SAAFL Div 5 2008

[gothebombers]

maybe cahill laid the haymaker and its more complicated..

Must've, the other two were for abusive language.

Surely they would do the striking case before abusive language cases
Doesnt that mean he can play this week and potentially hit another kid?
What a joke

i checked ,,his name isnt in the a gr list to play this week....unless the umpire cannot attend would be the only valid reason hecould play this week anyway

[zedman]

hey dogs...i was trolling thru saafl website and saw jorgensen had 9 games from a report hang over into 2007 from 2006..do you know what he did at the time and what the full penalty was..just curious mate..no drama

Apparently he gave a "B" grade umpire a drink!!!

LOL..how many did he get originally?

[Sturtman]

Have been away for a month so can anyone from Rosewater tell me how the Super star of amateur league Robert Cains has been performing after his miracle come back from a burst blood vessel in his calf??( very soft to miss games because of it!!!)

Do you have pictures of him on your bedroom ceiling??

No need for pictures on ceiling I have a blow up Robert Cains doll. It is very very hairy and stinks of alcohol!!!

[Dogsbreath]

Have been away for a month so can anyone from Rosewater tell me how the Super star of amateur league Robert Cains has been performing after his miracle come back from a burst blood vessel in his calf??( very soft to miss games because of it!!!)

Do you have pictures of him on your bedroom ceiling??

No need for pictures on ceiling I have a blow up Robert Cains doll. It is very very hairy and stinks of alcohol!!!

I wish I never asked!
I think he's back in the "A"s at the moment, not sure!

[Dogsbreath]

hey dogs...i was trolling thru saafl website and saw jorgensen had 9 games from a report hang over into 2007 from 2006..do you know what he did at the time and what the full penalty was..just curious mate..no drama

Apparently he gave a "B" grade umpire a drink!!!

LOL..how many did he get originally?

Not sure but it was a hot day! Unley's ump has never been a favorite!

[Bradman]

hey dogs...i was trolling thru saafl website and saw jorgensen had 9 games from a report hang over into 2007 from 2006..do you know what he did at the time and what the full penalty was..just curious mate..no drama

Apparently he gave a "B" grade umpire a drink!!!

LOL..how many did he get originally?

Not sure but it was a hot day! Unley's ump has never been a favorite!

]

haha
think the story goes he got sent off water bottle in hand and was giving some lip to the umpire on way off the umpire then reported him for the lip service and umpire then kept going on so Jorg's told him to shut up and he wouldnt
so everytime he went to talk Jorgy would spray water in his gob to shut him up

i believe and not 100% sure got 3 or 4 for swearing at the umpire and 5 or 6 for continuing to squirt water!!

[zedman]

LOL

thx guys..gl all today

[jumbo]

Blacks vs Greenacres a draw - bit of discussion yet to go over the scores - apparently some difference between goal umps and time keepers. Not sure what will happen.

Top game of footy though - Blacks led most of the day but couldn't quite put the Acres away.

[sprinttospace]

Blacks vs Greenacres a draw - bit of discussion yet to go over the scores - apparently some difference between goal umps and time keepers. Not sure what will happen.

Top game of footy though - Blacks led most of the day but couldn't quite put the Acres away.

was a bit crazy for 10 minutes after the siren. blacks goal ump, timekeeper and greenies team mngr had the same score 15.20 to 17.8. greenies goal ump had 15.19 to 17.9 looked like he put a point on the wrong side during the last quarter. all sorted in the end though.

was a great game, shame about the one of the umps though. dont take the whistle and the money if you are not willing to make tough decisions i say.

[jumbo]

Blacks vs Greenacres a draw - bit of discussion yet to go over the scores - apparently some difference between goal umps and time keepers. Not sure what will happen.

Top game of footy though - Blacks led most of the day but couldn't quite put the Acres away.

was a bit crazy for 10 minutes after the siren. blacks goal ump, timekeeper and greenies team mngr had the same score 15.20 to 17.8. greenies goal ump had 15.19 to 17.9 looked like he put a point on the wrong side during the last quarter. all sorted in the end though.

was a great game, shame about the one of the umps though. dont take the whistle and the money if you are not willing to make tough decisions i say.

Thought the umpiring was ordinary - but ordinary and consistent for both sides - they let it go quite a bit but don't reckon it influenced the outcome.

Blacks inability to convert was the most obvious story of the day - if they had made better use of the ball up forward the story would have been quite different - lost count of the number of shots around the corner attempted that mised when a runner at the goal was an option (actually counted 4 times). Blacks are improving and playing good footy towards the right end of the year.

[turk186]

Went and watched the "game of the round" and have to agree the umpiring did nothing to help the game, not sure about who got which scores right or wrong but there was a lot of controversy in both games with the goal umpiring, not sure which team was represented but I believe from where I was standing there were about six incorrect decisions made during the day (three in each grade) only one of which was questioned by the central umps (and changed).

What with the discussion that was on here recently the display I witnessed on sat at blacks ground did nothing to help the club umpire image and makes me feel SAAFL need to get people at these games take some notes and act accordingly

[LaughingKookaburra]

so its still a quality day at units then..they used to have a tool with a megaphone who would abuse you all day at the clubhouse end..also only game ive been involved in where the umpire was attacked by players..8-10 years ago when eddie fry coached us..end of the game they just went for him..i dont think he ever umpired again..its the culture there..its inbred in the club..even when they won a6 2 years ago the whole team would fight with each other, even on gf night they brawled..and they won it LMAO..has the coach lost control bb?

We knocked them out in straight sets in the magoos aswell Was gold singing the club song in front of the club rooms after aswell...... I honestly think we have done pretty well to be in a position of possibly avoiding relegation atm. With the list we had in the planned at the start of the year to what is on the park at the moment we have been crippled. IF we avoid relegation in my opinion the coaching staff need a medal, because for what they have had to put up with this year on player turnover it would drive most to the ground.

[Bubbula]

Ive been told a story from some acres people that there was a blatently bias goal umpire decision in the last quarter.. Can anyone put truth to this?

[LaughingKookaburra]

Ive been told a story from some acres people that there was a blatently bias goal umpire decision in the last quarter.. Can anyone put truth to this?

Interesting, but I reckon it happens at each game week in/week out. Theres always questionable decisions at each game. Whether it is blatant cheating or poor judgement is another question.

[Bubbula]

Ive been told a story from some acres people that there was a blatently bias goal umpire decision in the last quarter.. Can anyone put truth to this?

Interesting, but I reckon it happens at each game week in/week out. Theres always questionable decisions at each game. Whether it is blatant cheating or poor judgement is another question.

Exactly right, goal umpires were probably half cut anyway.

[LaughingKookaburra]

Yeah, theres a report from past seasons on the saafl website that had a Central United club goal umpire reported by the league umpire because he was drinking grog whilst goal umpiring. Must admit when I first saw it I had a laugh Surely you would realise you cant drink whilst you goal umpire.

[mighty hounds]

Ive been told a story from some acres people that there was a blatently bias goal umpire decision in the last quarter.. Can anyone put truth to this?

Interesting, but I reckon it happens at each game week in/week out. Theres always questionable decisions at each game. Whether it is blatant cheating or poor judgement is another question.

Exactly right, goal umpires were probably half cut anyway.

i'll comment seeing as i was playing in the game. i do belive it was a point which was given a goal but the greenacres goal umpire made some dodgy calls aswell, the only way the problem can be fix is the have neutral goal umpires like they do during the finals

[LaughingKookaburra]

The worst decisions I have seen have been from league umpires.

[turk186]

Hounds are u saying in your last that it was your goal ump that made the "mistake" because the "but the greenacres..." makes it sound like it was????

[LaughingKookaburra]

Sensational interview with Arty Bradshaw on ABC grandstand today. Single handedly is the reason why the club has been around for over 100 years. 97 and still going strong.