Which team had the most disappointing season?

[Booney]

Who didn't vote for West?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Sturt easily.

[Dirko]

On the whole as a club, West easily.

No team in the finals.

Absolutely bombed out in the A's after sitting pretty.

Game plan that bores the shit out of people.

[on the rails]

On the whole as a club, West easily.

No team in the finals.

Absolutely bombed out in the A's after sitting pretty.

Game plan that bores the shit out of people.

I agree and the silence from some of their "puffy chested" supporters on here has been deafening! LOL

[Brodlach]

On the whole as a club, West easily.

No team in the finals.

Absolutely bombed out in the A's after sitting pretty.

Game plan that bores the shit out of people.

I agree and the silence from some of their "puffy chested" supporters on here has been deafening! LOL

I wonder if Im one of those "puffy chested supporters" . I agree West was disappointing but you can say the same about North and Sturt.

[Grahaml]

I think if you looked at the ladder now at the start of the season you'd say Glenelg or Sturt in terms of the number of wins, but the way West started then fell over makes it hard to argue against them.

[MightyEagles]

Who didn't vote for West?

ME and some other people.

[MightyEagles]

I say Sturt as they have been a top 5 side for a few years now. West arn't disappointing as they usually either just make the finals or miss out of finals.

[MightyEagles]

Who voted for the Eagles and Central.

[cennals05]

I voted for North, with the list they have they should be doing a lot better.

[Big Phil]

Who voted for the Eagles and Central.

Was it you ME?

[FlyingHigh]

West were the most disappointing given their start, improvement in recent times and expectations.
North would be the most disappointed, to get so close so many times shows they weren't playing shocking footy, could really have been challenging for 3rd spot.
Port I don't reckon had any realistic expectations internally about making the finals and just wanted to get as much experience in their young side as they could, hence the Foxtel Cup. In hindsight getting so close to the finals actually making them would have been better than participating in the FC, but participating in the FC was more realistic at the start of the year.

[johntheclaret]

Guess most Westies fans would be disappointed after the start the bloods made. I would also think that despite North finishing one place lower than last year, most North fans would see this season as an improvement after two years of defensive boring crap the Roosters dished up under Healy. New coach, new gameplan and a more attacking style which ended with North being the 2nd highest scorers in the league is something to build on for next year.

If North don't make the finals next year then I can see them leading the same poll in 2012

[Ian]

If North don't make the finals next year then I can see them leading the same poll in 2012

Agree, but if North don't recruit at the very least a good tall defender that could well miss out again.

[MightyEagles]

Who voted for the Eagles and Central.

Was it you ME?

No, why would I vote for my club for?

[hawkseye]

I dont think its North given that its Francou 1st year. Westies maybe? Given the hype early on.

[bulldogproud2]

I voted for Sturt, based on how far they fell this year.
I would agree that West had the most disappointing second half of the season but based on where I thought they may finish at the start of the season, I would not class it as disappointing as Sturt's.
Cheers

[Big Phil]

Who voted for the Eagles and Central.

Was it you ME?

No, why would I vote for my club for?

It was a joke mate, hence the

[holden78]

On the whole as a club, West easily.

No team in the finals.

Absolutely bombed out in the A's after sitting pretty.

Game plan that bores the shit out of people.

Collins must be having a laugh to himself hes getting away with daylight robbery at Richmond Oval , bring back Mickan or Rehn at the very least !

[NFC]

Central, easily.