Your clubs B&F 2009 winners

[big red supporter]

Para Hills Results from last nights B&F count

A grade B&F Jake levy
A grade R/UP Nathan Flynn-Sinodinos

B grade B&F Steve Beer back to back
B grade R/UP David Minshaw

C grade B&F Luke King back to back
C grade R/UP Brad Cavell


Congratulations to all

[bandar]

PHOS Camden results from Friday night.

A Grade Winner Aaron Bergsma

R/U Todd Blacksell

B Grade Winner Bodan Bishop

R/U Craig Bensch

C Grade Winner Anthony Flett

R/U Sam Taylor

[schimma]

Smosh West lakes B&F
A grade
Callum Masson B&F
James Cibich runner up

B grade
Phil Noble B&F
Dave Cleary runner up

C grade
Darren sharp B&F
Phil Juancey runner up

D grade
Joint winners

[piccachu]

Smosh West lakes B&F
A grade
Callum Masson B&F
James Cibich runner up

was very surprised when i heard nitchatowski didnt win the b&f to come second in the medal and not finish top 2 at your club is a bit strange, also heard from a few mates there was on bloke in the A grade at smosh who wasnt hapy with how many votes he got, aparently sooked the whole way through the count.

[Mr Butterworth]

TTG Results

A's- Steven Pollock
B's- Phil Doyle
C's- Pete Uncle
D's- Travis langston & Brad Jones
U18's- Jordan Camplin

[Greenshields27]

Elizabeth

A.grade
winner justin platten
runner up trent greenshields

B.grade
winner ben taylor
runner up mick elliot

[BIG_REDS]

Smosh West lakes B&F
A grade
Callum Masson B&F
James Cibich runner up

was very surprised when i heard nitchatowski didnt win the b&f to come second in the medal and not finish top 2 at your club is a bit strange, also heard from a few mates there was on bloke in the A grade at smosh who wasnt hapy with how many votes he got, aparently sooked the whole way through the count.

similar story at Para Hills. i was just as surprised when i heard Thach didnt win the b&f or come in the top 2 despit coming 3rd in the medal, i also heard that another player wasnt happy with his finishing position and was sooking throughout the count at finishing 3rd

[Scouser]

Smosh West lakes B&F
A grade
Callum Masson B&F
James Cibich runner up

was very surprised when i heard nitchatowski didnt win the b&f to come second in the medal and not finish top 2 at your club is a bit strange, also heard from a few mates there was on bloke in the A grade at smosh who wasnt hapy with how many votes he got, aparently sooked the whole way through the count.

similar story at Para Hills. i was just as surprised when i heard Thach didnt win the b&f or come in the top 2 despit coming 3rd in the medal, i also heard that another player wasnt happy with his finishing position and was sooking throughout the count at finishing 3rd

that whinging bloke from SMOSH wouldn't be the less-talented cousin of a Crows player would it? The few times I saw them this year, all he would do was whinge...

[blackcat]

What club doesn't have a player or players believing they are better than what they are. As for players finishing high up in the assocciation counts and not in their club counts just shows you that the umpires ARE NOT ALWAYS RIGHT. Isnt it a team game?

[NO-MERCY]

What club doesn't have a player or players believing they are better than what they are. As for players finishing high up in the assocciation counts and not in their club counts just shows you that the umpires ARE NOT ALWAYS RIGHT. Isnt it a team game?

Very true "Blackcat"

[THACHY_7]

Smosh West lakes B&F
A grade
Callum Masson B&F
James Cibich runner up

was very surprised when i heard nitchatowski didnt win the b&f to come second in the medal and not finish top 2 at your club is a bit strange, also heard from a few mates there was on bloke in the A grade at smosh who wasnt hapy with how many votes he got, aparently sooked the whole way through the count.

similar story at Para Hills. i was just as surprised when i heard Thach didnt win the b&f or come in the top 2 despit coming 3rd in the medal, i also heard that another player wasnt happy with his finishing position and was sooking throughout the count at finishing 3rd

Jus clearing up that i wasnt the guy that was sooking during the count...
I dont even remember the count, so i cant sook about where i came, cos i didnt even know where i finished

[piccachu]

Jus clearing up that i wasnt the guy that was sooking during the count...
I dont even remember the count, so i cant sook about where i came, cos i didnt even know where i finished

thatchy i wasnt aiming it at you i was talking about a smosh player, and i do believe he came third, and it was not porplycia

[Shirtfront]

A Grade B&F, Rian Hornhardt & Josh Newberry tied.
Travis Muster Runner Up

B grade B&F won by Adam Marotta who also came runner up in the Under 18's, fair effort.

[Scorpion]

What club doesn't have a player or players believing they are better than what they are. As for players finishing high up in the assocciation counts and not in their club counts just shows you that the umpires ARE NOT ALWAYS RIGHT. Isnt it a team game?

Could also mean the people at the club voting are not always right - I have been asked on occasions at a club (even had an opposition once ask me) to cast my 3-2-1, but I have a habit of holding grudges and wont give 3 to someone I think is a knob - so I won't do it. Have also seen many times club vote cards given to guys/chicks that have been drinking all the way through the B's and are expected to cast votes on the A's - or fathers/brothers/cousins etc etc of players who are unabashedly biased....

[RHM 17]

What club doesn't have a player or players believing they are better than what they are. As for players finishing high up in the assocciation counts and not in their club counts just shows you that the umpires ARE NOT ALWAYS RIGHT. Isnt it a team game?

Could also mean the people at the club voting are not always right - I have been asked on occasions at a club (even had an opposition once ask me) to cast my 3-2-1, but I have a habit of holding grudges and wont give 3 to someone I think is a knob - so I won't do it. Have also seen many times club vote cards given to guys/chicks that have been drinking all the way through the B's and are expected to cast votes on the A's - or fathers/brothers/cousins etc etc of players who are unabashedly biased....

Para Hills b & f votes are done by the coach & asst coach and either the runner or team manager does the other card.

[steiger]

Could also mean the people at the club voting are not always right - I have been asked on occasions at a club (even had an opposition once ask me) to cast my 3-2-1, but I have a habit of holding grudges and wont give 3 to someone I think is a knob - so I won't do it. Have also seen many times club vote cards given to guys/chicks that have been drinking all the way through the B's and are expected to cast votes on the A's - or fathers/brothers/cousins etc etc of players who are unabashedly biased....

With my club we have 2 cards voting on a 3,2,1 basis in all grades. One card is done by the Coach with input from his team manager and runner, while the other card is given to any one of 4 or 5 people (spread around over the year). The supporters in this 2nd group are "picked" out by the team manager as experienced people, with no family ties to players to bias their opinion and of a sober nature. Don't think you can do much more. There are not many occasions at all that there is a big anomaly in the 2 cards. Perhaps an exception can be on occasions a coach may give some votes to a backman who does a particularly good job at shutting down a key forward and the supporter doesn't recognise that player as being in top 3 B&F.
If your club is handing out cards to people nilly willy without the above thought process, then they are not doing that job good enough and you can expect strange results.
At least Scorpion admits it and doesn't accept the card.

[Robran]

b lodge voting is done by the senior coach both A grade assistant coaches and the b grade coach the voting system works like this every player is voted on from 1 to 7 in every game 1 is obvisouly no impact on game and 7 being a outstanding game, so i think this way is fair to players that play consistently week in and week out and would think it will be a exciting count on nov 7th.
so 1 no impact or injured early
2 below average
3 average game
4 exceptable game
5 good game
6 very good game
7 outstanding game

believe its something like this anyway...

[steiger]

b lodge voting is done by the senior coach both A grade assistant coaches and the b grade coach the voting system works like this every player is voted on from 1 to 7 in every game 1 is obvisouly no impact on game and 7 being a outstanding game, so i think this way is fair to players that play consistently week in and week out and would think it will be a exciting count on nov 7th.
so 1 no impact or injured early
2 below average
3 average game
4 exceptable game
5 good game
6 very good game
7 outstanding game

believe its something like this anyway...

I like that method Robran

[aceman]

Gepps Cross as follows and voted by the Coach, Assistant Coach and a nominated other person;

5,4,3,2,1 basis which gives a maximum of 15 votes with 45 votes in total available per game.

Since this has been implimented a few years back, most has gone according to the way it has appeared during the season.

[zedman]

Gepps Cross as follows and voted by the Coach, Assistant Coach and a nominated other person;

5,4,3,2,1 basis which gives a maximum of 15 votes with 45 votes in total available per game.

Since this has been implimented a few years back, most has gone according to the way it has appeared during the season.

ditto..unless your coach and assistants are fools you will get the correct result