Of course, stereotypical of an AFL fan you seem to think anyone who actually cares about the SANFL is a dinosaur who lives in the past. You don’t seem able to comprehend people can, and want, to support an alternative league to your AFL. You have no history so you have no respect for for anyone else’s history.
SANFL fans are rightly proud of that great history, and proud of the clubs who made it, but they are also realists and know the challenges the league faces and where it sits in the pecking order. No one is under any illusions on either of those issues.
Anyway thanks for the mature debate.
by PhilH » Tue Mar 20, 2018 11:47 am
by bennymacca » Tue Mar 20, 2018 11:51 am
by stan » Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:39 pm
lol no of course we dont.bennymacca wrote:Do any of us actually know the contract the afl teams signed when joining the SANFL?
It’s not hard to imagine there was a clause in there about a national reserves competition, or something similar.
Then we could all be arguing about nothing?
by Jim05 » Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:52 pm
stan wrote:lol no of course we dont.bennymacca wrote:Do any of us actually know the contract the afl teams signed when joining the SANFL?
It’s not hard to imagine there was a clause in there about a national reserves competition, or something similar.
Then we could all be arguing about nothing?
But come on all this histeria has come about from a hack journo on the footy show.
Also we have had one team come out and say they havent been involved with any discussion yet.
by JK » Tue Mar 20, 2018 1:10 pm
bennymacca wrote:Do any of us actually know the contract the afl teams signed when joining the SANFL?
It’s not hard to imagine there was a clause in there about a national reserves competition, or something similar.
Then we could all be arguing about nothing?
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |