West beat WWT Eagles - Post Game Review

[Booney]

Pseudo, to save space I won't quote your last post, but I will say it was probably one of the most gratuitiously irrelevant posts in your illustrious posting career.

I was asked a question and gave a factual answer to that question. No more, no less.

I have to admit, though, that your offering, although totally irrelevant, was a highly entertaining entrant in the 'long-lasting sour grapes' competition

Get off your high horse RAB - I was merely pointing out that West has 12 listed AFL players, not 11. That I choose to combine it with a swipe at the hack Port Power coach is a matter of style.

Be him on an AFL list or not, Willetts was never an AFL footballer.

Suggesting you have style is a bit far fetched Pseudo, even for you...

[nickname]

Can't believe the comments about Shirley getting 5-7 or 6 games for an incident that happened in the play and was because an umpire didn't call for a ball-up quick enough.

Crikey Gowans only got three weeks after he was clearly shown to have hit a North player in the Grand Final after he chased him to do it!

Haven't noticed too many West Adelaide supporters commenting on the Grocke incident.

People who live in glass houses .....

What does the fact that the spear tackle happened 'in the play' have to do with anything? No matter when it's done it's appalling. And are you seriously suggesting it's justified because the umpire didn't call for a ball-up soon enough?
The Grocke incident was presumably a jab to the stomach, going by his posture when I looked over. If so, it hardly compares with a spear tackle.

[drebin]

Can't believe the comments about Shirley getting 5-7 or 6 games for an incident that happened in the play and was because an umpire didn't call for a ball-up quick enough.

So it's the umpires fault now!!! You better ring the Eagles and offer your services as his legal advisor and represent him at the Tribunal with that Pearler!!!

[Mickyj]

Take out Fairy and put in J . WRIGHT , and you have my vote !

IMHO
Dawson,Cullen,Cheep,Cica, Rimington,Banner and others need to come in.
And why can the crows say Hentschell plays a half next time a full game .then play him in the league .

Definitely some wholesale changes are needed.

Out: Hicks, Miles, Hill, Lane, Davoren, Daniel, Schultz, Corbett (possibly Shirley out suspended)
In: McKenzie, Rimington, Fitzgerald, Cicolella, Dawson, Staple, Fairclough, R Fiacchi (possibly Hentschel to come in)

Team:

F: Cicolella Hentschel Dawson
HF: Westbrook Grocke Fitzgerald
C: Rimington McKenzie Allmond
HB: Jarrad McGregor Stewart
B: P.Fiacchi Hier R.Fiacchi
R: Dabrowski Broadbent Treeby
I: Fairclough Staple Jacky

Grocke and McGregor might need to be used as 2nd ruckman when Dabrowski needs a break.

Not sure I agree with either of those 2 Holden but at least Wright looks like a footballer .

[Eagles_d]

Out: Hicks, Miles, Hill, Lane, Davoren, Daniel, Schultz, Corbett

That is the worst bunch of footballers ever to play league football - no wonder we are playing crap football.
The only other out would be Fuller to the B grade and bring in Jefferies[/quote]


You really need to watch the games and how these boys play. I bet you hardly know a thing about these boys and yet you make such a call?

[tinkerbell21]

Out: Hicks, Miles, Hill, Lane, Davoren, Daniel, Schultz, Corbett

That is the worst bunch of footballers ever to play league football - no wonder we are playing crap football.
The only other out would be Fuller to the B grade and bring in Jefferies

Not Sure I agree with all your outs but love your idea on Jefferies. The players are obviously responding well to his methods and they seem to WANT to play and do well for him.

His body language on game day is of a far more positive manner and his enthusiasm is evident. I liked they way he congratulated Rimmington on the ground after a BOG on Saturday too.

BTW I hope Cicca is back against the Dogs - One thing lacking (amongst a million things) is onfield leadership.

[holden78]

Is it time for Robert Pyman to come back home to the Eagles next year ?

[MightyEagles]

Is it time for Robert Pyman to come back home to the Eagles next year ?

I assume that you want him to take over from Fuller, am I right?

[Mickyj]

Is it time for Robert Pyman to come back home to the Eagles next year ?

what the hell have you been smoking holden78 no way in hell
Jeffries should take the next step up when ron finishes

[Mickyj]

Out: Hicks, Miles, Hill, Lane, Davoren, Daniel, Schultz, Corbett

That is the worst bunch of footballers ever to play league football - no wonder we are playing crap football.
The only other out would be Fuller to the B grade and bring in Jefferies

Not Sure I agree with all your outs but love your idea on Jefferies. The players are obviously responding well to his methods and they seem to WANT to play and do well for him.

His body language on game day is of a far more positive manner and his enthusiasm is evident. I liked they way he congratulated Rimmington on the ground after a BOG on Saturday too.

BTW I hope Cicca is back against the Dogs - One thing lacking (amongst a million things) is onfield leadership.[/quote]


Tinkerbell I have watched Jeffries the last 2 years.When just Rons assistant he was the one getting upset .and he coaches in a more attacking style .
I HOPE THE BOARD WOULD DO THE RIGHT THING AND GET JEFFRIES TO REPLACE RON WHEN RON FINISHES HIS TENURE AT OVAL AVE.

[Dutchy]

Another loss and another week of Eagles fans/officials going missing AGAIN....seriously is there a team with more front runners than Eagles fans?

[matt1]

Another loss and another week of Eagles fans/officials going missing AGAIN....seriously is there a team with more front runners than Eagles fans?

I suppose the only thing worse is the number of Glenelg supporters that have come out of the woodwork over the last two years.

Back in your spot b*tch.

[eaglesfan]

Yes, I would have thought that Glenelg supporters should be the last people to be critical of "front runners".....

[Dutchy]

at least you blokes found the thread!

Im talking of a few regulars on here such as CD, EAGLES, LEH, EHL, etc

check out the North game thread for all their comments, yet nowhere to been seen all of a sudden?

[dedja]

Dutchy ...



We're back there in 5 weeks and no cigars this century.

[CoverKing]

still 11 pseudo, willits is not on an AFL list. Therefore 11. RAB correct!

[cd]

Dutchy as an official who openly uses name on websites I am sure you would agree that this week all communication was to come via club CEO or President only.

[Mickyj]

:lol: at least you blokes found the thread!

Im talking of a few regulars on here such as CD, EAGLES, LEH, EHL, etc

check out the North game thread for all their comments, yet nowhere to been seen all of a sudden?

I am here dutchy and have been only able to post in short bursts due to my damaged but improving knee .

And just think yourself lucky pre internet days I would have stopped talking footy for a week

[Wedgie]

I am here dutchy and have been only able to post in short bursts due to my damaged but improving knee .

You should try typing with your fingers and not you knee mate!

[Mickyj]

I am here dutchy and have been only able to post in short bursts due to my damaged but improving knee .

You should try typing with your fingers and not you knee mate!

I make less spelling mistakes with my knees