Division 2 in 2007!

carey · Post by **carey** » Fri Feb 09, 2007 1:33 pm

dont know alot about div 2 but RRR is right with two things there if what i'm hearing is the truth kilburn to have a very tough year just matt whealan and dan thomas alone are huge loss's and pt distircts to be yery strong from what i hear a 6 man coaching panel all ex port magpies surely not true tho. 6 coach's ??? can anyone confirm ?

Dogwatcher · Post by **Dogwatcher** » Fri Feb 09, 2007 2:05 pm

Where's Whelan going?

The Real Number 3 · Post by **The Real Number 3** » Fri Feb 09, 2007 2:10 pm

signed at salis nth

Down&Out · Post by **Down&Out** » Fri Feb 09, 2007 10:43 pm

Anyone heard how Pt Districts Ramblers are going. Heard Peucker has taken half a team with him. Big Al has nothing but good things to say about his last 3 years at Rambers??
Christofis, Fenney, Muscara Lynch among recruits?? Didn't think Lynch had played for a couple of years? Will they improve Districts

ex player · Post by **ex player** » Mon Feb 12, 2007 1:04 pm

kilburn losses, thomas,white,whelan,boyle,reid and the gun recruit they were able to get has left to go interstate as well
my personal opinion of the coach of phos.............cant coach and over rated

dinglinga · Post by **dinglinga** » Mon Feb 12, 2007 5:16 pm

y is peachy overrated ex player... what disgruntled... couldnt get a game....

over rated???? not too many 2 time Div1 premiership coaches floating round in div 2 ....

how long were u at kilburn for....

super · Post by **super** » Mon Feb 12, 2007 9:55 pm

Hey Dinga, build a bridge mate ... you can use some of falcon chicks bricks! Ex player did say it was HIS opinion - but it is very sweet of you to defend Peachy all the time. :roll:

dinglinga · Post by **dinglinga** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 8:30 am

yes correct it was his opion ...but give us reasons y he is over rated....

and maybe i know peachy and know his coaching record in the SAAFL and other country leagues....

think u would agree that many players that become disgruntled with a coach will say they are over rated etc ....

and super hope u have told trevor smith ur comments relating to his knee cos hee didnt find them very funny

ex player · Post by **ex player** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 8:42 am

was around A1 long enough
What was the real reason he left PHOS the first time ???????????
Agreed he coached a A1 premiership.............fell over the line in a Prelim when Kilburn lost it
Whoever won that game would have beaten Broadview that year, they were so cocky they were ready for the picking
Ask some of his assistants, ask some of the State players, and more importantly ask some of the Kilburn players he had in A2 for a couple of years
Why he get the flick from West
Once again my opinion and might i say a LOT of others opinion also

barbs · Post by **barbs** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 12:59 pm

ex player wrote:Agreed he coached a A1 premiership.............fell over the line in a Prelim when Kilburn lost it
Whoever won that game would have beaten Broadview that year, they were so cocky they were ready for the picking

PHOS played Port Districts in the Prelim final and beat them easily, and I doubt they would have beaten Broadview. So it would have been hard for Kilburn to do it.

mazdabaiter · Post by **mazdabaiter** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 2:03 pm

correct me if im wrong but i thought phos played kilburn in a prelim in 2002 and belted them, then went on to another peachy a1 flag by defeating adelaide uni which no-one thought phos could beat....

mazdabaiter · Post by **mazdabaiter** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 2:05 pm

ex-player, im interested in knowing why you think the phos coach cant coach? have you ever played under him yourself?

ex player · Post by **ex player** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 2:38 pm

i think the year was 2000
it was at norwood oval
and as i say who ever won that game was going to go top which prooved correct
no i havent played under him, and i wouldnt
as i say i have been told enough from people who have
also his off field actions are questionable
i want to make sure every one understand it is MY opinion

barbs · Post by **barbs** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:15 pm

That was the qualifying final. Kilburn lost there last minor round game and 2 finals hardly the form of a premier.

dinglinga · Post by **dinglinga** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:49 pm

so ur opions are based on other ppls comments ....

u say u know daniels old man well ... i doubt if he has a bad word about peachy .... also danny ryan is known to have very good football relationship with him

super · Post by **super** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 8:03 pm

Well done ex player - hook,line and sinker! Mention Peachy and these two clowns come in like the tide :lol:

Word of warning though, the last person to dare to disagree with them was the subject of violent threats....keyboard rage is a terrible thing! :shock:

As for trev smith, maybe you can lend him some bricks too, dinga !!!

dinglinga · Post by **dinglinga** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 8:08 pm

keyboard rage??? when have i threatened any1 super

and dont think trev needs brick cos his house is complete

ex player · Post by **ex player** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 8:49 am

Mmmmm oh well everyone is entiled to their opinion
Peach was supposed to give kilburn ( including ryan and thomas ) all the names from westies while he was there, did it happen ?????????? i think you will find they have a changed opinion also !!!!!!!!!!!
anyway lets move on :lol:

Understand all is not rosey at Seaton either :?:

Down&Out · Post by **Down&Out** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 8:59 am

I have nothing on Peachy but having a good footy relationship with Danny Ryan is nothing to go by. He and players of his time are half the problem at Kilburn. So big of him to take on the coaching job at Kilburn!! Been a great time for them!

RRR · Post by **RRR** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 9:20 am

ex player wrote:Mmmmm oh well everyone is entiled to their opinion
Peach was supposed to give kilburn ( including ryan and thomas ) all the names from westies while he was there, did it happen ?????????? i think you will find they have a changed opinion also !!!!!!!!!!!
anyway lets move on
Understand all is not rosey at Seaton either

havent a lot of seatons players headed over to port districts?

Division 2 in 2007!

Who is online