SAAFL Div 5 & Div 5R (2011)

[LMA]

Totally different. Blokes from the SANFL won't pop in for a game of amateurs on the odd occasion they will be there because they have been omitted from their reserves or U18's team and don't have anywhere to play for that weekend. They will play at a club which they were aligned to prior to going to the SANFL or a club that they have signed with on advice from their league club prior to season proper.

[zedman]

Totally different. Blokes from the SANFL won't pop in for a game of amateurs on the odd occasion they will be there because they have been omitted from their reserves or U18's team and don't have anywhere to play for that weekend. They will play at a club which they were aligned to prior to going to the SANFL or a club that they have signed with on advice from their league club prior to season proper.

exactly..i of course didnt mean just "drop in"..there would obviously have to be a circumstance..and they could play for whoever they wanted to also via a clearance so not necessarily the previously aligned or advised club..you are still most likely playing against a player who WONT play finals..in either example of sanfl or country league..they still both effect the game and outcomes..its the same diff..

[LMA]

Totally different. Blokes from the SANFL won't pop in for a game of amateurs on the odd occasion they will be there because they have been omitted from their reserves or U18's team and don't have anywhere to play for that weekend. They will play at a club which they were aligned to prior to going to the SANFL or a club that they have signed with on advice from their league club prior to season proper.

exactly..i of course didnt mean just "drop in"..there would obviously have to be a circumstance..and they could play for whoever they wanted to also via a clearance so not necessarily the previously aligned or advised club..you are still most likely playing against a player who WONT play finals..in either example of sanfl or country league..they still both effect the game and outcomes..its the same diff..

SANFL clubs rely on feeder leagues such as the SAAFL or Southern League to get players, so it is only natural that if a bloke don't get a game through form or injury they go back to their local club for 1 or more games, without the need for a clearance or permit. This has been happening for probably longer than I have been alive and is an acceptable part of SANFL and Local league affiliation. What happened on the weekend though I just think is a different kettle of fish, but if it's in the rules so be it.

[Catters_4eva]

The thing is though as stated before he kicked goals at crucial times in the game and swung the momentum. He made a huge difference to that team he's a class player and the full back had his hands full. You say another forward would have kicked 4 but how would do u know. Football is so unpredictable he could have been well held by our full back and kicked nothing and we won. It's in the past I'm over it. Let's hope we will get our revenge.. Looking forward to the all important class between Woodville South and West Croyden next weekend. Back home at the cattery, Big game for the Cats

[woodublieve12]

i find it funny that people are complaining bout this... EVERY other club would have done it if possible..

[Mighty Bird]

The thing is though as stated before he kicked goals at crucial times in the game and swung the momentum. He made a huge difference to that team he's a class player and the full back had his hands full. You say another forward would have kicked 4 but how would do u know. Football is so unpredictable he could have been well held by our full back and kicked nothing and we won. It's in the past I'm over it. Let's hope we will get our revenge.. Looking forward to the all important class between Woodville South and West Croyden next weekend. Back home at the cattery, Big game for the Cats

Quite enjoyed all this talk,if stuff like this didn't happen then we would have nothing to talk about would we? Just a quick question for you catters, how can you justify your fullback (number 22) getting 3rd best on ground when a bloke kicks 8.6 on him?? Didn't think you get in the best for effort in senior footy...

Move over Easter and bring back the footy

[LMA]

i find it funny that people are complaining bout this... EVERY other club would have done it if possible..

Desperation

[unknown source]

everybody training tomorrow being a public holiday

big derby game for brahma and westies this week

[woodublieve12]

i find it funny that people are complaining bout this... EVERY other club would have done it if possible..

Desperation

not desperation at all... Reallity...
not saying i agree with it or that i do, just saying the facts

[Neville Bartoss]

one player does not win u a game. I dont hear people on here complaining about losing after losing players to injury during a game and playing with a restricted interchange or missing a club captain. Lutherans had this bloke all year last season and lost quite a few games.....sour grapes imo

[Catters_4eva]

one player does not win u a game. I dont hear people on here complaining about losing after losing players to injury during a game and playing with a restricted interchange or missing a club captain. Lutherans had this bloke all year last season and lost quite a few games.....sour grapes imo

Your right. However, last year that was the club he was connected with and has since moved on probably for the money. If the player wanted to play he should play the whole year if he wants to get a transfer then transfer him and dont let him back.. This guy is registered to another league why let him play in the SAAFL?

[LMA]

i find it funny that people are complaining bout this... EVERY other club would have done it if possible..

Desperation

not desperation at all... Reallity...
not saying i agree with it or that i do, just saying the facts

I must of been living under a rock than for the past 17 years I have played senior football

[catchisthecry]

one player does not win u a game. I dont hear people on here complaining about losing after losing players to injury during a game and playing with a restricted interchange or missing a club captain. Lutherans had this bloke all year last season and lost quite a few games.....sour grapes imo

Your right. However, last year that was the club he was connected with and has since moved on probably for the money. If the player wanted to play he should play the whole year if he wants to get a transfer then transfer him and dont let him back.. This guy is registered to another league why let him play in the SAAFL?

Incorrect catters. Moved due to employment. 8hrs a bit far to play every week, yes?
U lost, get over it!

[Neville Bartoss]

For whatever reason he played and as an opposition u need to deal with the team u r presented with. Possibly woodville south were caught unawares to his quality but they clearly didnt match up well on him. I would have thought the coaching staff would have seen wat was going on and adjusted the team accordingly. He didnt kick too many bags of 8 last year.....

[Catters_4eva]

one player does not win u a game. I dont hear people on here complaining about losing after losing players to injury during a game and playing with a restricted interchange or missing a club captain. Lutherans had this bloke all year last season and lost quite a few games.....sour grapes imo

Your right. However, last year that was the club he was connected with and has since moved on probably for the money. If the player wanted to play he should play the whole year if he wants to get a transfer then transfer him and dont let him back.. This guy is registered to another league why let him play in the SAAFL?

Incorrect catters. Moved due to employment. 8hrs a bit far to play every week, yes?
U lost, get over it!

i am over it. if you read above i was the one that said that we are over it and looking forward to a big game this week. we are over it. THE END!!!

[Demon Juke]

Bring on 100 pages!

[Demon Juke]

Is there a prize Footy Chick if I start the 100 page?

[Demon Juke]

You can give me the prize at training tonight!

[Demon Juke]

Still not on the 100th page yet!

[Demon Juke]

One more entry then i am giving up!!