2020 Retirements and delistings / trade talk

[Q.]

Treloar's deal over the next 3 years is over $1m pa, add Grundy's $1m pa and there has been some severe negligence in their list management.

Unless you are a A+ Elite player then any deal greater than 3 years hardly ever works for the club.

No ruckman should ever be on that coin

[beef]

Treloar's deal over the next 3 years is over $1m pa, add Grundy's $1m pa and there has been some severe negligence in their list management.

Unless you are a A+ Elite player then any deal greater than 3 years hardly ever works for the club.

No ruckman should ever be on that coin

Ruckmen are over rated. Which premiership team recently has had a superstar ruckman. Probably back to Dean Cox in 2006.

[Wedgie]

Treloar's deal over the next 3 years is over $1m pa, add Grundy's $1m pa and there has been some severe negligence in their list management.

Unless you are a A+ Elite player then any deal greater than 3 years hardly ever works for the club.

No ruckman should ever be on that coin

Ruckmen are over rated. Which premiership team recently has had a superstar ruckman. Probably back to Dean Cox in 2006.

Brad Ottens 07, 09 & 11
He was our missing link.

Sydney and West Coast have had some good rucks too!

[Dutchy]

So if Crows/Saints can't come to a trade deal does Crouch have to stay at Crows? Or can he go into the PSD?

[Brodlach]

So if Crows/Saints can't come to a trade deal does Crouch have to stay at Crows? Or can he go into the PSD?

Can go in the PSD where the Crows have pick 1, North would take him at pick 2 I reckon too

[Dutchy]

So if Crows/Saints can't come to a trade deal does Crouch have to stay at Crows? Or can he go into the PSD?

Can go in the PSD where the Crows have pick 1, North would take him at pick 2 I reckon too

OK so he does have options, just a shit position for him if Saints now don't want to trade

[tigerpie]

And im positive Isaac Smith is a poor decision.

You mean taking a 32 year old who has won flags and isn't as hungry for success as he once was is a bad idea?

Smith and the cats have an interesting history as well.
Was it him that missed a set shot after the siren some years back to give the cats a win.

Then sledged the crap out of him.

They do need another line breaker from half back though.
Not sure he's the answer.

[marbles]

And im positive Isaac Smith is a poor decision.

You mean taking a 32 year old who has won flags and isn't as hungry for success as he once was is a bad idea?

Smith and the cats have an interesting history as well.
Was it him that missed a set shot after the siren some years back to give the cats a win.
]

Cant beat em then join them?

[Booney]

So if Crows/Saints can't come to a trade deal does Crouch have to stay at Crows? Or can he go into the PSD?

Can go in the PSD where the Crows have pick 1, North would take him at pick 2 I reckon too

OK so he does have options, just a shit position for him if Saints now don't want to trade

So St Kilda don't want to pay him top dollar or trade for him. Obviously desperate to get him.

[Wedgie]

And im positive Isaac Smith is a poor decision.

You mean taking a 32 year old who has won flags and isn't as hungry for success as he once was is a bad idea?

Smith and the cats have an interesting history as well.
Was it him that missed a set shot after the siren some years back to give the cats a win.

Cant beat em then join them?

Yep. He's said Cats fans would probably like him as he's won a couple of games for us before.

[stan]

"Last week Nathan Buckley had a phone conversation with Adam Treloar. He told him that the senior core of the group didn't want him around anymore. I would find it staggering (if the players wanted him out), he is very popular in that group"

- Sam Edmund

File that one under "Conversations that never took place"

That's becoming a big file these days, the media is absolute tripe at the moment.

[gadj1976]

I got sent an article saying that Carlton had medically assessed Paddy McCartin!

[amber_fluid]

I got sent an article saying that Carlton had medically assessed Paddy McCartin!

Please no.
Hope he gets a 2nd chance somewhere just not with us.

[woodublieve12]

I got sent an article saying that Carlton had medically assessed Paddy McCartin!

Please no.
Hope he gets a 2nd chance somewhere just not with us.

i saw we were keen on him too

[tigerpie]

I got sent an article saying that Carlton had medically assessed Paddy McCartin!

Please no.
Hope he gets a 2nd chance somewhere just not with us.

i saw we were keen on him too

Fittest he's ever been. Skinfolds way down.
Big question mark over concussion is the worry.

Could be a bargain for someone?

[stan]

This is not a good idea for him,he really needs to look after his long term future. Another head knock could be disaster.

[Jim05]

This is not a good idea for him,he really needs to look after his long term future. Another head knock could be disaster.

Yeah, I wouldn’t be taking a punt on him. Very high risk

[Booney]

Port offer pick 26 (now 28) and Essendon reject it. Want a 1st round pick for Fantasia. Port don't have one.

Walk away boys, walk away now.

[Trader]

Port offer pick 26 (now 28) and Essendon reject it. Want a 1st round pick for Fantasia. Port don't have one.

Walk away boys, walk away now.

Agree 100%, I wasn't happy giving up 26, if they don't want to trade lets leave it alone!

[mighty_tiger_79]

Throw the kitchen sink Port...you know you need too

Sent from my SM-A520F using Tapatalk