Carlton

[MW]

Jon Ralph says TDK will be at St Kilda next year.

Jon Ralph says a lot of things.
Reckon his strike rate is worse than most media cretins

think this one might be on the money (pun intended)
insane life changing coin

[amber_fluid]

I’m not a huge betting man but why the hell would you choose the Saints?
One premiership says it all!!

[amber_fluid]

Jon Ralph says TDK will be at St Kilda next year.

Jon Ralph says a lot of things.
Reckon his strike rate is worse than most media cretins

think this one might be on the money (pun intended)
insane life changing coin

You read the contract?
The media just talk utter crap
How would they know?

[wenchbarwer]

Terrible list management call from the Saints if this is true, as silly as Grundy to the Demons a couple of years ago

[Armchair expert]

3 first rounders thank you St Kilda

[MW]

I’m not a huge betting man but why the hell would you choose the Saints?
One premiership says it all!!

Some people put $ over success.

[gadj1976]

I’m not a huge betting man but why the hell would you choose the Saints?
One premiership says it all!!

Money vs premiership success. I know what I'd be looking for ($$$$). Your body could be wrecked after 10 years or so of footy, so why not cash in?

[gadj1976]

Terrible list management call from the Saints if this is true, as silly as Grundy to the Demons a couple of years ago

I agree, you're not winning premierships paying that money for 1 player. Your only hope is to think the salary cap is going to go up exponentially whilst he's there.

[amber_fluid]

I’m not a huge betting man but why the hell would you choose the Saints?
One premiership says it all!!

Money vs premiership success. I know what I'd be looking for ($$$$). Your body could be wrecked after 10 years or so of footy, so why not cash in?

$1m a season is still pretty good coin though and it’s what’s reported we’ve offered him(who really knows though)

He’s got zero chance of success at the Saints though

[wenchbarwer]

I’m not a huge betting man but why the hell would you choose the Saints?
One premiership says it all!!

Money vs premiership success. I know what I'd be looking for ($$$$). Your body could be wrecked after 10 years or so of footy, so why not cash in?

$1m a season is still pretty good coin though and it’s what’s reported we’ve offered him(who really knows though)

He’s got zero chance of success at the Saints though

I spoke with a player manager a few years ago, this was the advice he said he gave to his clients.

An offer from another team in the same state - want to be at least 30% better off than what you'd get if you stayed. From an interstate club, at least 40%. And not to forget, you'll lose at least 40% of the extra money in tax. Not to mention you'd already be settled in your current team, there's no guarantees of that happening at the next club.

[gadj1976]

I’m not a huge betting man but why the hell would you choose the Saints?
One premiership says it all!!

Money vs premiership success. I know what I'd be looking for ($$$$). Your body could be wrecked after 10 years or so of footy, so why not cash in?

$1m a season is still pretty good coin though and it’s what’s reported we’ve offered him(who really knows though)

He’s got zero chance of success at the Saints though

I spoke with a player manager a few years ago, this was the advice he said he gave to his clients.

An offer from another team in the same state - want to be at least 30% better off than what you'd get if you stayed. From an interstate club, at least 40%. And not to forget, you'll lose at least 40% of the extra money in tax. Not to mention you'd already be settled in your current team, there's no guarantees of that happening at the next club.

And If I were Marshall I'd be seeking the exit door if I were him. You'd expect TDK to play 1st ruck and Marshall would become a second string ruckman which I'm sure he wouldn't be happy about. Maybe a swap?

[Brodlach]

St Kilda are closer to a premiership than Carlton

[amber_fluid]

St Kilda are closer to a premiership than Carlton

They were lucky to win the one they did all those years ago

[wenchbarwer]

Marshall is an 80 - 90% game time ruck. So is TDK.

Grundy and Gawn didn't work, neither will this.

[MW]

Marshall is an 80 - 90% game time ruck. So is TDK.

Grundy and Gawn didn't work, neither will this.

Crows looking for a no.1 ruck, Marshall can come to us

[amber_fluid]

TDK is a bloody good forward also so maybe that’s what Saints are thinking?

[wenchbarwer]

TDK is a bloody good forward also so maybe that’s what Saints are thinking?

https://afltables.com/afl/stats/players ... oning.html

30.31 in 83 games doesn't normally scream "bloody good forward". Has kicked 3 in a game once.

[amber_fluid]

TDK is a bloody good forward also so maybe that’s what Saints are thinking?

https://afltables.com/afl/stats/players ... oning.html

30.31 in 83 games doesn't normally scream "bloody good forward". Has kicked 3 in a game once.

Have you seen him when he spends 10 minutes up forward?
Jumps at the ball as good as any current forward there is

We’ll keep him

[gadj1976]

TDK is a bloody good forward also so maybe that’s what Saints are thinking?

Really? I would take King over him any day (as a forward).

[amber_fluid]

TDK is a bloody good forward also so maybe that’s what Saints are thinking?

Really? I would take King over him any day (as a forward).

Plenty of room for 2 key forwards
Though I do wonder why the Saints would throw stupid amounts of coin considering they have Marshall who is a very good ruck