2018 AFL delistings / retirements

[woodublieve12]

Menzel and Murdoch both been delisted

one of them will end up at sydney

[Brodlach]

Maybe he was asking too much money?

[mighty_tiger_79]

Menzel and Murdoch both been delisted

No doubt Port will pick them both up

Menzel is an odd one, as noted all over media circles he's better than most of Geelong's depth players.

Murdoch I'd almost take on a one year deal depending on who we secure in the draft.

Murdoch is ******* useless, so please take him

Sent from my SM-A520F using Tapatalk

[Booney]

Menzel and Murdoch both been delisted

No doubt Port will pick them both up

Menzel is an odd one, as noted all over media circles he's better than most of Geelong's depth players.

Murdoch I'd almost take on a one year deal depending on who we secure in the draft.

Murdoch is ******* useless, so please take him

Might just need to play under a good coach.

[Lightning McQueen]

Might just need to play under a good coach.

No point in coming to Port then.

[woodublieve12]

Might just need to play under a good coach.

No point in coming to Port then.

agreed...

[Dutchy]

This is where Port/Ken are not ruthless enough, why keep Trengove and McKenzie on the list? Especially going into a supposed deep draft?

I'd keep them on, would only be costing a packet of skittles and a can of fanta.

And so would Menzel and Murdock who are clearly better depth players, Port pulled the trigger too soon, again.

[Booney]

This is where Port/Ken are not ruthless enough, why keep Trengove and McKenzie on the list? Especially going into a supposed deep draft?

I'd keep them on, would only be costing a packet of skittles and a can of fanta.

And so would Menzel and Murdock who are clearly better depth players, Port pulled the trigger too soon, again.

Not like for like, need to look at list balance, with Pittard being disposed of and Hombsch looking for more opportunity we need more in the back half than we do the front half.

Menzel isn't for us, Murdoch maybe at best.

[Brodlach]

All pisstakes aside, Port have improved their list over the summer already. No need to take either of these two IMO

[Booney]

All pisstakes aside, Port have improved their list over the summer already. No need to take either of these two IMO

I'm excited by the addition of Burton into the back half mix. When Hartlett went down ( and was in perhaps career best form ) our disposal from the back half was questionable at best, once the ball movement from the back half was poor by foot or slow ( no confidence to "go" ) the forwards were always going to struggle.

[MW]

All pisstakes aside, Port have improved their list over the summer already. No need to take either of these two IMO

Polec, Pittard and Whingeguard out for Lycett and Burton is an improvement?

[Brodlach]

Got rid of Toumpas, Thomas, Neade and Pittard

[JK]

All pisstakes aside, Port have improved their list over the summer already. No need to take either of these two IMO

Polec, Pittard and Whingeguard out for Lycett and Burton is an improvement?

When you add 2 or 3 gun kids to it soon it's going to look pretty good imho.

[MW]

Got rid of Toumpas, Thomas, Neade and Pittard

All four were in and out of the side.
Kids not even drafted yet, let alone proven.
They have gone backwards IMO.

[Booney]

Got rid of Toumpas, Thomas, Neade and Pittard

All four were in and out of the side.
Kids not even drafted yet, let alone proven.
They have gone backwards IMO.

And therein lies the motives, in and out of a side who missed the finals. It's time for you to go.

[PatowalongaPirate]

21 list changes since the end of 2017. The rebuild is in full swing.

[MW]

Got rid of Toumpas, Thomas, Neade and Pittard

All four were in and out of the side.
Kids not even drafted yet, let alone proven.
They have gone backwards IMO.

And therein lies the motives, in and out of a side who missed the finals. It's time for you to go.

Agree. Polec and Wingard on the other hand...

[Lightning McQueen]

21 list changes since the end of 2017. The rebuild is in full swing.

Didn't Essendon have 35 in one season?

[PatowalongaPirate]

21 list changes since the end of 2017. The rebuild is in full swing.

Didn't Essendon have 35 in one season?

12....and 10 of them signed back on the following year

[woodublieve12]

Menzel and Murdoch both been delisted

No doubt Port will pick them both up

Menzel is an odd one, as noted all over media circles he's better than most of Geelong's depth players.

Murdoch I'd almost take on a one year deal depending on who we secure in the draft.

Murdoch is ******* useless, so please take him

Sent from my SM-A520F using Tapatalk

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/no-tac ... p8yF6WO2eg