Division 5 in 2007!

[The Ash Man]

Angry commissioners last night.
15 games for abusing an umpire?


Chris Marciniak U18 North Haven Striking Guilty 1 game
Mathew Rogan U18 Salisbury North Headbutting Guilty 6 games
Lee Pastyn 1 Henley Striking Guilty 2 games
Christopher Motley 1 Salisbury North Striking Guilty 1 game
Alan Margitich 3 C.B.C.O.C. Striking Guilty 1 game
Stephen Harkin 3 Athelstone Striking Guilty 1 game
James Francisco 6 Hectorville Rough play Not guilty
Chris Rogers 6 Mitchell Park Attempted striking Not guilty
Brett McPherson 7 Wingfield Royals Threatening an umpire Not guilty
Daniel Arch 4R Rosewater Striking Guilty 10 games
Ben Matthews 5R Greenacres Continued abuse towards umpire Guilty 15 games
Stuart Allison 7 Kaurna Eagles Charge withdrawn
Donny Richardson 7 Paralowie Rescheduled for 1/8/07
Jeffrey Wagner 7 Paralowie Rescheduled for 1/8/07

[zedman]

well if he threatened him he got what he deserved..

[The Ash Man]

Im not arguing that at all but the charge was Continued abuse towards umpire
Threatening an umpire is a totally different charge
Maybe someone could shed some light on it?

[zedman]

maybe he followed him to his car etc after game..or rang him up and abused him..who knows..must have been serious tho

[Bluedemon]

probably followed him everywhere he went

[Bully]

Angry commissioners last night.
15 games for abusing an umpire?


Chris Marciniak U18 North Haven Striking Guilty 1 game
Mathew Rogan U18 Salisbury North Headbutting Guilty 6 games
Lee Pastyn 1 Henley Striking Guilty 2 games
Christopher Motley 1 Salisbury North Striking Guilty 1 game
Alan Margitich 3 C.B.C.O.C. Striking Guilty 1 game
Stephen Harkin 3 Athelstone Striking Guilty 1 game
James Francisco 6 Hectorville Rough play Not guilty
Chris Rogers 6 Mitchell Park Attempted striking Not guilty
Brett McPherson 7 Wingfield Royals Threatening an umpire Not guilty
Daniel Arch 4R Rosewater Striking Guilty 10 games
Ben Matthews 5R Greenacres Continued abuse towards umpire Guilty 15 games
Stuart Allison 7 Kaurna Eagles Charge withdrawn
Donny Richardson 7 Paralowie Rescheduled for 1/8/07
Jeffrey Wagner 7 Paralowie Rescheduled for 1/8/07

what about the young fella playing under 18s smithfield that got 6 years or whateva it was?

[bondy]

what about him?

[Bully]

what about him?

nothing just they are talking bout players getting suspended for a few weeks, just mentioned it as 6 years is a long time. hope you guys smash elizabeth this week

[BenchedEagle]

Why do we play our best footy at the wrong times!

Pretty much 0% chance of finals for us and we turn on a performance like yesterday!!!

Footys a funny game.

[Bully]

a week is a long time in footy as they say

[Bluedemon]

hopefully elizabeth play two shockers in the A's and B's this week so kenilworth get 2 wins.

[Pidge]

Nearly all of the Div 5 Reserves umpires are absolutely hopeless and some of them even cheat so much that teams have lost because of their decisions.

[Bully]

hopefully elizabeth play two shockers in the A's and B's this week so kenilworth get 2 wins.

it could very much happen

[BenchedEagle]

Nearly all of the Div 5 Reserves umpires are absolutely hopeless and some of them even cheat so much that teams have lost because of their decisions.

And ur only just realizing this now???

[LaughingKookaburra]

Lol,hear hear duncs.Problem in the A's some weeks aswell.You can't tell me some of those umpires are not biarst.But with out them you do not have a game..........

[Bluedemon]

Nearly all of the Div 5 Reserves umpires are absolutely hopeless and some of them even cheat so much that teams have lost because of their decisions.

And ur only just realizing this now???

where has michael been, unfortunatly to many Div5R umpires favour there team, we have one in 2 weeks time, we play glenunga, he is the biggest cheat of all time.

[BenchedEagle]

Nearly all of the Div 5 Reserves umpires are absolutely hopeless and some of them even cheat so much that teams have lost because of their decisions.

And ur only just realizing this now???

where has michael been, unfortunatly to many Div5R umpires favour there team, we have one in 2 weeks time, we play glenunga, he is the biggest cheat of all time.

I second that. He is a greasy cheat! Never wanted to punch an umpire so bad!

[zedman]

i third it..outright blatant cheat..how does the saafl let him keep umpiring??

[stan]

i third it..outright blatant cheat..how does the saafl let him keep umpiring??

unfortunitly the lack of umpires is a real problem. Plenty will cheat in the reserve grades and well at this stage theres not much that the saafl will do about it. Clubs supplying there own umps is really going hurt the ameture league, and already is.

[Dogwatcher]

I dunno if that's fair.

We have club umpires in local B grade matches in the Riverland and most of them are pretty good. And in fact from my experience, there's less complaints about them then the normal umps.