SAAFL Division 3 2014

[Phantom Gossiper]

is Plympton the first team this year to fail at kicking 40 plus goals on Kilburn ???

Salisbury didn't kick 40 goals on Kilburn either

[S Demon]

I would like to congratulate Kilburn on their endeavour on Saturday.
For a side that cops it every week, they never gave up, right up until the final siren.
The game was played in great spirits, with no trouble what so ever.

is Plympton the first team this year to fail at kicking 40 plus goals on Kilburn ???

Probably the first team to play them in wintery conditions also...

[marbles]

oh big win 51 goals to none anyone notice?

[Jetters]

✈

[Who]

We have reached the halfway point and I thought I would throw out a few questions....

Can we anoint Unley as champions at the halfway mark?

Does Kilburn continue for the remainder of the season now that they have made it to the halfway point?

Are Pembroke a serious threat to Unley this year?

Is Steve Carr the Paul Roos of SAAFL?

Thoughts on umpires?

[Jetters]

We have reached the halfway point and I thought I would throw out a few questions....

Can we anoint Unley as champions at the halfway mark?

Does Kilburn continue for the remainder of the season now that they have made it to the halfway point?

Are Pembroke a serious threat to Unley this year?

Is Steve Carr the Paul Roos of SAAFL?

Thoughts on umpires?

Should the umpires stop giving votes and at the half way mark crown Luke Crocker as the div 3 medalist?

[Pag]

We have reached the halfway point and I thought I would throw out a few questions....

Can we anoint Unley as champions at the halfway mark?

Does Kilburn continue for the remainder of the season now that they have made it to the halfway point?

Are Pembroke a serious threat to Unley this year?

Is Steve Carr the Paul Roos of SAAFL?

Thoughts on umpires?

No.

No.

Yes.

Not quite, but he seems like a good bloke and has the respect of his group.

Had a few good weeks and a couple of shockers. Pass mark from me.

[Bulls forever]

We have reached the halfway point and I thought I would throw out a few questions....

Can we anoint Unley as champions at the halfway mark?
Not yet, they are very impressive, but an injury to White or Wark might just change things.

Does Kilburn continue for the remainder of the season now that they have made it to the halfway point?
Most of us cannot see the point, I even didn't go and watch Modbury on the weekend because the result was a forgone conclusion, but happy I went to Port Reserve, TTG v Portland a good game of footy.

Are Pembroke a serious threat to Unley this year?
Perhaps, big test this week v Modbury, might tell us more.

Is Steve Carr the Paul Roos of SAAFL?
Who

Thoughts on umpires?

I think they have been very good, Modbury person obviously, but even the three games they have lost, I thought the umpiring was fine. I do think too many people expect too much and can't look at the umpiring impartially. Only 1 umpire in 1 game failed to impress me and haven't see Hitler since.

[marbles]

would kilburns agrader be getting paid haha

[Phantom Gossiper]

would kilburns agrader be getting paid haha

Performance based incentives for wins?
At least they are slowing showing signs of improvement, and kicked a few goals on the weekend.

I see they are still working hard to recruit - Peter Woolford is a handy inclusion to the side.

Get through the last 8 rounds and then i'm sure Phil Martin will really ramp up things up to improve for the future.

[Slots It Through]

would kilburns agrader be getting paid haha

Performance based incentives for wins?
At least they are slowing showing signs of improvement, and kicked a few goals on the weekend.

I see they are still working hard to recruit - Peter Woolford is a handy inclusion to the side.

Get through the last 8 rounds and then i'm sure Phil Martin will really ramp up things up to improve for the future.

Watching them on the weekend, they certainly have improved since R1. Jake Morano in the side makes a big difference.

[stealthbomber]

Are Iggies on the slide? To little, too few good players to get them competitive?

[renix40]

What is it with the college teams?
By now every club must have been supplied with their FREE uniforms for club umpires. However, in recent weeks we have played 2 college teams where their club umpires ( boundary and goal ) have been wearing clothing that looks nothing like official uniforms, new or old. This is not the first time that this has happened. Also, during the B grade game on Saturday a guy was running around on the field with a white shirt on, with no markings on it. Turns out he was their runner, and with the amount of time that he spent on the oval each quarter, he probably should have been wearing a Guernsey. At half time he was asked to put on a fluro top and was also queried as to why he needed to spend 17 minutes of 22 on the field. Isn't it a $100 fine for umpires and runners not being correctly attired?

[Footy Chick]

was it reported to the league? if so, I'm sure whatever fine it is punishable by will be handed to them.

[jo172]

I understand it's a rule, but the new umpires uniforms provide for a bit of a clash when teams with dominant white away strips (North Haven, PNU, Salisbury) play away games.

[renix40]

was it reported to the league? if so, I'm sure whatever fine it is punishable by will be handed to them.

We didin't report it to the league, because thats not what we are about.
Just asking a question to see why these teams feel they do not have to follow the rules.

[renix40]

I understand it's a rule, but the new umpires uniforms provide for a bit of a clash when teams with dominant white away strips (North Haven, PNU, Salisbury) play away games.

They were not even wearing the old uniforms, which are to be used in a clash (there was no clash what so ever).
Perhaps they want the uniform changed to a dark blue jumper like they were wearing.

[Mr Beefy]

I understand it's a rule, but the new umpires uniforms provide for a bit of a clash when teams with dominant white away strips (North Haven, PNU, Salisbury) play away games.

If the umpires are informed that one team is wearing white then they will be instructed to wear orange.

[Footy Chick]

yeah, like the umps have serious clash issues with the Heccies home strip so they either have to wear green or white.

[Jetters]

Anyone see the Pembroke v Seaton game?