amber_fluid wrote:
We make a good decision but then follow it with a bad one still. I don’t know why we let Durdin go but kept Motlop
I much preferred Durdin when fit
We'll show you why.
If you can keep him fit he’ll be a handy small forward
No superstar but will kick 30-40 goals
There are no stupid questions, just stupid people.
Brodlach wrote:If Tom Campbell and Todd Goldstein are still on a lists this season,Cox deserves to be on one.
Lack of quality back up rucks around currently
Goldy is a fair bit better than Cox, even at this stage of his career. Plus, his coaching of the young blokes puts him head and shoulders ahead of the other two.
amber_fluid wrote:
We make a good decision but then follow it with a bad one still.
I don’t know why we let Durdin go but kept Motlop
I much preferred Durdin when fit
amber_fluid wrote:
We make a good decision but then follow it with a bad one still.
I don’t know why we let Durdin go but kept Motlop
I much preferred Durdin when fit
He wanted to leave too.
I know but if we let everyone go that wants too we may have to forfeit most weeks
I was ok with letting Curnow go due to the compensation we got but we got bugger all for Durdin
Hopefully Motlop and Moir can stand up in 2026 coz we certainly need them both(different players I know)
There are no stupid questions, just stupid people.
amber_fluid wrote:
We make a good decision but then follow it with a bad one still.
I don’t know why we let Durdin go but kept Motlop
I much preferred Durdin when fit
He wanted to leave too.
I know but if we let everyone go that wants too we may have to forfeit most weeks
I was ok with letting Curnow go due to the compensation we got but we got bugger all for Durdin
Hopefully Motlop and Moir can stand up in 2026 coz we certainly need them both(different players I know)
I don't disagree with anything you're saying and I think we should've kept Curnow and played him the two's till he stopped sooking.
Durdin hasn't shown much but then neither has Motlop, although he has been able to venture into the midfield.
wenchbarwer wrote:Port must really rate this draft
In the best year of SA talent for a decade
If you've got top 15 picks, yes. Sharp, Schubert, Marsh and Cumming all top 20 bound where Port didn't have any capital.
Unless we wanted to trade up / in then we're not in that market. We've been very clear about the 2024 draft and then what we aim to gather in 2026 and 2027.
Brodlach wrote:If Tom Campbell and Todd Goldstein are still on a lists this season,Cox deserves to be on one.
Lack of quality back up rucks around currently
Goldy is a fair bit better than Cox, even at this stage of his career. Plus, his coaching of the young blokes puts him head and shoulders ahead of the other two.