Crows vs Hawks

[Booney]

It really is tough spending 2 or 3 years at the top without any results,more so when you fall apart in September.The only thing that can ease the pain is a premiership at the end of it all.

[am Bays]

It really is tough spending 2 or 3 years at the top without any results,more so when you fall apart in September.The only thing that can ease the pain is a premiership at the end of it all.

Thanks for your concern Booney, I can tell its from the heart....

[Booney]

It is Tassie,it suuuuuure is.

[am Bays]

It is Tassie,it suuuuuure is.

Haven't seen you on the SANFL board much lately??

[sydney-dog]

another grub

mate, why don't you just worry about your mob

the tigers have been promising to my the 8 for 20 years now and can't get out of the bottom 4.

not to mentioned, they spent a shite load of money on a five year deal with Wallance, 3 years in to his contract the club has gone backwards

I would advise you to watch the Hawks this week, look at #23, and think to yourself

FFS, why did Wallance chose Tambling over Buddy Franklin

Your club has nothing and will be shite for a few more years

[rod_rooster]

I would advise you to watch the Hawks this week, look at #23, and think to yourself

FFS, why did Wallance chose Tambling over Buddy Franklin

Bit harsh. 3 blokes got taken before Franklin. Even Hawthorn took a player before Franklin (Roughead).

[Sojourner]

as much as it hurst to say Choco is a far superior coach!

I was surprised to hear that Choco has the best win-loss ratio of any current AFL coach! Who knows, he may well have another premiership win soon!

[sydney-dog]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

[rod_rooster]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

Hawthorn took Hodge before Judd. Everyone thought Hawthorn were stupid........................until recently

[bulldogs]

I wasnt that keen on craigy when they appointed him, i had to eat humble pie after his 1st couple of yrs. I see after 31/2 yrs the side hasnt grown or developed. I beleive the crows are a club who will always want to be around the top 8 but to go to the next step and be a grand finalist they need some changes which might hurt them in the short term and see them drop down to the bottom 4. Look at Collingwood they dropped down in 2004/05 got great draft picks used them well and whammo same as port power. Craigy would be given 1 more year and if we dont play off in the big one see ya latter.

Good post, except you contradicted yourself by saying give Craig one more year for the big one or sack him

your right MW i did. what i should of said if the crows make plenty of changes but see improvement in development not just position on the ladder then keep craigy, but if they go the same old same old and the results arent there then give him the bullett.

[JK]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

Hawthorn took Hodge before Judd. Everyone thought Hawthorn were stupid........................until recently

As good as Hodge is I'd still take Judd

[rod_rooster]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

Hawthorn took Hodge before Judd. Everyone thought Hawthorn were stupid........................until recently

As good as Hodge is I'd still take Judd

Depend what your after i guess. Really need to put draft picks in perspective. Also really need to wait till careers are finished before making a true value judgement.

If Judd breaks down now and never plays again and Hodge plays another 10 years of good footy who was the better choice. Same thing with Franklin. If he loses the plot and never plays another good game but Tambling plays 10 years of good solid footy surely that would be better value.

[Booney]

It is Tassie,it suuuuuure is.

Haven't seen you on the SANFL board much lately??

Dont be silly,that season finished about 4 weeks ago.

[JK]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

Hawthorn took Hodge before Judd. Everyone thought Hawthorn were stupid........................until recently

As good as Hodge is I'd still take Judd

Depend what your after i guess. Really need to put draft picks in perspective. Also really need to wait till careers are finished before making a true value judgement.

Yes, very good call, can't argue with that at all ... Splitting hairs with blokes like Judd and Hodge anyway as both have always been top-shelfers.

Tambling seemed to be greatly improved in the 2nd half of this season and could be a surprise down the track!

On Buddy, the boy is special, just has that WOW factor that puts bums on seats, I luv watching him play.

[NFC]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

Hawthorn took Hodge before Judd. Everyone thought Hawthorn were stupid........................until recently

As good as Hodge is I'd still take Judd

I'd take Hodge.

More physical, a better leader (yes Judd is captain, Hodge isn't...), better skills and a better mark.

A greater all-round package IMO.

[JK]

rod_rooster

Richmond took 2 out of the 3 blokes before Franklin, so they were two times as stupid

Hawthorn took Hodge before Judd. Everyone thought Hawthorn were stupid........................until recently

As good as Hodge is I'd still take Judd

I'd take Hodge.

More physical, a better leader (yes Judd is captain, Hodge isn't...), better skills and a better mark.

A greater all-round package IMO.

Dont disagree with the first 2 mate, but better skills??

[Hondo]

Surely if both were fit and ready you would take Judd??????

Brownlow medalist/ Norm Smith medalist and proven match-winner / game-breaker

No disrespect to Hodge who is also an excellent player

[redden whites]

.Why would Adelaide persist with Burton??? Had the chance to almost put it beyond doubt with a mark in the goalsquare when Adelaide were cooking .In front of the pack he shat himself .Put his arms up and was expecting to be hit and the ball hit both his hands and he didnt make any attempt to close his hands and mark it expecting the crunch that never arrived and went to ground....fraud.

forward to 09..GROUNDHOG DAY