Adelaide Footy League Division 6 - 2017

[The Bedge]

Brahma Lodge Salisbury West Goldsmith, Shannon Pending 2017-06-27
Kilburn Salisbury West Harradine, Trevor Pending 2017-06-27
Salisbury North Salisbury West Newchurch, Steven Pending 2017-06-27
Smithfield Salisbury West Wanganeen, Tyson Pending 2017-06-27
Kilburn Salisbury West Wills, Donald Approved 2017-06-22 2017-06-23

Are Westies becoming the new North Pines?

[The Bedge]

I expect this week we will see 20+ new players come in to Div 6.

I'm gonna see how accurate this guess is - i suspect you will be very close to the mark!

[beef]

Brahma Lodge Salisbury West Goldsmith, Shannon Pending 2017-06-27
Kilburn Salisbury West Harradine, Trevor Pending 2017-06-27
Salisbury North Salisbury West Newchurch, Steven Pending 2017-06-27
Smithfield Salisbury West Wanganeen, Tyson Pending 2017-06-27
Kilburn Salisbury West Wills, Donald Approved 2017-06-22 2017-06-23

Are Westies becoming the new North Pines?

How old would Shannon Goldsmith be. Seems to have been around for ever. Surely 40+
(If it's the same guy)

[The Informer]

One thing i always wonder, is what is the rule if someone has played first half of the season at a Div 3 or so club and played A grade, and then joins a div 6 club and just plays reserves for say 4 games, does he qualify for finals in the Div 6R team no issue even know he may have played 10 A grade games at another club before being cleared?

[thegrowler]

Surely if Aloisi comes back into the Ammos he needs to test himself at higher than divvy 6 or is he not capable???

I guess if Brahma is cashed up it might be a good fit.

Would be good to see how he travels against a higher quality of opposition.

Surely if Michael McMahon and Kym Edwards wanted to play in SAAFL they would test themselves at higher than divvy 5 or are they not capable?

Yes they will.... next year in Div 4 (please note that like Zartan the pi$$takings on SA footy of the Growler do not reflect the thoughts and feelings of the entire club) Its just that these forums are all about "love ins" these days.

I got a text message that Tim has done an ACL. Sorry to hear that. Hope he recovers well.

[The Bedge]

One thing i always wonder, is what is the rule if someone has played first half of the season at a Div 3 or so club and played A grade, and then joins a div 6 club and just plays reserves for say 4 games, does he qualify for finals in the Div 6R team no issue even know he may have played 10 A grade games at another club before being cleared?

Unfortunately I think that is allowed because the rules only refer to games for member club - so i imagine they'd view it as only 4x games for their member club.

Could be wrong.

[The Informer]

One thing i always wonder, is what is the rule if someone has played first half of the season at a Div 3 or so club and played A grade, and then joins a div 6 club and just plays reserves for say 4 games, does he qualify for finals in the Div 6R team no issue even know he may have played 10 A grade games at another club before being cleared?

Unfortunately I think that is allowed because the rules only refer to games for member club - so i imagine they'd view it as only 4x games for their member club.

Could be wrong.

If it is fine looks like you might have a few down hill skiers to worry about then

[The Bedge]

If it is fine looks like you might have a few down hill skiers to worry about then

I'm expecting it don't worry!

[carey]

Surely if Aloisi comes back into the Ammos he needs to test himself at higher than divvy 6 or is he not capable???

I guess if Brahma is cashed up it might be a good fit.

Would be good to see how he travels against a higher quality of opposition.

Surely if Michael McMahon and Kym Edwards wanted to play in SAAFL they would test themselves at higher than divvy 5 or are they not capable?

Yes they will.... next year in Div 4 (please note that like Zartan the pi$$takings on SA footy of the Growler do not reflect the thoughts and feelings of the entire club) Its just that these forums are all about "love ins" these days.

I got a text message that Tim has done an ACL. Sorry to hear that. Hope he recovers well.

Text message from Tim lol my ass you did.

[The Bedge]

I suspect thegrowler isn't from Glenunga

[Footy Chick]

I suspect thegrowler isn't from Glenunga

Nooooooo... you should be a detective

[Senor Moto Gadili]

Brahma Lodge Salisbury West Goldsmith, Shannon Pending 2017-06-27
Kilburn Salisbury West Harradine, Trevor Pending 2017-06-27
Salisbury North Salisbury West Newchurch, Steven Pending 2017-06-27
Smithfield Salisbury West Wanganeen, Tyson Pending 2017-06-27
Kilburn Salisbury West Wills, Donald Approved 2017-06-22 2017-06-23

Are Westies becoming the new North Pines?

How old would Shannon Goldsmith be. Seems to have been around for ever. Surely 40+
(If it's the same guy)

Would have to be 40+ ....was a seriously good footballer in his prime

[thegrowler]

I suspect thegrowler isn't from Glenunga

Nooooooo... you should be a detective

Footy Chick - Hope Valley
Zartan - United
Carey - Paralowie

I am 100% certain none of you have played a game at any of these clubs this year.

Do I attend Glenunga games. have mates at Glenunga and mentor a player - YES!

Would I pull on the boots if the C's were desperate. Maybe pending work etc but I just couldn't commit to the A grade call up that would be a forgone conclusion once the Growl gets unleashed.

[Footy Chick]

I suspect thegrowler isn't from Glenunga

Nooooooo... you should be a detective

Footy Chick - Hope Valley
Zartan - United
Carey - Paralowie

I am 100% certain none of you have played a game at any of these clubs this year.

Do I attend Glenunga games. have mates at Glenunga and mentor a player - YES!

Would I pull on the boots if the C's were desperate. Maybe pending work etc but I just couldn't commit to the A grade call up that would be a forgone conclusion once the Growl gets unleashed.

haha, not sure about Zartans but you're way off on the other 2 ( well ok, i've never played as such...)

Carey coached Paralowie. He just likes to live in his glory days

[The Informer]

Carey was useless as a coach!

At Paralowie i must say!

[Arch44]

One thing i always wonder, is what is the rule if someone has played first half of the season at a Div 3 or so club and played A grade, and then joins a div 6 club and just plays reserves for say 4 games, does he qualify for finals in the Div 6R team no issue even know he may have played 10 A grade games at another club before being cleared?

Unfortunately I think that is allowed because the rules only refer to games for member club - so i imagine they'd view it as only 4x games for their member club.

Could be wrong.

If it is fine looks like you might have a few down hill skiers to worry about then

Should this be addressed at the end of the year for the future? Front runners

[human_torpedo]

One thing i always wonder, is what is the rule if someone has played first half of the season at a Div 3 or so club and played A grade, and then joins a div 6 club and just plays reserves for say 4 games, does he qualify for finals in the Div 6R team no issue even know he may have played 10 A grade games at another club before being cleared?

Unfortunately I think that is allowed because the rules only refer to games for member club - so i imagine they'd view it as only 4x games for their member club.

Could be wrong.

If it is fine looks like you might have a few down hill skiers to worry about then

Should this be addressed at the end of the year for the future? Front runners

How many div 3 regular A graders will transfer to div 6R in the hope of playing finals?

[The Bedge]

How many div 3 regular A graders will transfer to div 6R in the hope of playing finals?

Wouldn't think many would have it high on their list.
Depends on the person - if they're a fringe A grader or not where they are, and where they're going.

At a guess, Brahma Lodge is the only club that is already high on points and cant really afford anymore in, so may be a case of too many points forcing guys to play B grade (or rather not force them higher). They were at 14 points last week, really no room for Sexton, Sobels, Dawson to come into the mix, unless they plan on dropping one of their 3 point players.. still got McIntyre to return also..

Also hearing on the grape vine Fuller, Nick & Phil Hall, Frawley, Hickey, Mizzi to return only to play B grade also..

Brahma will be very hard to beat.

[cossi11]

How many div 3 regular A graders will transfer to div 6R in the hope of playing finals?

Wouldn't think many would have it high on their list.
Depends on the person - if they're a fringe A grader or not where they are, and where they're going.

At a guess, Brahma Lodge is the only club that is already high on points and cant really afford anymore in, so may be a case of too many points forcing guys to play B grade (or rather not force them higher). They were at 14 points last week, really no room for Sexton, Sobels, Dawson to come into the mix, unless they plan on dropping one of their 3 point players.. still got McIntyre to return also..

Also hearing on the grape vine Fuller, Nick & Phil Hall, Frawley, Hickey, Mizzi to return only to play B grade also..

Brahma will be very hard to beat.

Sobels 0 points and I reckon Dawson 0 points too.. not sure on Sexton (not even sure who that is)

[cossi11]

How many div 3 regular A graders will transfer to div 6R in the hope of playing finals?

Wouldn't think many would have it high on their list.
Depends on the person - if they're a fringe A grader or not where they are, and where they're going.

At a guess, Brahma Lodge is the only club that is already high on points and cant really afford anymore in, so may be a case of too many points forcing guys to play B grade (or rather not force them higher). They were at 14 points last week, really no room for Sexton, Sobels, Dawson to come into the mix, unless they plan on dropping one of their 3 point players.. still got McIntyre to return also..

Also hearing on the grape vine Fuller, Nick & Phil Hall, Frawley, Hickey, Mizzi to return only to play B grade also..

Brahma will be very hard to beat.

Sobels 0 points and I reckon Dawson 0 points too.. not sure on Sexton (not even sure who that is)

Or am I wrong because they are a mid year transfer?
both have played in excess of 25 games at BLFC I think so I thought they would be 0 points