Round 20 - How's the symmetry; how's the serenity!

[Lightning McQueen]

who would want to sit through a hinkley presser, the most boring man in the AFL

Would be a good fit at Sydney then

Could watch a game of soccer using an oval shaped ball then have Kenny give us a rundown on it.

[Wedgie]

Just saw Ross Lyon saying it was 100 metres behind the play. It was about 25 metres away from the play & the ball was actually kicked past where the incident took place so hardly behind the play.

How dare Ross Lyon be a bit emotional and exaggerate where it occurred after seeing an 18yo get his jaw smashed and 4 teeth removed and witnessing the kids mum crying over it. I think the point was it might as well have been 1000 metres behind play as it had nothing to do with the play.

Like most I'm happy to be critical of Lyon for many things but his presser was not one of them.

[woodublieve12]

There was a lot of "no offense but..." about catchphrase Kenny's presser...

Watched the presser?

who would want to sit through a hinkley presser, the most boring man in the AFL

Hold my beer - John Longmire

lies

[amber_fluid]

Here’s another angle to JJ goal

7C7330A4-977E-4ECF-8C3F-58416CB160F4.jpeg (79.11 KiB) Viewed 4152 times

It clearly didn’t hit the post

[cracka]

Just saw Ross Lyon saying it was 100 metres behind the play. It was about 25 metres away from the play & the ball was actually kicked past where the incident took place so hardly behind the play.

How dare Ross Lyon be a bit emotional and exaggerate where it occurred after seeing an 18yo get his jaw smashed and 4 teeth removed and witnessing the kids mum crying over it. I think the point was it might as well have been 1000 metres behind play as it had nothing to do with the play.

Like most I'm happy to be critical of Lyon for many things but his presser was not one of them.

I'm not condoning what happened but I don't think exaggerating incidents is the way to go either.

[Booney]

Terrible for Gaff.

Tribunal has given him 4 years at Carlton.

[amber_fluid]

Terrible for Gaff.

Tribunal has given him 4 years at Carlton.

Troll.

[Brodlach]

#closetbluessupporter

[Corona Man]

Terrible for Gaff.

Tribunal has given him 4 years at Carlton.

Makes you wonder what the Curnow blokes did wrong!

[amber_fluid]

Terrible for Gaff.

Tribunal has given him 4 years at Carlton.

Makes you wonder what the Curnow blokes did wrong!

Ed wouldn’t get a game at any other club anyway.

[Q.]

Crikey, what a mess!

Whateley calling for a 12 game suspension

[bennymacca]

Gerard arguing for 12 weeks for gaff.

his argument was Barry hall got 10 weeks in 2008 (which was reduced to 7 because of an early guilty plea), and in the last 10 years community attitudes have moved significantly with regards to 1 punch attacks in clubs, so it should do the same here.

makes a fair point.

My initial thoughts were 6 weeks, but I can see them going higher

[LMA]

Won't be playing again this year, initially thought 6 but thinking 8 now

[bennymacca]

Won't be playing again this year, initially thought 6 but thinking 8 now

Bugg got 6 recently but that was rated as high impact, this is rated as severe, so yeah I think 8 is likely

[Half Back Flanker]

Think Gaff has just ruined his chances of going to the Demons next year. Big bro wouldn’t be too happy, but neither would be his brother that plays for West Coast.

[Lightning McQueen]

Think Gaff has just ruined his chances of going to the Demons next year. Big bro wouldn’t be too happy!

He had played golf with Andrew (Brayshaw) only 4 days before Sunday.

[whufc]

Think Gaff has just ruined his chances of going to the Demons next year. Big bro wouldn’t be too happy!

They might pick him up as a bargain now.

[tigerpie]

Maybe all the pressure of contract time has got to him and he just had a massive brain fart.
Certainly out of character. Like many I went in at 6 weeks but is that enough?

[whufc]

Maybe all the pressure of contract time has got to him and he just had a massive brain fart.
Certainly out of character. Like many I went in at 6 weeks but is that enough?

If Barry Hall got 7 how many ever years ago i think Gaff has to get more now.

I'm thinking he will get 8 if they take his good record seriously into account. 10 if they want to make a stand and send a message out.

If i'm West Coast management we accept any suspension he gets. Concede it was out of character but cant be tolerated in the game and that we respect the AFL's decision. We will provide him with all the support during the suspension and he is still a required player once the suspension is up.

[MW]

I think he'll still get 6 based on the evidence they will present of his intentions for a hit in the chest area not the head