TimmiesChin wrote:daysofourlives wrote:An 8 team comp of 7 two dayers and 7 one dayers and from then on compulsory PROMOTION and relegation of 2 teams each year
IMO this would give every club an even chance to stay in a1 and also know what is going to happen b4 the season starts if they finish outside the 8.
That is the optimum outcome in terms of scheduling, and should flow on to even out all the grades below it - as most grades seem to have two distinct standards of side.
The issue becomes dealing with how far the relegation/promotion goes down the grades, how to deal with two sides from the same club playing in a grade, and how to write the enforced promotion/relegation into the bylaws to make it stick.
Also need to enforce some standards in terms of ground conditions to improve the higher end of the comp, with at least 1 ground not really being fit for A1 cricket with its pitch and runups being substandard, the ground in question also seems to have elastic boundary markers.
what oval are u referring to there timmie, gawler central perhaps? since when did u have a bowling run up lol. i think south gawler with a 6ft pitch is more of an issue
perhaps just a 6 team a2 comp would solve all the problems of having two teams in a particular division and would be fairer on the clubs 2nd teams that are currently in a2 having to compete against 1st eleven sides. therefore no teams would be relegated from a2 unless exceptional cicumstances arise, but i believe it is also in the constitution that ur highest team must play div 2 or higher. 2 teams in one division isnt a problem down the grades and perhaps it could also see the return of a5 as the one day comp and a4 to become a 2 day comp again. there would be enuff teams to allow this to happen as there was 38 this year and add sandy creeks 4 gives us 42 to split amongst 5 grades, so 2009/10 would be a1-12, a2-10, a3-8, a4-12 with everything getting tidied up the year after
so 2010/11 would be a1-8,a2-6, a3-8, a4-8, a5 remaining teams 12