That’s a big call on Rozee.tigerpie wrote:Probably equal to Rozee.Rik E Boy wrote:Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.Booney wrote:No mention of Butters' importance to our line up.
regards,
REB
Rozee could be better than Gray.
Speaking of injuries and in particular Butters injury- Ankle Syndesmosis, I've never seen or heard of it being so well documented across the AFL before, is it just me or is it becoming more common and more players have been diagnosed with it?Rik E Boy wrote:Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.Booney wrote:No mention of Butters' importance to our line up.
regards,
REB
Been a few actually, I'm not going to be able to in hear that word now.The Dark Knight wrote:Speaking of injuries and in particular Butters injury- Ankle Syndesmosis, I've never seen or heard of it being so well documented across the AFL before, is it just me or is it becoming more common and more players have been diagnosed with it?Rik E Boy wrote:Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.Booney wrote:No mention of Butters' importance to our line up.
regards,
REB
1. Wanganeenamber_fluid wrote:That’s a big call on Rozee.tigerpie wrote:Probably equal to Rozee.Rik E Boy wrote:Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.Booney wrote:No mention of Butters' importance to our line up.
regards,
REB
Rozee could be better than Gray.
Gray arguably the best Power player so far.
Probably, he was something special.Bum Crack wrote:Was Wanganeen really that good to be classed as number 1? I thought he was a bit overrated.
Hello!Rik E Boy wrote:1. Wanganeenamber_fluid wrote:That’s a big call on Rozee.tigerpie wrote:Probably equal to Rozee.Rik E Boy wrote:
Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.
regards,
REB
Rozee could be better than Gray.
Gray arguably the best Power player so far.
2. Tredrea
3. C Cornes
all say hello.
regards,
REB
Booney wrote:Tredrea
Gray Wanganeen
Boak
C Cornes Primus
Francou R James P Burgoyne S Burgoyne Lade
Wilson
Probably alongside Francou etc but could you imagine the furore on here?am Bays wrote:Booney wrote:Tredrea
Gray Wanganeen
Boak
C Cornes Primus
Francou R James P Burgoyne S Burgoyne Lade
Wilson
No room for a 4 x John Cahill Medallist and 300 game player (record holder for another six weeks baring injury)
He wouldn’t make the top 10.am Bays wrote:Booney wrote:Tredrea
Gray Wanganeen
Boak
C Cornes Primus
Francou R James P Burgoyne S Burgoyne Lade
Wilson
No room for a 4 x John Cahill Medallist and 300 game player (record holder for another six weeks baring injury)
Your taking the piss surely?Booney wrote:Probably alongside Francou etc but could you imagine the furore on here?am Bays wrote:Booney wrote:Tredrea
Gray Wanganeen
Boak
C Cornes Primus
Francou R James P Burgoyne S Burgoyne Lade
Wilson
No room for a 4 x John Cahill Medallist and 300 game player (record holder for another six weeks baring injury)
His stats are outstanding and should rate him among the best ever, I just didn’t rate him.Booney wrote:Nope, you're a bad judge if 4 x BnF ( 8 years in a row top 5 ) 2 x AA, 300 games and a premiership doesn't tick the boxes of a player deserved of recognition, or, you're confusing his media profile with him as a player.
I could have rattled plenty more out, Carr could be in there, Wines will be, Westhoff on the next line, perhaps I under rate him. Subjective so open to debate for sure.amber_fluid wrote:His stats are outstanding and should rate him among the best ever, I just didn’t rate him.Booney wrote:Nope, you're a bad judge if 4 x BnF ( 8 years in a row top 5 ) 2 x AA, 300 games and a premiership doesn't tick the boxes of a player deserved of recognition, or, you're confusing his media profile with him as a player.
I think Josh Carr, Cassisi, Wines, Westhoff plus the ones all mentioned above are better than him.
Isn't it just what used to be called a sprained ankle?The Dark Knight wrote:Speaking of injuries and in particular Butters injury- Ankle Syndesmosis, I've never seen or heard of it being so well documented across the AFL before, is it just me or is it becoming more common and more players have been diagnosed with it?Rik E Boy wrote:Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.Booney wrote:No mention of Butters' importance to our line up.
regards,
REB
He’s not even the best footballer in his familyBooney wrote:I could have rattled plenty more out, Carr could be in there, Wines will be, Westhoff on the next line, perhaps I under rate him. Subjective so open to debate for sure.amber_fluid wrote:His stats are outstanding and should rate him among the best ever, I just didn’t rate him.Booney wrote:Nope, you're a bad judge if 4 x BnF ( 8 years in a row top 5 ) 2 x AA, 300 games and a premiership doesn't tick the boxes of a player deserved of recognition, or, you're confusing his media profile with him as a player.
I think Josh Carr, Cassisi, Wines, Westhoff plus the ones all mentioned above are better than him.
( But Kane is in there )
A high sprain yes.Mr Beefy wrote:Isn't it just what used to be called a sprained ankle?The Dark Knight wrote:Speaking of injuries and in particular Butters injury- Ankle Syndesmosis, I've never seen or heard of it being so well documented across the AFL before, is it just me or is it becoming more common and more players have been diagnosed with it?Rik E Boy wrote:Best of your young guns I reckon. Hope he can return to the field sooner rather than later. Too many injuries these days.Booney wrote:No mention of Butters' importance to our line up.
regards,
REB
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 175 guests
