AdFL Tribunal Listing

[PortPower2018]

Two Reds at the Central United V Salisbury Game

By the umpire that use to play there.

Central United throwing punches behind play

I always thought that there was a rule that an umpire can't make comment about a reportable offence. The Units can't use it as a defence, as it would most probably then be heard as an investigation, but the umpire needs to be sanctioned.

Are you defending a clear strike to the face

[PortPower2018]

By the umpire that use to play there.[/quote]

None of them Umpires have played for us

[BoundaryRider84]

thanks mate - weak as piss move from him deserves everyone of those games hes getting.

No one said he didn’t, and he’s owned his mistake from the start, but thanks for your insight.

That's pretty poor...hope he enjoys his 6 weeks off

[Demon Juke]

Where you at the game as there is no video footage.

[Brodlach]

For those salivating

[The Old Fellow]

By the umpire that use to play there.

Central United throwing punches behind play

I always thought that there was a rule that an umpire can't make comment about a reportable offence. The Units can't use it as a defence, as it would most probably then be heard as an investigation, but the umpire needs to be sanctioned.

Are you defending a clear strike to the face

Where have I ever tried to defend the player? Both the player and the club must know that the player has done wrong (as you say a clear strike) as they accepted the offer. My comment was about the umpire and his so called professionalism.

[PortPower2018]

Where have I ever tried to defend the player? Both the player and the club must know that the player has done wrong (as you say a clear strike) as they accepted the offer. My comment was about the umpire and his so called professionalism.[/quote]


Game was Umpired well I think its wrong to question an Umpires professionalism because of actions of players

[Demon Juke]

Where have I ever tried to defend the player? Both the player and the club must know that the player has done wrong (as you say a clear strike) as they accepted the offer. My comment was about the umpire and his so called professionalism.

Game was Umpired well I think its wrong to question an Umpires professionalism because of actions of players [/quote]

Should never let a umpire the game when he played at that club.

[Reeree35]

Where have I ever tried to defend the player? Both the player and the club must know that the player has done wrong (as you say a clear strike) as they accepted the offer. My comment was about the umpire and his so called professionalism.

Game was Umpired well I think its wrong to question an Umpires professionalism because of actions of players [/quote]



Many factors in to why clubs don’t challenge the league at tribunal. Cost, volunteer fatigue and the risk of getting more games for trying to give your side of the story

[PortPower2018]

Game was Umpired well I think its wrong to question an Umpires professionalism because of actions of players [/quote]

Should never let a umpire the game when he played at that club.[/quote]

Watched the game on dartfish didn't seem like the umpires were favouring any side, your reading to much into it brother

[The Old Fellow]

Where have I ever tried to defend the player? Both the player and the club must know that the player has done wrong (as you say a clear strike) as they accepted the offer. My comment was about the umpire and his so called professionalism.

Game was Umpired well I think its wrong to question an Umpires professionalism because of actions of players [/quote]

Do agree with Demon Duke that explayers should never umpire their previous clubs. My thoughts on the standard of umpiring will not be mentioned, but I am glad your are arms are long enough to pat yourself on the back.

I am questioning the umpire's professionalism for making comments about a report after the game and before any outcome has been achieved. There are rules governing this and the umpire has breached them.

[Lightning McQueen]

I’m trying to decipher who has written what?

[PortPower2018]

I’m trying to decipher who has written what?

You and me both

[MarionPremers2018]

Jerry Jerry Jerry

[Brodlach]

Nothing to report this week

[jo172]

Given the number of people who play each weekend and crackdowns on things like dangerous tackles an extraordinary result for the league to keep a clean sheet over an entire weekend.

Pats on the back all round

[Ezyasfallingdown]

Given the number of people who play each weekend and crackdowns on things like dangerous tackles an extraordinary result for the league to keep a clean sheet over an entire weekend.

Pats on the back all round

=
NEKT MINNIT

[Brodlach]

Given the number of people who play each weekend and crackdowns on things like dangerous tackles an extraordinary result for the league to keep a clean sheet over an entire weekend.

Pats on the back all round

There was a couple of unannounced investigations, but you sentiment is absolutely correct


If you take off dangerous tackles, which in the past probably wouldn’t be all reported, the low number of reports is very good

[whufc]

Given the number of people who play each weekend and crackdowns on things like dangerous tackles an extraordinary result for the league to keep a clean sheet over an entire weekend.

Pats on the back all round

Great result for the league....well done

They've done a great job in recent years.....some may whinge about the game getting soft but imo the league has done by far whats best for the genuine guys who want to go out and 'play' football each week.

[jo172]

Given the number of people who play each weekend and crackdowns on things like dangerous tackles an extraordinary result for the league to keep a clean sheet over an entire weekend.

Pats on the back all round

Great result for the league....well done

They've done a great job in recent years.....some may whinge about the game getting soft but imo the league has done by far whats best for the genuine guys who want to go out and 'play' football each week.

Not just the league as it is, but the Clubs and players. Ultimately clubs and players seem to be largely embracing this mindset rather than having it imposed on them against their will. For everyone's benefit